| Welcome, Guest |
You have to register before you can post on our site.
|
| Online Users |
There are currently 2093 online users. » 5 Member(s) | 2082 Guest(s) Applebot, Baidu, Bing, DuckDuckGo, Google, Yandex, Aga Tentakulus, eggyk, Goldenstern
|
| Latest Threads |
First Ideas by a new user
Forum: Analysis of the text
Last Post: pjburkshire
42 minutes ago
» Replies: 1
» Views: 53
|
The 'Chinese' Theory: Fo...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: Jorge_Stolfi
3 hours ago
» Replies: 1,109
» Views: 454,729
|
f58v Visual Code, Weird S...
Forum: Imagery
Last Post: nablator
6 hours ago
» Replies: 26
» Views: 1,517
|
Old Czech (Bohemian) or M...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: pjburkshire
9 hours ago
» Replies: 80
» Views: 12,380
|
No text, but a visual cod...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: Antonio García Jiménez
10 hours ago
» Replies: 1,961
» Views: 1,637,769
|
One author, working a sea...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: ololololo
10 hours ago
» Replies: 1
» Views: 105
|
Circular text in the Voyn...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: Voynich1234
11 hours ago
» Replies: 20
» Views: 1,945
|
Voynichese is a numeric c...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: ololololo
Yesterday, 11:25 AM
» Replies: 296
» Views: 67,279
|
f57v – Are the empty ring...
Forum: Physical material
Last Post: Jorge_Stolfi
Yesterday, 07:04 AM
» Replies: 13
» Views: 1,232
|
Poll on f116v Voynichese ...
Forum: Marginalia
Last Post: Jorge_Stolfi
21-11-2026, 11:10 PM
» Replies: 7
» Views: 699
|
|
|
| Voynich |
|
Posted by: oceme.alt - 11-10-2026, 11:39 AM - Forum: Voynich Talk
- Replies (2)
|
 |
Hello everyone.
Im completely new at this, just a regular person who stumbled upon the Voynich manuscript scans a little while ago, but looking at the pages, I cant help but feel that brilliant people are overthinking it.
To me, it looks like a practical notebook shared by few medieval guys who used a clever visual shorthand to save expensive things and keep their recipes private.
By just looking at the different handwritings I came up with 4 simple rules that make sense TO ME:
1: The Loop Rule (Herbal): In the plat pages, closed-look letters like "O" "a" "d" arent single letters. They look like symbols for whole lab actions, like writting in circle every time you mean "mix". The open letters with long lines are just the normal letters completing the word.
2: The Mirror Trick (Astrology): The artist who drew the stars (ye, an artist for me) changed the rules to hide his notes. In this section its the exact opposite: the long vertical lines are the main syllables, and the loops are just a single connecting letters. its like flipping a mirror to confuse outsiders. Make sense to me.
3: The Quantity Rule (Recipes): A word repeat three times in a row? For me, this is a medical recipe book (or something like that). If a tired clerk writes a word three times, he isnt crazy, he is just writting quantities without numbers.
4: Ignore Decorations Rule: The one who drew the stars was clearly a showoff. He added extra loops and flares to the letters just to make them look pretty around the diagrams. If you visually erase those fancy adds, the real words become way clearer.
If anyone runs this rules though a script to try and decode it, I bet theyll get a huge surprise
I dont think its a complex mathematical cipher. Its just a 15th century dynamic shorthand that changes depending on wich one was holding the pen that day.
I belive the psychology of the scripters directly influences their encryption style.
Iam zero expert, zero researcher, but this simple logic clicked on my head and want to share it.
I hope this helps in some way
|
|
|
| Proposed Manuscript Chronology |
|
Posted by: npcompl33t - 11-10-2026, 02:53 AM - Forum: Theories & Solutions
- Replies (77)
|
 |
I just shared an updated version of some page classifications I have been working on. You can read You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. or view You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. for more information on how these are generated. You can explore the data for this sequence specifcally on You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.
Briefly: - I create a glyph level transition matrix for each page, both for individual words, and the entire line (removing spaces). I then combine these together.
- I then calculate the pairwise Jensen-Shannon Divergence between each page.
- This matrix is viewable on the web app, as a cluster-map.
For this theory, the actual clusters themselves are irrelevant. Instead, we just look at the MDS ( MDS is essentially PCA over this pairwise distance matrix). The graph of the 2 most significant dimensions produces a similar shape to the PCA bigram charts that have been shared on this forum before.
The Guttman Effect
Note, the distinct 'horseshoe' shape. In the above chart
This is what is known as a Guttman horseshoe. It is a You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.that can happen with both PCA and MDS. This occurs in very specific conditions, when a sequential trend moves across some type of environmental gradient. An example is like this: if you walk two blocks north, then turn and walk 2 blocks east, you have walked 4 blocks. Yet the actual distance will be 2.83. PCA cannot recover the full distance because it attempts to fit a straight line, and one straight line cannot capture the full 4 block distance.
The most common way to check is to look at the 3rd dimension compared to the first. This 3rd dimension will normally have an S shape, but it can manifest more complex shapes depending on the dimensionality of the underlying curve. Notably, it can have a 4 factor polynomial curve, which resembles a W or M.
Lets look at this for our data:
The Bifolio Agreement
So how does this relate to manuscript chronology? Well, once you have identified a guttman horeshoe, you can correct it by applying a polynomial curve to reproduce the full nonlinear gradient. This is what that looks like:
Its immediately apparent this achieves very strong split by sections across the manuscript. The curve also splits currier A and B cleanly.
However, where this gets really interesting is when we compare the average variation of pages in the same bifolio along this curve. The 1st MDS dimension already almost perfectly orders pages by bifolio. Pages on the same bifolio's average variation on the first MDS dimension is just 2.5%, and this drops to an even lower 1.5% when applying the curve. Compare that to an average of 15-50% difference across the other MDS dimensions.
How does this connect to chronology?
Think for a second about what this is saying.
- The fact that pages within a bifolio have < 2% divergence across this entire sequence, shows this is measuring some production level feature
- It also forms a smooth continuous gradient across all bifolio in the manuscript.
- It is not correlated to LFD hand.
- What feature could possibly be represented by a smooth continuous gradient between production units?
The most obvious answer is time, and in fact, time is one of the classic known drivers of a Guttman Horseshoe. For example, Flinders Petrie ordered Egyptian graves in time by their pottery styles around 1900, and in the 1970s David Kendall showed that MDS on such data produces a horseshoe whose order along the curve is the chronological order.
Therefore this pattern is not only consistent with chronology, chronology is one of the known major drivers. This, combined with the fact that the sequence has < 2% divergence along known production units, strongly suggests this is the actual chronology of the manuscript.
What is the chronology?
Note the ordering of some points can be sensitive to the exact curve being drawn. The relative ordering in between sequences is fairly reliable, but groups should be interpreted as production batches, not as an exact ordering sequence.
- D25-32 is a strong candidate for the first created bifolio. It is the first in both the word level and word+line level reconstruction, and it appears 1st in 49 attempted leave-one-pool out refits.
- 2 distinct but separate production batches then produced 2 sections of early Herbal A. The exact ordering depends on the polynomial degree used, as either work, but 1a is a slightly better fit.
- A transition Herbal A section bridges the 2nd Herbal A batch with Pharma
- Several Cosmo, along with f58 came next
- Herbal B came after this, followed immediately by half of stars
- Bio follows The first stars half. The final page varies in different curves.
- T08-111 is a strong candidate for the final page of the MS. Layfield and Davis order this 2nd to last. It appears last in 46/50 leave one pool out refits.
This shows that Herbal B was likely created after both pharma and cosmo, yet was re-ordered and interspersed within Herbal A sometime before quire numbers were added. It also implies that Stars was created in two distinct productions, before and after bio.
What else can be derived from this?
It strongly suggests that several features known to be associated with Currier A vs B splits are actually shifts in the way voynich was written, and that the entire sequence contains several such significant shifts. It is exactly this type of stepwise process that would result in a Guttman horseshoe. The next step would be to incorporate these known statistical properties alongside this chronology, to show how the voynich language appeared over time.
Links:
|
|
|
| Tolkien Analogy Theory |
|
Posted by: Soph007 - 11-10-2026, 12:09 AM - Forum: Theories & Solutions
- Replies (1)
|
 |
A thought experiment: What if the Voynich Manuscript were something like Tolkiens Works, but without any surviving context?
Imagine discovering a book written entirely in an invented language, accompanied by illustrations of unfamiliar but similar plants, rituals and cosmological systems. With no translations, explanations or other writings to provide context. Like the silmarillion written in one of tolkiens invented languages and artwork for said book found houndreds of years from now.
Would we necessarily recognise it as a fictional world or would we assume it was an encoded account of our own world/hostory?
Could the Voynich Manuscript be a constructed symbolic or fictional knowledge system blending real medieval knowledge with imagined elements?
I’m curious wether this possibility has been seriously explored in Voynich research ?
|
|
|
Cost to produce the Voynich manuscript |
|
Posted by: Sephardi_Genius - 09-10-2026, 09:40 PM - Forum: Voynich Talk
- Replies (15)
|
 |
Hi everyone, new user, got interested in the Voynich manuscript recently as a result of watching Koen's Youtube videos 
I was wondering if anyone could point me to a source on the price of vellum in late medieval Central Europe? I have oscillated my thoughts on whether the manuscript is an authentic piece of writing or a hoax designed to be sold as an esoteric/mysterious text, and one of the things that I have been thinking about is the cost to manufacture it. We have about 240 surviving pages, but it was probably closer to ~270, and it was written on vellum with colored inks and includes the hands of multiple people, with many sources I can find online saying five people. Needless to say, assuming it was designed to be sold as a bit of fakery, this seems like a lot of work even if you assume everybody that was working on it was doing it for free.
Obviously we know that Rudolf II bought it for 600 ducats, which is an insane amount of money for a book, but that's at least 150 years after it was likely made, and I'm curious about what it likely would've cost the authors to make in the first place. My thinking is that if it had been made up by a group of broke university students or someone else looking to made a quick buck by copying a bunch of stuff that looks like a book (or a bunch of books) they'd seen earlier, they either wouldn't have had enough money to make it in the first place, or wouldn't have needed the money they could get by selling it, especially given how much you time and effort it must've cost to write all this stuff down in a way that it somewhat resembles a natural language or cipher. Anyways, thanks for the help, and I hope I haven't bothered your community with my silly question too much
|
|
|
| f86v3 - The birds and the.. spices? |
|
Posted by: Bluetoes101 - 09-10-2026, 09:17 PM - Forum: Imagery
- Replies (4)
|
 |
There's a few common tales eastern spice merchants would tell westerners in regards to where spice came from.
Much of it is also probably just from a couple of influential names from antiquity saying stuff and it being repeated forever.
In the case of cinnamon "forever" ended around 1505 when a Portuguese ship was chasing a spice merchants ship,
got lost and found themselves on the shores of Sri Lanka (as a story goes), from there they figured it out and took over.
Whether tastes just changed, or cinnamon lost its mystique, this marked a point where the popularity of cinnamon in Europe
would start on a downward trajectory. Maybe it just didn't taste as good when it wasn't harvested from the nest of the legendary "Cinnamologus"!
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.
Please read the above for a comprihensive overview, but the "TLDR" (Too Lazy Didn't Read) is as follows.
It is worth noting I have read several conflicting things about what Pliny the Elder said, but I'm going to stick to this source.
- Herodotus. Great birds take the sticks (cinnamon) to nests built of mud on the mountain crags. Men left large bits of meat for them,
once back in the nest the weight would break it, once at the bottom men would take the cinnamon.
- Aristotle. The cinnamon bird makes a nest of cinnamon (both things from an unknown place) in very tall trees. The natives dip arrow heads
in iron which destroy the nest, then they can pick up the cinnamon.
- Pliny the Elder. Agrees with Aristotle but now gives it a name "a bird called Cinnamologus".
- Aelianus. "Cinnamologus" is now "Cinnamomus" and the story becomes a mix - The bird fetches twigs from the ends of the earth. And builds
a nest among sheer crags (the tree is gone). People shoot heavy arrows from a bow strained to its utmost, this shatters them and they fall down.
- Gaius Julius Solinus. Cinnamologus (we are back to this now) weaves a nest from cinnamon fruits ( ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ ). People shoot leaden darts at the nest.
- Isidore of Seville. Cinnamologus makes a nest in tall trees. People use lead-weighted missiles to dislodge the nest.
Jumping from 7CE to 13CE
- Thomas of Cantimpré. Cynamologus builds nest in the highest trees. People shoot it with leaded arrows to drop down Cinnamon.
So what the manuscripts of the middle ages show is people shooting down the nest from a tree with arrows, presumably from a bow. Right?
That would be too easy!
The slingshot does seem to be quite a popular adaptation, however there are many variations that achieve the same message overall.
The mountain crag/cliff part of the story seems to not be as popular. At least I haven't found examples.
Personally I had taken the VMS images to show mountain/cliff - However Rene notes "The two at the bottom are a bit larger and appear to have some elements of flowers." You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.
If you look at the examples above and the ones here You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view., you will note many of the trees are more "plant-like" than "tree-like".. but either way, I think its safe to say the VMS drawing is ambiguous and mountain/big plant.. things, might be in the ballpark.
Reading the image counter clock-wise,
Person (seems like a man) with a round thing in hand, on cliff/plant.. thing
I flipped this image just to show the hand better
Person (seems like a man) with movement lines shooting up from hand (throwing/shooting/projectile..ing?)
Bird seemingly on a nest (Speculatively, I have wondered if the circles with lines coming down to nest are balls hitting it)
Bird is flying/falling, a bunch of stuff falls down, so far that it goes through the text.
Might I have a story of the Cinnamologus?
On researching the fancy containers starting on You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. my feeling currently is that they are containers for spice, and other valuable ingredients. They also appear in the middle of the ROS (the other side of f86v3). If my hunch is right, a story about the origins of Cinnamon planted in the middle doesn't seem out of place.
Sorry for a wall of text, hopefully it wasn't too boring. I'd like to hear what you think.
|
|
|
| eva-m on f3/f6 |
|
Posted by: Skoove - 07-10-2026, 09:19 AM - Forum: Analysis of the text
- Replies (2)
|
 |
I have been trying to think about eva-m a lot recently and I realised that almost all of the instances of this letter within Herbal A is on the one singulion which is f3/f6 (as per Lisa's analysis).
I'm not sure if this helps us figure out what this glyph actually is but it almost looks the scribe was testing it out or had some other reason to use it over and over again specifically here.
Also of interest is that it is used non line-final in multiple places in these pages.
For those who don't believe that 'm' is an line-final positional glyph (i.e. it doesn't encode for any information) or those who don't believe it to be an abbreviation for 'iin' what other theories are out there (that don't just say that it is meaningless)?
|
|
|
|