Welcome, Guest
You have to register before you can post on our site.

Username/Email:
  

Password
  





Search Forums

(Advanced Search)

Online Users
There are currently 2093 online users.
» 5 Member(s) | 2082 Guest(s)
Applebot, Baidu, Bing, DuckDuckGo, Google, Yandex, Aga Tentakulus, eggyk, Goldenstern

Latest Threads
First Ideas by a new user
Forum: Analysis of the text
Last Post: pjburkshire
42 minutes ago
» Replies: 1
» Views: 53
The 'Chinese' Theory: Fo...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: Jorge_Stolfi
3 hours ago
» Replies: 1,109
» Views: 454,729
f58v Visual Code, Weird S...
Forum: Imagery
Last Post: nablator
6 hours ago
» Replies: 26
» Views: 1,517
Old Czech (Bohemian) or M...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: pjburkshire
9 hours ago
» Replies: 80
» Views: 12,380
No text, but a visual cod...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: Antonio García Jiménez
10 hours ago
» Replies: 1,961
» Views: 1,637,769
One author, working a sea...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: ololololo
10 hours ago
» Replies: 1
» Views: 105
Circular text in the Voyn...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: Voynich1234
11 hours ago
» Replies: 20
» Views: 1,945
Voynichese is a numeric c...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: ololololo
Yesterday, 11:25 AM
» Replies: 296
» Views: 67,279
f57v – Are the empty ring...
Forum: Physical material
Last Post: Jorge_Stolfi
Yesterday, 07:04 AM
» Replies: 13
» Views: 1,232
Poll on f116v Voynichese ...
Forum: Marginalia
Last Post: Jorge_Stolfi
21-11-2026, 11:10 PM
» Replies: 7
» Views: 699

 
  Writing a fake Voynich by rules: copies, habits and the link between words
Posted by: quimqu - 18-10-2026, 10:34 PM - Forum: Analysis of the text - Replies (84)

@nablator asked me to explain the generator I mentioned, so here it is. Sorry, it got a bit long...

What it is

I call it "the scribe". It's a small program that writes a complete fake Voynich: same pages, same sheets, same paragraphs, same number of lines and words per line, same gaps for the drawings, Currier A and B, the five Davis hands. There is no meaning anywhere in it. It only follows writing rules that I measured first on the real text (ZL3b).

Why I did it

For months I collected rules about how the text is written. At some point you have to check if they are right, and the best way I found is this: if the rules are good, someone who follows them blindly should write a text you can't tell apart from the real one, at least in everything we know how to measure. If the fake text fails somewhere, a rule is missing or wrong.

How it writes

First it picks the habits of the sheet. Every sheet (the folded piece of vellum, four pages) has its own taste for some free choices: k or t, ch or sh, putting q in front or not, ending in dy or in y, and using words with e or without. The pages of the same sheet look alike in this, and inside a page it drifts a little from line to line.

Then, word by word, it decides to copy or to write something new.

About a third of the time (35%) it copies a word that is already on the page. It prefers the words close by, the chance halves every three lines or so, and it likes the word just above. In almost half of the copies it changes one letter, so qokedy can come back as qokeedy or okedy. One thing I learned the hard way: that change has to be something the hand would write anyway. More on that below.

The rest of the time it writes a new word letter by letter, and to choose the next letter it only looks at the two before. That is enough to keep the words in shape. They follow a sort of template: maybe a start (q, o, d, s or y), then a gallows or a bench, sometimes some e, and an ending. Words with e end in y or dy (qokedy, chedy) and words without e end in aiin, ar, ol (qokaiin, dar). It never puts two gallows in one word and never mixes e and i.

How a word starts depends on how the previous one ended. After a word in y, a word whose core starts with o usually gets q (shedy qokedy). A core starting with a gets d (daiin).

Then the line. The first word of a line likes to start with d, s or y, and avoids the same first letter as the line above (with ch it always avoids it, with s almost never). The last word gets "closed": daiin becomes dam, chol becomes choly, chor becomes chory. It does this more or less strongly depending on the hand.

And the paragraph. It starts with a gallows, the first line uses p and f instead of k and t, and the first line almost never copies.

That's it. It's seven steps, but some of the tables behind them are big, and they are learned from the text, so it's not a ten line rulebook.

How it looks

Real f78r, first lines:

Code:
tshedor shedy qopchedy qokedy dyqokol oky qokeedy qokedy shedy tchedy otar olkedy dam qckhedy cheky dol chedy qokedy qokain olkedy yteedy qotal dolshedy qokedar chcthey otor dor or

The scribe, same layout:

Code:
qokod chol qokeey chedy qopar otom o ral ydain shedy qody chody chals qokedy qotedy qokedy qokeey qolal shedytedy ytam tchdy shor qokeey qokaiinsh qokedy shedy qokaiin qoted

You can still spot some bad words in it, like shedytedy or qokaiinsh (two word endings glued together). I'll come back to that.

The measures

To compare the fake text with the real one I use 64 measures. Each one is a number you can compute on both texts the same way. Some examples, real value first and the scribe second:

How often a word is repeated right after itself, compared with what chance would give: 3.1 times chance in the real text, 3.3 in the scribe.

How many words have a "twin" earlier on the same page, the same word or one letter different: 64% real, 68% scribe. The nearest twin is usually two lines up in both.

How often the last word of a line ends in m: 15.9% real, 16.7% scribe. Closed endings in general at the end of a line: 27.1% and 27.3%, against about 2% inside the line.

How often a paragraph starts with a gallows: 93% and 92%. How many gallows in the first line are p or f: 31% and 31%, against less than 3% in the other lines.

How much the pages differ from each other in their habits, for example in putting q after y. If every page was the same this number would be about 1. Real 6.3, scribe 5.7.

The link between the end of a word and the start of the next (more below).

And an "eye test": how many words have a piece of three letters that appears 3 times or less in the whole real text. Those are the words that look wrong when you read them. Real 4.6%, scribe 4.1%.

A measure counts as reproduced if the scribe is within 25% of the real value, average of 5 runs.

What comes out

The scribe reproduces 58 of the 64 measures.

For comparison, a simple generator with three rules that I made before gets 33 of 64. So the rules definately make the difference, it's not that any generator gets there.

The test I like most: I let the scribe learn its tables only from the odd folios, and then write the even folios, wich it has never seen, and compare with the real even folios. It gets 51 of 64. That number alone doesn't say much untill you see this: the real odd folios against the real even folios match on only 55 of 64, because some measures change a lot from one part of the book to another. So 51 should be read against 55, not against 64. It means the rules describe how the text is made, they don't just memorize it.

And if I take out any single rule, measures go wrong. Without the copying, all the repetition measures fail. Without the habit of the first line, p and f dissapear from the first lines. Every piece is needed.

The 6 tests it fails

Exact repeats. A word written twice in a row is 0.9% of the word pairs in the real text and 1.2% in the scribe. Compared with chance it's fine (3.1 against 3.3 times chance), but in raw numbers it repeats a little too much.

Repeats at distance 5, the same word coming back five words later: 2.9 times chance in the real text, 3.8 in the scribe.

Words that avoid repeating. In the real text 16% of the common words almost never come right after themselves (dal, shey, saiin), while okaiin does it five times more than chance. The scribe has 21%. It only knows families of words, not single words.

The m at the end of long lines. Real lines of 10 words or more end in m 3.4 times more often than lines of 1 to 4 words. The scribe only gets 1.9 times.

q at the start of a paragraph: 4.2% real, 6.2% scribe. The numbers are small here, it's just over the limit.

Long words, 8 letters or more: 5.3% real, 7.4% scribe. Some of them are the two endings glued together you saw in the example (shedytedy, qokaiinsh).

Why I think it's interesting

The recent Harvard paper (Schwartz) says that no generator so far, theirs included, reproduces one thing: the link between the end of one word and the start of the next. They leave it as one of the few things unexplained.

In the scribe that link is just the habit I described above: the start of a word depends on how the previous one ended, and on nothing else from it. Not the whole word, not the word before, not the position in the line. Even the last pen stroke alone carries most of it, so it looks like a thing of the hand and not of grammar. Measured roughly the way the paper does, the real text gives 0.115 bits for hand 1 and 0.224 for hand 2 (the paper says 0.12 and 0.21). With the habit, the scribe gives about the same strength (after removing what a shuffled text would give: 0.097 against 0.089 for hand 1, and 0.171 against 0.205 for hand 2). Without the habit it falls to almost zero.

Two things I didn't expect

No dictionary needed. An earlier version made too many wrong looking words. Almost all came from the copies with a changed letter, because the change was random (daiin became daain, chedy became chddy). Giving it a list of real words fixed the look but killed the variety. What worked was making the change follow the same two letter rule as new words. Wrong looking words went from 8.7% to 4.1%, real is 4.6%.

The kind of word follows the sheet, not the plant. Words with e (qokedy, shedy) against words without (qokaiin, dar, ol): their share is shared by the pages of the same sheet, even with the other half of the sheet that sits far away in the book, and not with the next page if it belongs to another sheet. In the herbal, where every page has a different plant, the other half of the sheet matches at z = -7.0 and the next page at -0.7. So it behaves like the habit of the day it was written, not like the subject.

What it doesn't show

It doesn't prove the Voynich has no meaning. It shows that a procedure with no meaning is enough for most of what we can measure.

And the tables are learned from the text, so it says how the pieces combine, not where the letter rules come from.

Any questions, I'll be happy to reply.

Print this item

  Boticelli - Venus and Mars on f66r?
Posted by: JustAnotherTheory - 17-10-2026, 07:31 AM - Forum: Imagery - No Replies

Look at this painting by Sandro Boticelli, at the end of the 15th century:

   

It's called "Venus and Mars".

Now look at VMS folio 66r, on the bottom of the page:

   

The annotations next to the person are also strangely reminiscent of the words "Venus" and "Mars":

   

Print this item

  [split] Does Voynichese evolve from A to B?
Posted by: Jorge_Stolfi - 17-10-2026, 05:16 AM - Forum: Analysis of the text - Replies (50)

MODERATOR NOTE - Posts 1 to 23 were originally part of the You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. and were moved to be their own thread]

(16-10-2026, 11:36 PM)pfeaster wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.From the standpoint of potential parallels with Voynichese, I'm particularly interested in their finding that the writer of the Rohonc Codex seems to have been working out the details of his writing system as he went along, with rules that evolved over time.
But I don't get that impression from Voynichese.  Yes there are differences between sections, but since we have no independent  way of determining the order of writing or the internal structure, we cannot tell whether they are the result of the Author gradually evolving the language/script/encryption, as in the Rohonc Codex, or just determined by different topics/structure/style, possibly with one discrete but relatively modest "spelling reform" at some point.

(And yes, @npcompl33t claims otherwise.  We are still fighting over that.)

By the way, the style of the nymphs tells me that Zodiac was drawn before Bio.  And that Aries and Taurus were drawn before Pisces and the rest of Zodiac.  

And the way some Pharma sketches were badly copied and expanded in Herbal tells me that Pharma is earlier than Herbal.

Also the bifolios of the Starred Parags section may have been scrambled and/or flipped over, but pages You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. and You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. were written last. (But, as I discuss in another thread, You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. was all but completely erased by a water spill and wrongly "restored" by a later owner.)

All the best, --stolfi

Print this item

  Chronological Path Stability/Uncertainty Analysis
Posted by: npcompl33t - 16-10-2026, 10:19 PM - Forum: Analysis of the text - Replies (43)

This is a follow-up analysis to my You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. All of the code for this work can be found in the You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view..



Problem / Goal



The goal of this analysis was to answer "how uncertain / unstable are points on the proposed chronology". In particular, some follow-up analysis I have been conducting shows high sensitivity around the inclusion of f58, suggesting the placement of the missing H quire could change the ordering.

The core problem is, when tracing a path, the ends of the path have the least certainty. This is because points in the middle of the path have preceding and following points, which also have preceding / following points. These multiple overlapping observations provide much more certainty about the ordering. 

However, points on the end do not have this. By definition, the first and final points would only have either a preceding or following connection. Depending on the direction and amount of movement, this can create uncertainty around which group is the first or last.

f58 and the missing H bifolio add this same uncertainty in the middle of the manuscript. We are missing part of the path, which creates additional uncertainty, specifically in the Herbal B ordering.



Method



I tested the ordering stability using both 207 individual pages and 50 pooled bifolia, holding the transition-distance/MDS representation fixed. 

I utilized the ensemble procedure described in You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.  which involves fitting curves to 100 random approximately 90% subsets, using eight starting routes and two regularization settings. A whole-bifolium sampling control brought the total to 4,800 fits.I then compared recurring positions, order reversals and competing routes’ scores within each sample. 

I ran You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. to attempt to identify any discontinuous regions along the gradient.

To establish toe potential impact of the missing pages, and the creation of the the H-position MDS charts below, I used the You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view., applied derivative-based continuation at λ=.01, checking assignment changes and different movement paths.


A You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. of exactly how each methodology was applied can be found on the voynich-clusters web page. All code is You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.



Results



Instability Across the Gradient

The chart below shows the variance in the ordering of the individual pages based on different ensemble simulations described in ElPiGraph's paper. This shows where across the 4,800 different fit variants each page and bifolia fell. This allows us to determine how sensitive the positioning is to different starting conditions, assumptions, and modeling parameters. Darker regions indicate more variants placed the page in that area.

   

Observations from the chart:
  • the ordering with respect to 1a and 1b is ambiguous, however 1a pages generally exhibit a slight initial ordering preference over 1b
  • 1.5a and 2a's placements are generally stable. 
  • f58, astro and cosmo are generally stable as a group. The only exception is Rosettes, which is the single isolated band not with the others in 5a, on the page level chart. It clearly was not made at the same time as the other 5a group, probably instead being produced alongside the Herbal B sections, but possibly even being made as late as stars 3c.
  • Herbal 3a and 3b's ordering is not stable, and will be discussed below in the next section. 
  • At the bifolium level Stars 3c is generally stable, with f85r1 and r2 (the two unassigned bars ) also having the strongest preference for the same timing.
  • Bio / Stars 4c are more ambiguous, with fits generally preferring the ordering Stars 4c-> Bio



Checking for discontinuity 

scEGRET is a method described by Zheng et al that applies directly to our problem. It is a toolkit designed to follow paths and identify discontinuous regions, allowing us to more firmly establish if we are missing any sections of the overall curve. The code is freely available on the authors github.

The general idea is this, along a well sampled progression, successive groups should generally change gradually. An unusually large change indicates the trajectory crosses a gap, for example, because intermediate data is missing. 


scEGRET identifies no fully discontinuous regions across the gradient. Note, this does not mean certain areas along the curve are not missing pages. It simply means scEGRET was unable to detect one. 


F58 does show a modest local signal. The scEGRET scores measuring relative change jump from .184 to .271, around a 1.5x increase. Calibration places this within the 95% confidence region. Removing f58 along with adjacent astro material entirely does produce discontinuity flags, but it depends on certain model settings and is therefore not conclusive.

So there appears to be no obvious gaps in the gradient, f58's region appears suspicious but is not enough to claim the region is discontinuous. 



Impact of Missing Quire H on Herbal B

The chart below shows the impact the missing Quire H bifolia could have on the ordering of Herbal B's 3a/3b sections. 
  • This is using the same MDS dimensions as the plots in the previous chronology theory, 
  • The star shows the current placement of f58, the only remaining portion of quire H. 
  • The colors indicate which ordering of 3a and 3b is preferred, based on where the missing pages of quire H would shift the current Quire H centroid on the MDS dimensions
  • Red regions mean if the missing pages shift the centroid there, the preferred ordering is 3a->3b. If the missing bifolia instead shift the centroid into the blue regions, then the preferred ordering is 3b->3a. 
  • The black line divides the frontier between these regions


   

You can see the current f58 placement is almost directly on this red/blue frontier. This means without those missing pages, it is probably not possible to say for certain which Herbal B group comes first, because any slight changes from the current f58 point could alter the ordering.



Conclusion



The overall gradient is clear, but how confident we can be around the relative ordering of certain sections along that gradient varies. The  largest uncertainty is:
  • The ordering of Early Herbal A sections 1a and 1b, although 1a is generally preferred as the starting point
  • The ordering of 3a and 3b, basically indeterminant without the missing Quire H
  • The ordering of 4c and 4a / Stars-T and Bio is indeterminant, although bio is generally preferred as the endpoint.

Print this item

  "Curse" or Bird Mirror?
Posted by: Bluetoes101 - 15-10-2026, 06:31 PM - Forum: Voynich Talk - Replies (18)

When a social bird person is kept in isolation, providing a mirror mysterious manuscript can trigger a severe psychological phenomenon known as the "mirror trap.". Because most pet bird species people fail the mirror self-recognition test, they do not understand that the reflection is their own body mind. Instead, they perceive the reflection as a completely different, real bird solution.

In isolation, this illusion fills a desperate biological need for a flock friend, but it quickly spirals into a damaging, one-sided obsession.

The bird person becomes trapped in a loop of trying to get a reaction from a "stranger" that never vocalises back or moves independently.
This causes chronic anxiety, depression, and severe mental fatigue.

The bird person may begin violently guarding the mirror mysterious manuscript, treating its human owners peers or other toys people as hostile intruders. They will viciously bite or scream if anyone approaches their "friend".

Parrots People will often stop eating, grooming themselves, or playing with stimulating toys communicating with other people because they refuse to leave the side of the mirror mysterious manuscript.

Print this item

  Could it be that this represents a system for generating music?
Posted by: Maruyama Toru - 15-10-2026, 05:37 PM - Forum: Theories & Solutions - Replies (103)

Hello, everyone.

I would like to share a new hypothesis based on my own research and a visual analysis of the illustrations found in the manuscript.

My hypothesis is that the Voynich Manuscript may visualize concepts and mechanisms for generating something new.

This may relate to counterpoint, not merely as the combination of independent melodies, but as a process in which motifs are transformed, connected, and developed into new musical material.

The plant illustrations, for example, may represent the combination of different elements to generate new motifs. This is a possibility worth exploring.

I have posted further details and an outline of the underlying theory on my website.

You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.

I would greatly appreciate any constructive feedback, opinions, or even critical perspectives you might have regarding this musical interpretation.
Thank you!

Print this item

  Voynich words evolve over a linear sequence
Posted by: npcompl33t - 13-10-2026, 06:35 PM - Forum: Theories & Solutions - Replies (38)

For the last several weeks, I have been working on an attempt to 'translate' Herbal A to Herbal B. This turned up many probable transformations that turn words from Herbal A into Herbal B, preserving frequencies, but many of these transformations only worked between two sections, never collectively across the entire manuscript.

You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view., I laid out a hypothesis and evidence for a Voynich chronology, showing that Voynich word construction shows drift that is equivalent to stepwise evolutions, that sometimes undo previous results. The methods I used are identical to those used to reconstruct the chronology of Egyptian tombs, by modeling changing pot styles. 

If i apply this to my rule/transformation work, and instead of modeling rules that must be true across the entire manuscript, model them as stepwise transitions between each stage, everything falls into place. Frequencies all mostly align between sections, and once large gaps become a series of gradual transitions.

Note that the transformations below are not the result of manually linking individual words. I define a series of transformations that must apply to all words. For example, *ol -> *eol , then *eol-> *edy. 

A small set of these rules, about 20 or so, can explain most frequency differences between words across the entire manuscript, when applied in sequence, similar to how linguistic reconstruction models phoneme changes between words.

You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.

At any given step, these rules only capture a small amount of volume, with most words retained. 

   

However, if we actually see how many words remain consistent from start to end, we see an obvious gradual turnover of words. Each step changes a small amount, but over several steps these collectively add up, eventually resulting in large turnover across multiple steps. The chart below shows how many words from each step are retained into subsequent steps. Notice the gradual decline each step. By the end of the sequence, very little is directly retained from 1a.

   


Worked Examples

The chart below shows the evolution of the word 'chol'. Looking at just Currier A/ Currier B, there appears to be a dramatic gap, with chol appearing to mostly vanish from voynich vocabulary. However, in the chart below, we can actually see chol gradually declining and shifting into other words, not a single large jump. Chols transition into chedy is actually gradual, with its roots in the 1.5 'transitional A' section when it first divides into cheol. 

   


Below shows chor. This also appears like a dramatic jump between Currier A/B, but we can now see that its decline is actually gradual, slowly shifting into competing forms at each step, before finally vanishing in Stars.

   


Shol, another example.

   



Note these changes are sometimes undone, for example chol appears to be mostly turned into chedy in 3b, before reverting partially back into chol in 3c. This is consistent with what you would expect from random drift, some changes end up 'undoing' themselves. 


The missing sections, and Currier A/B

I strongly suspect that some of the most extreme differences between Currier A/B, like the appearance of the 'ed' bigram, would exhibit gradual changes in the missing bifolia. Already in the above charts, we can see that many of the A/B differences appear to be the results of transformations that began in the 1.5a transitional herbal section, and i expect that specifically missing quires P, R, and H, (f91, f92, f97, f98, f59-f65) would all show a more gradual transition, with 1 of either quire P/R occurring before pharma, and H and the other occurring afterwards. F58 and the cosmo/astro prose collectively represent a small amount of text, but we can already begin to see some of this occurring there.


The question of semantic meaning vs self citation
The above rules do not settle the question of semantic meaning vs self citation. If this linear evolution represents a gradual turnover, with scribes mostly copying existing words, i think it would be unusual for some forms to actually have their frequency mass preserved across the entire chain like this.

For example, if words truly lacked semantic meaning, there would be no reason why chol could not just simply gradually vanish with no replacement. That does not seem to be what is occurring here. Instead, words frequencies are mostly preserved downstream. It's possible some form of self-citation could also do this, but it would have to be fairly complex to preserve information in this way, and in my opinion, at least currently I think this actually points more to an evolution of the script or writing system.

In summary, I don't think there is enough evidence to fully resolve this question at present.

The exact rule changes

The rule changes i am using are all You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view., in the rule manager tab. I do not claim this is the full comprehensive set, just that the current set appears to capture most of the drift under a fairly small set of rules. I have no doubt they could be improved. I suspect applying linguistic reconstruction techniques would be a valuable approach. You can actually create and test your own rules on the site.

Print this item

  Voynich manuscript created by Giovanni di Cosimo de' Medici's sons
Posted by: bsbanks - 13-10-2026, 04:14 PM - Forum: Theories & Solutions - Replies (4)

Who could have created the Voynich Manuscript?
Whoever created the VM was well educated in art, languages and most likely music.
The creator would most likely have been wealthy to afford the time required to create the VM and able to afford the vellum and inks.
It's my opinion that the creator was not an adult. The art is not particularly good and the script seems unstructured. I think the creator
was an early teen. 
It's been pretty well accepted that the VM originated in Italy in the 15th century, there is little doubt about that.
The creator was most likely very wealthy. Where does that lead, Giovanni di Cosimo de' Medici.
Giovanni di Cosimo de' Medici was a wealthy art and manuscript collector. But he was not a teenager. However in the mid 15th century
his two sons were, Piero (1416) and Giovani (1421).
It is reasonable that 2 wealthy, well educated teenage boys that had access to old manuscripts would themselves be tempted to create their own manuscript.
It would also be reasonable to assume that their father being a collector of manuscripts would have in his collection a manuscript written by Roger Bacon and that the boys would have seen that manuscript and have been influenced by it. I know that the Roger Bacon connection
to the VM has been ruled out. I'm not suggesting that Bacon had anything to do with the VM, only that the Medici boys may have been influenced by it.
It's likely that Medici, being a manuscript collector would have access to vellum and inks and would have encouraged his sons in manuscript creation.

I think the two Medici boys formed a secret society (secret societies were all the rage) with perhaps three other well educated teens, a 15th century dead poets society so to speak. This group of teens decided to write a manuscript that tells a story.

What is the story?   
The story is about a star travelling through the heavens. It would seem that the VM s not in order.
The story starts with the introduction of the star families with the astronomical illustrations and the cosmological illustrations.
The next section would be the story of the heavenly bodies giving life, quire 13.
The biological illustrations followed by the history and tales of the main character 8and. 8and is one of the stars named on F68r1 bottom right. F68r1 and F68r2 are clearly star families.

The plants in the biological section are simply fanciful creations that provide art for the manuscript. I doubt that the plants actually have anything to do with the story. 
I believe the reason the plants are completely unidentifiable is because the artist(s) were not good enough to draw actual plants accurately.

The script?

The script is not a language. This is a combination letters and words that represent musical sounds.
The text also acts as mnemonic devices that would remind the orator of key words in the story.
Lisa Fagin Davis has identified that there are five scribes in the VM. Those five scribes are the
authors and were the story tellers.
1. The orator
2. Bells/chimes
3. Lute
4. Whistle/flute
5. Percussion

The words and letters would tell musicians what instrument to be played and the sound.
For example every time 8and appears it might be a certain combination of instruments and tones specific to that word. In some cases where additional letters are found with a word such as o8and
then that might represent the instrument combination with the addition of another instrument.
At that same time something about 8and that would need to be added to the narration.

I think Rene Zandbergen got it right, the VM is a musical transcription. Mr. Zandbergen's analysis is genius. However it may not be that complex. I would add to his analysis that the text also represents mnemonics for the narration.

So the story of 8and is told in poems on vignettes through the biological illustrations and shorter poems are found in quire 20, each separated with a star.

These stories would be told and performed for the Medici court, family, friends etc... 

What happened?
Why didn't the story of the VM, the script, the secret society get told, why did it disappear?
The members of the society grew up and moved on. I suspect that the manuscript was kept by Piero because he, like his father was a collector of manuscripts. He most likely put this on a shelf as a memory of boyhood fancy and forgotten. Then a hundred years later his manuscript collection was passed on and the rest is VM history. 

Conclusion
I think this is a book of stories illustrated, written and performed by five teenagers for amusement.
When they grew older the book was shelved and forgotten. Simply a fanciful book of children's stories.

Print this item

  4-slot FSM and procedural gemination in the ZL corpus (Python)
Posted by: 4free - 13-10-2026, 11:01 AM - Forum: Theories & Solutions - No Replies

Hello everyone,

I would like to share the methodology and empirical findings of a quantitative study conducted on the Zandbergen-Landini transcription corpus (ZL3b-n.txt, 5,316 lines, 33,645 tokens). Rather than attempting an ad-hoc translation of isolated folios or asserting arbitrary linguistic substitutions, this study examines whether the lexical and syntactic layers of MS 408 can be formally modeled as a deterministic positional state machine, evaluates sequential transition entropy, and quantifies section-dependent operational constraints.

All analyses were implemented in Python and are fully reproducible on the raw ZL corpus. The complete script pipeline is attached to this post.

1. The 4-Slot Morphotactic FSM Model

Testing positional slot constraints indicates that Voynichese word tokens are predominantly generated by a strict, left-to-right positional finite-state grammar rather than natural inflectional morphology:

Token = [S0: Prefix] + [S1: Gallows Selector] + [S2: Kernel/Core] + [S3: Terminal/Minims]

Slot Inventory:

  • S0 (34 Prefixes): qok-, qot-, qop-, qo-, che-, cho-, she-, sho-, da-, d-, sa-, ol-, ok-, ot-, etc.
  • S1 (9 Gallows / Ligatures): k, t, p, f, cth, ckh, cph, cfh, d.
  • S2 (35 Kernels): chol, chor, ee, al, ar, eol, ai, od, etc.
  • S3 (23 Terminals / Minims): -in, -iin, -iiin, -iiiin, -edy, -eedy, -y, -ey, -al, -ar, etc.

Quantitative Parameters:
  • Corpus Coverage: The 4-slot automaton successfully parses 84.01% of all lexical tokens across 5,316 lines of text without requiring external dictionary lookups or fuzzy stems.
  • Information Density: The resulting state distribution yields an empirical word entropy of H = 10.47 bits/token and a combinatorial redundancy of R = 18.64%, confirming that token generation operates under strict positional constraints rather than free phonotactic distribution.

2. The Heading Anomaly (Herbal A)

When extracting the very first word of each folio entry in Herbal A (110 initial tokens preceding plant illustrations):
  • 85.5% (94 out of 110) of these initial tokens fail the standard 4-slot FSM parse.
  • They behave as structural isolates featuring low-frequency consonants and distinct phonotactic skeletons.
  • This quantitative asymmetry provides objective evidence for a functional division within the manuscript: an open nominal index (headings) followed by a closed procedural matrix (running text).

3. Sequential Markov Transition Constraints

Evaluating the sequence of word classes across sentence and line units demonstrates that token ordering is not a random permutation:

Chi-Square Contingency Test of Class Transitions:
Code:
Chi-square = 335.30,  df = 9,  p-value = 8.29e-67

Transition Matrix (%):
Code:
To            C0_Substance  C1_Quality  C2_Operation  C3_Other From                                                          C0_Substance        11.22      20.70        18.40    49.68 C1_Quality            9.14      14.57        30.96    45.33 C2_Operation          8.24      17.43        30.16    44.17 C3_Other              7.87      15.92        23.69    52.53

4. Word-Level Gemination (W W): Evidence Against Dittography

Immediate word repetitions (qokeedy qokeedy, chol chol, shedy shedy) have frequently been interpreted as mechanical scribal errors (dittographies caused by eye-skips). We quantified exact duplicates and root-level geminations across all thematic sections of the manuscript:

Code:
+--------------+-------------+------------------+-----------------+-------------------+ | Section      | Total Pairs | Exact Dups (W W) | Root Gemination | Combined Index    | +--------------+-------------+------------------+-----------------+-------------------+ | Balneo      |    5,128    |      1.27%      |      4.06%      |      5.32%        | | Recipes      |    8,272    |      0.91%      |      3.95%      |      4.86%        | | Herbal B    |    1,110    |      0.63%      |      3.87%      |      4.50%        | | Herbal A    |    7,335    |      1.05%      |      3.22%      |      4.27%        | | Astro/Zodiac |    1,933    |      0.57%      |      3.67%      |      4.24%        | | Pharma      |    2,834    |      0.85%      |      2.96%      |      3.81%        | | Cosmo        |    1,428    |      0.49%      |      2.94%      |      3.43%        | +--------------+-------------+------------------+-----------------+-------------------+

Key Observation:
Gemination density peaks sharply in technical and procedural sections (Balneo at 5.32%, Recipes at 4.86%), while dropping significantly in astronomical diagrams (0.57%) and cosmological schemes (0.49%). Because scribal fatigue should correlate with text volume or line density rather than thematic illustration style, this distribution indicates that gemination functions as a deliberate operational iteration modifier (coque et recoque).

5. Sectional Specialization & Negative Control

Operational Predicates (qo-):
The frequency of action-initiating prefixes (qo-) drops to 2.01% in Astro/Zodiac, compared to 16.53% in Recipes and 23.28% in Balneo. This demonstrates that circular astronomical texts operate as catalogical registries, while Balneo and Recipes serve an operational function.

Phase Co-occurrence (ol vs. ee):
The co-occurrence of liquid phase markers (ol and ee) within individual lines is statistically significant:
Code:
Odds Ratio = 2.303,  Chi-square = 156.96,  p-value = 5.21e-36

Negative Control: Testing Macro-Humoral Polarity:
To test whether whole-page macro-profiles correlate with classical Galenic plant classifications (Circa Instans), we performed a Monte Carlo permutation test (N = 10,000 iterations) matching che- (warm) vs. cho- (cold) against medieval reference catalogs:
  • Observed Agreement: 52.00%
  • Null-Hypothesis Mean: 39.13% (+/- 7.67%)
  • Effect Size: z = +1.677
  • Empirical p-value: p = 0.1156

Conclusion: The null hypothesis cannot be rejected at the macro-level (p = 0.1156 > 0.05). Whole-page Voynichese text profiles cannot be reliably mapped to binary Galenic plant properties without collapsing into statistical noise. This demonstrates the danger of relying on short 2–3 consonant skeletal matches.

6. Summary and Discussion

The empirical data indicates that MS 408 is structured as an artificial, positional state-machine-driven procedural formulary with clear functional divergence between sections, rather than natural spoken syntax encrypted via substitution cipher.
The complete Python script used to parse the corpus and produce these statistics is attached.

P.S. Research Methodology & AI Assistance Disclosure:

For full transparency regarding the research workflow:
  1. The Chain of Hypotheses: Our investigation originated from the hypothesis that Voynichese behaves not as a natural spoken tongue, but as a modular, artificial recording system (a procedural laboratory or apothecary formulary). We formalized this into a 4-slot deterministic finite state machine (FSM). We subsequently tested whether running text reflects algorithmic recipes (evaluating sequential Markov constraints and procedural word gemination W W), and whether page headings function as an open nominal registry. Finally, we instituted a negative control to test whether folio-level macro-profiles could map directly to classical Galenic humoral classifications (Circa Instans), which our permutation test properly refuted (p = 0.1156).
  2. Use of AI / LLM Tools: An AI assistant (Large Language Model) was utilized as an interactive computational co-pilot throughout this project. It was employed to rapidly generate, refactor, and debug the Python data-processing pipelines in Google Colab, compute statistical tests (chi-square contingency, information-theoretic entropy, Monte Carlo permutations), and structure the mathematical formulation of our findings into this presentation. All data, counts, and statistical outputs presented here were generated deterministically by the attached Python script running on the raw ZL transcription.



Attached Files
.txt   voynich_fsm_pipeline.txt (Size: 13.62 KB / Downloads: 4)
Print this item

  Actual theories on Voynichese being Rhaetian?
Posted by: Sephardi_Genius - 12-10-2026, 10:34 PM - Forum: Theories & Solutions - Replies (8)

Hello everyone, my undergraduate concentration in history was on late medieval and early modern Northern Italy, so my first thought when I learned about the suspected provenance of the Voynich manuscript to Tyrol or a similar Alpine region was that it could've been written in some form of Rhaeto-Romance language, such as Ladin, Romansch, or Friulian. I tried looking on this forum for anyone that's gone on a deep dive into this theory, but I wasn't able to find anything. I will be the first to admit that I am far from capable of engineering such a theory to begin with (even my standard Italian and classical Latin skills are pretty bad at this point), and I suspect that any Romance language is probably out of the question, but was just interested if anyone had actually gone down this rabbit hole before, and what their conclusions might've been?

Print this item