An article about the Voynich manuscript at lesswrong.com: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.
The author argues the VMS is a meaningless fabrication, analysed with the Zandbergen-Landini transcription. Much of it replicates known results: the very low glyph-level conditional entropy from Lindemann & Bowern 2021, and Timm’s finding that near-identical words cluster both within lines and between adjacent lines beyond what a shuffled-page baseline predicts. The author pushes back on Lindemann & Bowern’s view that a hoaxer couldn’t have produced such language-like statistics.
The new parts:
He reports the Zipf fit explicitly (parameter 1.854), noting that an order-1 Markov process lands in the same natural-language range, so a Zipf fit is weak evidence either way.
He trained a GRU on a subset of pages and on control corpora, then masked earlier lookalike words. Prediction degraded much more for Voynichese than for Latin or a Markov process, and slightly less than for text from the self-citation generator.
The degradation is strongest when lookalike pairs differ at both the start and end of the word, which he argues fits a copy-and-edit process better than any real inflection system.
The comments are worth reading too: Michael Roe says he spent years with the Voynich discussion group, including Landini, and thinks the text is a made-up pseudolanguage, though he calls the statistical evidence highly suggestive rather than conclusive. He suggests checking whether the two proposed “authors” differ more than two writers of one language could.
It’s interesting to set this next to Michael Roe’s early contribution to the Voynich mailing list in 1993 (“A word to unlock the Voynich MS”). In that email he proposed "okal" as a possible way into the Vonyich text and suggested reading the word starts as case markers. voynich.nu presents the resulting word pattern in EVA in section 3.2.2 (“Mike Roe’s generic word”) of his word-structure page (see You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.).
This thread is a sibling to the one about P/F's evolution, but this one is focused specifically around Bench gallows.
Looking at bench gallows use across the manuscript arranged in my proposed chronological order shows some striking patterns. You can view this yourself You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.(scroll down to see the graphs by page).
This chart shows the per 10k occurrences of ckh (first set of bars) and cth (second set of bars) across the manuscript, in chronological order.
I've annotated the chart to show the interesting features. First, note the void in section 1b. This occurs in the 18:23 bifolio. The first page of the bifolio, 18r, has above average cth compared to all prior usage. But this plummets on the two interior pages and the final page.
If we look at 18r, it seems the scribe was really struggling with the bench gallows forms. Look how many 'mistake' or 'aberrant' bench gallows are on this page.
Did the scribe just get frustrated and abandon bench gallows entirely for the rest of the bifolio? The first page on the next bifolio (f44r), cth is also is absent, although the following page You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. contains the most cth occurrences in the entire MS.
The 2nd drop in pharma, also occurs mid bifolio. This one is a fold out, 87:90. There is a substantial drop from 87v to 90r, that persists throughout the remainder of the manuscript. This change is not subtle or gradual, it happens all at once, and persists. Ckh does not appear to be affected like cTh.
Looking at 87v, we can again see several apparent issues the scribe had writing the bench gallows, even more than in 18r. It seems they were consistently having trouble with the h glyph, with many missing or showing signs of corrections. Several sh's look abnormal as well, like the scribe may have started to use a bench gallows but then stopped and tried to correct it into an sh.
It seems extremely odd that cTh would experience such a sharp decline, mid bifolio, that persists over all subsequent pages. Did the scribe end up deciding that cTh simply was too much trouble?
both pages immediately after the cTh decline (18v and 90r), show substantial increases in q words. Both are the top 2 pages by number of q uses in the entire Currier A portion of the MS. The fact this occurs after both declines would seem to indicate the Q words are directly replacing the cth words.
Whats more, it appears to specifically be qok, NOT qot words that are elevated.
This strongly seems to suggest that cTh -> qok. I have not looked to see if word forms are comprehensively preserved. cthy for instance is one of the common cth forms that disappears from 18r->18v, and qoky does indeed appear in 18v. But other qok word appear that do not seem to have any cth equivalent, like qokchy, which is predominantly an A word, and possibly what evolves into qokedy if my previous hypothesis that chy->edy.
Much like the P/F discussion, this i think raises important questions about bench gallows, whether they can be expressed in other combinations of glyphs, and what forms replace them. Like P/F, there does not appear to be a consistent rule, which i think is troubling and supports different forms undergoing different mutations.
New missing piece: Córdoba?
While researching the “primer analogy”, looking more closely into Bessarion, and following historical references in the Voynich forum, I came across Fernando de Córdoba almost by accident.
Core idea
Fernando de Córdoba's De artificio omnis et investigandi et inveniendi natura scibilis may provide a historical comparison to the structure of the Voynich Manuscript that has so far received surprisingly little attention.
This is explicitly not an attempt to declare Córdoba the author of the Voynich Manuscript, nor to claim that his work provides a direct key to Voynich.
The more interesting question is whether the general, multi-layered and combinatorial method described by Fernando shows functional similarities to structures that are already known in the Voynich Manuscript or are currently being investigated. Facts about Fernando de Córdoba's De artificio omnis et investigandi et inveniendi natura scibilis and the structure of the Voynich Manuscript
According to Fernando's own account, Bessarion explicitly instructed him to interrupt his ongoing study of Plato and Aristotle and work instead on the De artificio.
The work was dedicated to Bessarion in 1468/69. The exact date of Bessarion's original request is unknown.
→ Could Bessarion at this point already have had an idea related to “Voynich”, or even had access to an already existing Voynich Manuscript? Highly hypothetical.
Fernando describes his goal as a:
Quote:“unica et indivisibilis ars”
In other words, a single and indivisible method.
Its basic idea can roughly be described as:
Quote:“I am developing a method by which the possible questions, concepts, relationships, proofs and conclusions relating to any field of knowledge can be generated systematically.”
So the aim is not simply to collect existing knowledge, but to create a systematic procedure or rule-based method through which knowledge can be investigated and generated. The basic system
Córdoba distinguishes, among other things, 25 transcendental determinations:
perfection, quantity, possibility/power, duration, rest, force, inclination, being or non-being, mediation, limit, principle, degree, order, unity, number, positive, privative, habit, measure, and so on.
From these, theoretically: 25 × 25 = 625 possible combinations
can be produced.
In addition, there are 31 absolute perfections.
These are organised using basic distinctions such as:
absolute / relative
substance / accident
real / rational
simply / in a certain respect
act / potency
simple / composite
necessary / contingent
infinite / finite
independent / dependent
positive / negative
identical / different
If there is any relation to the Voynich Manuscript, its own system could of course contain a completely different number of such “categories”.
The numbers 25 and 31 are therefore not meant to be transferred directly to Voynich. They belong first and foremost to Córdoba's own system. Llull, Scotus and Aristotle
According to Rafael Ramis Barceló, the work is not simply inspired by Lullism, but represents a strong connection between Llull and Scotism.
Scotus is one of the most prominent scholastic authors in the work. The Scotists are even the most frequently mentioned philosophical school.
In simplified terms, one could say: Llull mainly provides the idea of the method. Scotus provides a large part of its philosophical fine structure.
Aristotle is also an important basis for the logical and demonstrative structure.
One important difference from Llull himself is that Córdoba's system does not necessarily require combinatorial wheels.
Combination is not abandoned. It is transformed and integrated more strongly into a logical, scholastic system of investigation and demonstration. Antecedent, consequence and relationships
In the second book, Fernando develops rules for: antecedent, consequence, agreement, difference, opposition and relationships between concepts.
Bonilla counts, among other things, 85 possible rules of comparison.
Fernando is strongly influenced here by Aristotle, particularly the Topics and the syllogistic tradition: premise → conclusion
Combination is therefore not removed; it is made logically traceable.
One might say that:
Quote:Fernando turns the Lullian combinatorial machine more strongly into a scholastic search and demonstration machine based on Aristotelian philosophy.
Fernando also describes a procedure by which one can move from concepts to their consequences, antecedents, opposites and so on.
In a sense, this allows one to move through a space of relationships.
The principle is not: A + B + C = secret meaning
but rather:
A has relation R to B.
B includes C.
C contradicts D.
D belongs to class E.
This produces a rule-governed catalogue of concepts — obviously not in our modern mathematical terminology, but functionally similar.
This particular point may be considerably more interesting for Voynich than the search for a simple, classical cipher. A small basic inventory can generate an enormous space of possibilities
Fernando himself makes some remarkable claims.
By combining transcendental concepts + related concepts + subordinate concepts + question forms + rules, he says that an enormous number of possible arguments can be generated for a single question.
At one point, he speaks of more than 60,000 possible lines of argument.
This does not mean that a medieval scholar would have had to write out 60,000 possibilities.
It simply means:
Quote:A small, finite inventory of rules and basic elements can create a very large space of possible states.
And this is structurally important.
A system based on such procedures could outwardly generate a very large number of different “words” or combinations even if the underlying grammar consisted of relatively few elements.
This is obviously not evidence that Voynich works this way.
But it does provide a historical mechanism that makes this general type of behaviour understandable. From universal concepts to concrete things
It becomes even more interesting when Fernando moves from universal concepts toward more concrete things.
He begins with general categories and then moves increasingly toward specific classes.
The surviving description includes, among other things: the heavens, elements, seas, rivers, mountains, winds, stones, fish, animals, birds, etc.
This suggests that the “universal Ars” was not intended simply as philosophy reflecting on itself.
It was meant to be applied to real domains of knowledge and objects in nature.
The basic scheme would therefore look roughly like this:
Code:
universal operators
→ general categories
→ field of knowledge
→ concrete class of objects
→ concrete object
→ questions
→ relationships
→ possible conclusions
This comes surprisingly close to a formal system for organising knowledge. The ten questions
In the third part, Fernando shows how one is supposed to find all possible questions relating to a given object.
To do this, the ten types of questions are combined with the different levels of concepts and categories.
For example:
Code:
quid + plant
quare + plant
quantum + plant
ubi + plant
cum quo + plant
and then the same procedure is repeated with subclasses and properties.
The system therefore does not merely generate answers.
It first generates the space of possible questions.
As a theoretical idea, this is extremely important.
Fernando is attempting to formalise the process of scientific investigation itself. The later parts of the system
The final parts are shorter or less completely developed.
Fernando attempts to establish:
[]how the objects belonging to a science can be derived from the subject of that science,[]how possible conclusions can then be produced,
and how tracing the antecedents backwards can eventually lead to the first principles of that science.
From a modern point of view, this could roughly be written as:
This gives the whole work an almost algorithmic form.
Not an algorithm in the modern mathematical sense, but a rule-based workflow. The problem of the missing Practica
This leads to one of the most interesting problems in the transmission of the work.
Fernando repeatedly refers to a “Practica” or “Exercitatio”, in which the application of the Artificium was apparently supposed to be demonstrated in practice.
He even states that certain things would be explained there by means of examples or viva voce — orally.
This practical elaboration has not survived.
Whether it was ever fully developed as a separate work cannot currently be established with certainty.
Bonilla explicitly points out in his edition that Fernando repeatedly refers to this Practica or Exercitatio. No separate, completely preserved practical work is known.
This means:
Quote:We largely possess the rulebook, but apparently not the complete exercise or application book.
For Voynich, this gap is methodologically important.
We should therefore not make the mistake of claiming that Voynich is Fernando's lost Practica.
There is absolutely no evidence for that.
What we can say is:
Quote:At present, we do not know what a practically applied Cordoban system would have looked like on the page.
And for that reason, we should not automatically expect its practical application to resemble a theoretical Latin treatise. The early Bessarion copy in the Marciana
The important early Bessarion copy of the De artificio is now held in the Biblioteca Nazionale Marciana: Marc. Lat. Z. 481 (=1915), fols. 4r–88v.
It contains Bessarion's ex libris and his coat of arms.
At present, I have not found a freely accessible complete online viewer for this codex.
It is therefore currently not possible to check directly whether this early copy contains, besides text, initials and decoration, any schematic, tabular or other visual forms of organisation.
A direct examination of this manuscript would therefore be particularly interesting for the Voynich comparison. And Plato?
This is where Bessarion becomes important.
As mentioned earlier, according to Fernando's own account, Bessarion caused him to interrupt his work on Plato and Aristotle and instead write the De artificio.
This fits remarkably well with Bessarion's intellectual environment and with the way in which, between Byzantine traditions influenced by Aristotle, Plato and Plethon, he did not simply want to discard Aristotle and replace him with Plato.
The aim was to compare knowledge and, where possible, to “reconcile” it.
Technically, however, Fernando is by no means simply a Platonist in the De artificio.
Bonilla already emphasised in 1911 that the actual work was much more strongly shaped by Aristotle, Scotus and Llull than by Plato.
Monfasani's later research has tended to confirm rather than contradict this impression.
One could therefore say:
Quote:The broader goal shows a Platonic tendency toward the unity of knowledge.
The machinery underneath is predominantly influenced by Aristotle, Scotus and Llull.
And what about You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. and f66r?
The unusual pages You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. and You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. had already been connected with one another long before this Córdoba comparison.
Their possible relationship should therefore not be attributed to Fernando.
Whether these pages actually represent parts of a general rule system or application system must be tested independently of the historical comparison.
Córdoba does not provide a key to them.
For this reason, a statistical investigation of You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. and You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. is being carried out deliberately separately from the historical Córdoba hypothesis.
The results and the methods used in those tests will be presented in a separate post.
This should make it possible to examine later whether the statistically observed structures actually fit such a historical comparison, without mixing the two approaches from the outset. What possibilities arise from the relationship between Voynich, Bessarion and Córdoba?
The following examples are explicitly speculative.
They are intended to illustrate possible historical directions, not to prove any of them. Possibility A: A common origin
The similarity between Voynich and Córdoba's work could represent a kind of family resemblance.
They would not necessarily have to know one another.
Both could have a common origin and represent different developments within a reform of the Lullian tradition. Possibility B: Only a historical comparison
Voynich and the De artificio may have no direct genealogical connection at all.
Córdoba could still be relevant because his work demonstrates that a comparable type of method was historically real in the fifteenth century.
This would be the most cautious possibility. Possibility C: Voynich influences Bessarion
Bessarion gains access to the Voynich Manuscript.
He is able to understand its content and therefore encourages Córdoba to “create” a universal language or universal method influenced by Llull. Possibility D: Bessarion cannot understand Voynich
Bessarion gains access to the Voynich Manuscript.
He cannot understand its content, but while investigating it he develops the idea of creating a universal system or universal language.
Córdoba is subsequently encouraged to pursue this idea. Possibility E: Voynich is created within Bessarion's circle
Bessarion himself, or a Bessarion circle, creates Voynich.
As a basis, he — or the circle — uses the De artificio omnis et investigandi et inveniendi natura scibilis in order to apply its own script as a universal language in practice. Possibility F: Voynich as the practical application
Voynich represents the missing practical part of the work of De artificio omnis et investigandi et inveniendi natura scibilis.
Again:
There is currently no direct evidence for this. The chronological problem with E and F
The parchment was radiocarbon-dated to 1404–1438.
This establishes the production date of the parchment, but does not necessarily date the writing itself to the same period.
However:
Quote:A substantially later inscription would in principle be possible, but would have to be demonstrated independently.
Since Córdoba's work was completed in 1468/69, Possibilities E and F create a substantial chronological conflict.
A “Bessarion circle”, meaning a close group of people within his network, could also potentially have written Voynich collectively — purely hypothetically.
However, the chronological factor remains an important obstacle to this possibility. Additional thoughts
Why might Córdoba have been overlooked until now?
Could the inaccurately transmitted hare story — historically documented differently from the way it was presented in the forum in connection with Cusanus — be one reason why Cusanus / Nicholas of Cusa was investigated, while Córdoba remained largely overlooked?
Is Bessarion the pivotal figure?
His network, his history, his motives and his opportunities could explain a great deal. Even without factual evidence, Bessarion remains a possible and fascinating candidate in the history of the origin and development of the Voynich Manuscript. Sources Fernando de Córdoba and the De artificio
Adolfo Bonilla y San Martín, Fernando de Córdoba (¿1425–1486?) y los orígenes del Renacimiento filosófico en España. Episodio de la historia de la lógica. Madrid: Victoriano Suárez, 1911.
This remains one of the most important sources for the De artificio. It contains extensive discussion and textual material relating to the 25 transcendental determinations, the 625 combinations, the 31 absolute perfections, the rules of comparison, the claim of more than 60,000 possible arguments, and Fernando's references to a Practica and Exercitatio.
Rafael Ramis Barceló, “Fernando de Córdoba y el lulismo del siglo XV,” Mediaevalia. Textos e estudos 34 (2015), pp. 127–144. DOI: 10.21747/21836884/med34a8.
Particularly important for the modern reassessment of Fernando as a syncretic rather than simply anti-Lullian thinker, the connection between Lullism and Scotism, and the interpretation of the De artificio as an attempt to construct a general method for all sciences.
John Monfasani, Fernando of Cordova: A Biographical and Intellectual Profile. Transactions of the American Philosophical Society, vol. 82, part 6. Philadelphia: American Philosophical Society, 1992.
The major modern biographical and intellectual study of Fernando, including his relationship with Cardinal Bessarion and the wider intellectual context of his works. Bessarion and the Marciana manuscript
John Monfasani, Bessarion Scholasticus: A Study of Cardinal Bessarion's Latin Library. Byzantios: Studies in Byzantine History and Civilization 3. Turnhout: Brepols, 2012.
Important for Bessarion's Latin and scholastic library, his intellectual circle and the manuscript tradition associated with his collection, including Marc. Lat. Z. 481 (=1915).
Biblioteca Nazionale Marciana, Venice, Marc. Lat. Z. 481 (=1915), fols. 4r–88v.
Early manuscript witness of Fernando de Córdoba's De artificio associated with Bessarion.
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, “Bessarion.”
Useful as a modern overview of Bessarion's relationship to Platonism, Aristotelianism, scholasticism and the Plato–Aristotle controversy. Llull and fifteenth-century Lullism
Ramon Llull Database, Universitat de Barcelona.
Bibliographical resource for Ramon Llull, Lullism and the transmission and transformation of Lullian thought.
Rafael Ramis Barceló, “Fernando de Córdoba y el lulismo del siglo XV,” Mediaevalia 34 (2015), pp. 127–144.
Especially relevant for Fernando's position within fifteenth-century Lullism and Scoto-Lullism. Voynich: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. and f66r
Minutes of the Teddington Voynich Meeting, 1998.
Important because the possible relationship between You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. and You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. was already explicitly discussed there. The participants noted the rare word dairal, unusual sequences on both pages, and the possible significance of 17 elements on You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. versus 34 on f66r.
The statistical investigation referred to in this post is separate from the Córdoba hypothesis and will be presented independently. Voynich dating
University of Arizona radiocarbon analysis of Beinecke MS 408, carried out in 2009.
Four parchment samples were tested. The commonly cited combined result places the parchment in the 1404–1438 range with approximately 95% probability.
The important limitation is that radiocarbon dating dates the parchment support, not the act of writing on it.
René Zandbergen, “Radio-carbon dating of the Voynich MS,” Voynich.nu.
Detailed documentation of the Arizona measurements, calibration and surviving internal report.
Beinecke Rare Book & Manuscript Library, Yale University, Beinecke MS 408.
Repository and manuscript record for the Voynich Manuscript. Earlier Voynich discussion
Voynich Ninja, “A Cusanus Ladin Hypothesis” discussion, 2022.
Relevant to the earlier discussion involving Cusanus, Llull and Bessarion, including the transmission of the so-called hare/hunting anecdote.
This forum discussion should be distinguished from the primary and scholarly sources listed above. Note: This post was originally written in German. The English translation was produced with AI assistance. AI was also used to optimise paragraph structure and visual readability. The underlying arguments, hypotheses, source selection and conclusions are my own.
I’m Jason Carroll Holloway, a novelist in Kansas City. The News board takes announcements of books related to the VMS, so here is mine, with the label up front: it is fiction.
Masters X began as a research project and became a novel. A graduate student inherits his grandfather’s notebooks and is drawn toward Rudolf II’s Prague. Its central conceit is that the Voynich Manuscript, the Ars Notoria and the Codex Gigas are three expressions of one system. That claim is the novel’s invention, not a finding, but I grounded everything around it in as much real research as I could.
What is real, and what I tried to get right: Beinecke MS 408, the 1404 to 1438 radiocarbon range, the Baresch and Marci letters, and the reported 600 ducats from Rudolf. I wrote that history up as a field note. I recently published a corrected second edition after a long continuity audit, and I’d be honored to make a third edition corrected by people here who know the provenance better than I do:
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.
There’s also a free browser tool on the book’s site that puts 166 Beinecke page images beside the Ars Notoria notae, so you can overlay and rotate them:
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.
A note on AI: I use AI tools for research and editing, and a book this dense wouldn’t have been possible without them. My background in English literature and data analytics helps me use them carefully. My next book, which I start next year, will be written on an IBM Selectric. I honestly can’t wait.
I want to discuss P/F gallows, and their relationship to K/T. Throughout this post I am going to refer to my proposed 'chronological gradient'. If you disagree such a gradient exists, there are other places to argue that.
LFD's explanation for P/F is that they represent Ke/Te, based on the fact K is depleted in line openings. However, this explanation alone doesn't seem to line up with what we see in the MS.
K is only depleted in line openings in Herbal A, which almost entirely lacks any ke or te words. Pch is incredibly common, but tech and kech is nonexistent.
The charts below show the per 10k occurrences, arranged by my chronological gradient of
Ke or Te
Kch or Tch
pch
Note, the apparent gradual increase in Ke/te from the 1.5-2a sections, coincides almost exactly with the decline of tch and kch. Pch is slightly less common in 2a, but it's use is much flatter over the entire course of the MS.
It's clear from the above charts P/F cannot simply be Ke or Te, as Ke/Te did not become popular until pharma.
To better see the differences between P/F bearing words and K/T bearing words, i created the same MDS plots, but I filtered to only Gallows bearing words, and I replaced all gallows characters with <G>. For each bifolia, i then pooled the <P/F> gallows, and the <K/T> gallows.
For comparison, I also created a 2nd version, that uses Ke/Te instead of K/T. In this version, Ke/Te are collapsed to <G>, so we can compare P/F to ke/te words directly.
This allows us compare word construction patterns between P/F, K/T and Ke/Te, along the MDS dimensions. When we do this, something very interesting happens.
In the chart below, each arrow points from the same bifolio's P/F words, to its K/T words.
Immediately something is very obvious. P/F virtually always sit to the right of K/T. What's more, the distance between the P/F words and the K/T words increases over the course of the manuscript, as the chart below shows. Comparing P/F to Ke/Te does not resolve this issue -- in fact this creates substantially greater distance between the points in 1a/1b, while not particularly lowering the later distances.
If i turn this (pf)->(kt) into a vector, I can compare it directly against the local path for all words. Basically, this is seeing if the direction of the pf->kt matches the direction of the overall gradient. If the directions align, the arrow is green. If they point in the opposite direction, it is orange. The charts at the bottom report the actual angle of alignment.
We can see that overwhelmingly, P/F and K/T are separated in the direction of the gradient. This strongly implies that P/F are more conservative or 'lagged' K/T. In other words: at any given point, P/F are following older word construction patterns than K/T.
This raises many important questions.
Are P/F an 'archaic' or conservative 'K/T'?
Why did P/F not eventually get the same E-treatment as K/T?
What does this mean for Ke/Te words as a whole? Is <e> simply some kind of shorthand or alternative notation that never is integrated with P/F?
Are the apparent coeval drop of <G>ch and rise of <G>e related? ch already strongly resembles ee.
Hello everyone, please be patient with me, this is my first time posting here :-)
f57v and You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. – The Primer Analogy (German: Fibel)
I am aware that many of these approaches have already been examined individually. What is particularly important here is the physical connection between You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. and f66r. These pages were therefore not randomly selected to fit the idea; they already share a historical/physical connection (bifolium).
What I could not find in my research was an analogy between a primer (German: "Fibel", a traditional first-grade reading textbook) and the diagram on f57v. I therefore want to emphasize that I am not trying to take credit for other people's ideas, but rather to combine existing ideas with my own.
In this primer analogy, You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. could represent a second-grade language textbook. The two pages would not necessarily have to be directly connected through readable text, but they could still be connected in terms of their meaning. What do I mean by this?
The following could therefore be possible: a didactic guide can contain repetitions, variations, isolated characters, combined units, and complete sentences right next to each other, without all of them serving the same function.
What the primer actually demonstrates (with german example)
→ P p
= Basic forms
The purpose here is to introduce characters. The same letter appears in uppercase and lowercase, as well as in different writing styles (print and cursive).
→ Pa – pa
= Syllable formation
The purpose here is to demonstrate construction. One character is combined with another already familiar character. This creates a readable unit.
→ Papa
= Word formation
This demonstrates the principle of repetition and combination. Two instances of "Pa" form a complete word.
→ Papa ist am …
= Application
Here, context is introduced. The same building blocks are then used in larger structures.
In the photographic example of a first-grade primer, the right-hand column shows the variations Papa, Pap, Pa, P, Pa, Pap, Papa. This demonstrates how something can be broken down and put back together, showing the logic behind the letters, syllables, and the word. However, "Pap" represents an intermediate element that only serves the formation of the word later on, without having a meaning of its own in the language. We only know this because we can read the language. With f57v, this is precisely the knowledge we are missing.
The difference between my interpretation of the rings and Matsuta's interpretation is, in my view, that he would already assign the procedures according to the positions of the rings. I see it more as a compact way of showing how the rings might interact to form a kind of "instruction manual".
If we consider the four rings in a way similar to Llull, several possibilities arise:
- One ring could introduce individual building blocks.- Another could show variations or possible combinations.- A further ring could contain more complex constructions.- The last could represent applications or another stage of processing.
BUT: The primer example also shows that these functions do not necessarily have to be distributed across four separate rings. Several functions can already appear within a single learning unit.
Nevertheless, one could conclude from this that repetitions and deviations within the ring sequences are not necessarily errors or meaningful textual variants. They could simply be systematically demonstrating the different possibilities.
One could also ask whether the characters are only combined linguistically, or whether they might also serve as a basic graphical arrangement or a construction principle for gallows and benched gallows. However, to investigate this, we would probably first need to understand the basic forms.
One logical, didactic consequence could be:
R2 (sequence of forms) → R4 (basic elements) → R3 (process of transformation) → R1 (formation of variants).
This sequence follows more of a logical progression if we stay with the primer analogy. But why a different order? If R1 is the ring of variants, it might need more space because several variants would have to be shown in greater detail. R2, on the other hand, needs space for its 68 character positions.
The idea of placing the sequence of forms before the basic elements comes from the primer analogy. It does not necessarily have to begin with the traditional ABC. It is conceivable that a limited selection of characters and their sequence could first be introduced, before explaining their structure, transformation, or combination.
However: This would first have to be confirmed by a statistical or paleographic investigation.
Theoretically, the unusual features identified by Matsuta might even support this idea ({&169} on f57v, {&170} on f57v, {&171} on f57v, and {&172} on both You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. and f66r).
The three characters described only on You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. could indicate a special function of this diagram page. The additional occurrence of {&172} reported on f66r, on the other hand, could be a possible concrete connection between the two pages. Taken together, this might also point towards an "instruction manual" or a "learning path".
f66r
If we now consider You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. as a possible example of application, the question arises whether the three text areas might also serve different functions. Similar to the primer, they would not necessarily have to show the same content, but could represent different steps or variations of a common procedure.
Lisa Fagin Davis's study (2020) is also interesting in this context. Although You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. and You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. belong to the same bifolium, Davis assigns the two pages to different scribal hands (Hand 1 and Hand 5). This could point towards collaboration or at least different stages of work. Whether this also has any significance for the content naturally remains an open question.
Koen G. also pointed out the unusual characteristics of Quire 8 on the Voynich Ninja forum (October 2025). What stands out is that the connection often observed between scribal hand, Currier language, and page type does not entirely follow the usual pattern here. You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. in particular occupies an unusual position. Whether this has any significance for a possible connection to You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. would first need to be investigated.
Another interesting aspect of this folio is the large number of simple relationships between variants.
The five paragraphs on You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. could also be compared structurally. Could different exercise or application steps be identified in connection with my assumption?
To what extent a tabular arrangement in three columns establishes a relationship between them is something I cannot demonstrate as a fact. It is possible that columns 1 and 2 form a kind of construction kit that serves as a reading or construction aid for column 3.
Alternatively, even a fixed relationship between horizontal divisions and vertical columns would be conceivable. This could be based on the five graphically apparent paragraphs (attached PDF, page 2, illustration "A"), or on further subdivisions within those five paragraphs involving characters from the respective column(s) (attached PDF, page 2, illustration "B").
It would also be conceivable that, under the assumption of a "Frame-Core Hypothesis" (German: "Rahmen-Kern-These"), the page might demonstrate by example how the definition of columns 1 and 2 affects the context in column 3.
My personal opinion is that the arrangement of the three columns was deliberate and was not added afterwards.
To test this hypothesis, however, a statistical analysis and, ideally, a paleographic investigation would be necessary. I would cautiously point out that purely statistical comparisons could potentially misinterpret the context of the primer analogy, since a direct repetition or correspondence between instructions and application does not necessarily have to be present. The important question would therefore be which relationships should actually be tested.
Interesting historical examples related to the primer analogy
1. Donatus, Ars minor, and Alexander de Villa Dei, Doctrinale
These works taught basic rules of grammar. They did not simply present reading texts, but organized learning around grammatical rules.
2. Ramon Llull – Ars brevis, 1308
Perhaps the most interesting candidate in this context: learning through regulated positions in circular diagrams. The diagram was therefore not merely used as an illustration, but as a tool.
Furthermore, it could have been known to an author (or authors) of MS 408. Other aspects of its content are also remarkable when considered in relation to MS 408.
Source: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.
Already discussed in the Voynich Ninja threads "The Lullian Apophatic Machine" (03/2026) and "A Cusanus Ladin Hypothesis" (07/2022).
Further sources
René Zandbergen – Voynich MS, Quire 8
Documentation of the shared bifolium f57/f66, the ring structure on f57v, and the division of the text on f66r.
Jorge Stolfi – Interlinear Transcription of the Voynich Manuscript
Transcription comparisons and descriptions of the unusual character forms and column structure on f66r.
Lisa Fagin Davis (2020) – "How Many Glyphs and How Many Scribes? Digital Paleography and the Voynich Manuscript." Manuscript Studies, Vol. 5, No. 1.
Mitsuro Matsuta (2026) – "Structural Analysis of the Voynich Manuscript: Elucidating a Knowledge System through Statistical Methods." Preprint, March 2026. DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.19058612.
Koen G. (2025) – Post #14, October 9, 2025, in the Voynich Ninja thread "Looking at You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. in regards to the line as a functional unit." Discussion of the unusual combinations of scribal hand, Currier language, and page type within Quire 8, particularly You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. and the f57/f66 bifolium.
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.
Translation note: This post was originally written in German and translated into English with the assistance of AI. The ideas, hypotheses, interpretations, and conclusions are my own.
I am new to the forum, but have had an interest in the "Voynich Manuscript" for some time. I am not a specialist nor an academic by any stretch, but I have come up with a theoretical framework based on historical context and sociological observation. My approach is to answer "The Why". I do not know if any of my assumptions have already been tested, however I am certain the intellectuals of this forum will advise and share their thoughts.
I believe, The Voynich Manuscript is a holistic medical book written by or co written by non-classically trained women. Communicating in either their own engineered language or a mash-up, blending of several languages that they later encrypted. This would reflect the diversity of their backgrounds and regions, which is actually very common today.
The women would have been from varying medical/health backgrounds such as healers, herbalists, or midwives. Because this is not traditional medicine and is authored by women (theoretically), secrecy is clear. This "cipher" was used to protect the women, clients/recipient and the practice in a patriarchal society. Many restrictions, challenges and roadblocks that are still common today could explain "The Why". Rather than continuing to solve this mystery with the same approach of asking "what is this", we should stand back and start asking "why".
Please share your thoughts on my possible theory and if any of this has already been explored/tested. As far as cracking the language I do believe AI, Linguist and Cryptologist have focused their efforts on decoding based on a single language model. Due to posible language barriers or dialects we would naturally have discrepancies. I do not think we are dealing with a single language. I often say Salut or Buenos Dias but I am only fluent in English. My theory leans on the idea that humans are predictable and have not changed much over time.
Background: Bess and I disagree on many basic interpretations so I probably shouldn't continue to post my ideas in her thread.
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.
Review: I strongly suspect that the mystery language of the Voynich Manuscript is Old Czech (Bohemian) or Moravian. I am working on updating the EVA alphabet. So far:
EVA → Update
a → ? d → d l → r r → ? s → s t → v v → ? y → a
The "Rules" so far:
- May need to drop the first "o" character.
- Update the EVA characters.
- Vowels are flexible.
Like many people, I think the words on the top of page You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. are the Five Classical Greek Elements.
Air: olkchs → lkchs → rkchs → ?? "rauch" (wind)
Water: otedy → tedy → veda → ? "voda" or "vodou" (water)
Aether: otork → tork → vo?k → ?? "vrch" (the upper atmosphere)
Fire: otol → tol → vor / var → ? "var" (fire, heat)
Earth (Land): dchdy → dchda → ?? "deža" (earth, clay)
The only ones I feel really good about are "voda" (water) and "var" (fire) but I think the other three may work out if I can figure out more letters.
I previously talked about the solo "s" character meaning "with" in Czech.
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.
It looks like the solo "a" character means "and" in Czech.
If I am reading EVA "y" ( y ) as "a", then the solo EVA "y" ( y ) could mean "and". If I counted correctly, it looks like the solo EVA "y" ( y ) appears 50 times in the 20 pages of Quire 13.
Woo-hoo!! Do we have two confirmed Czech words?
I know, two solo character words aren't going to convince anyone but it supports "otedy" ( otedy ) → "voda".