Welcome, Guest
You have to register before you can post on our site.

Username/Email:
  

Password
  





Search Forums

(Advanced Search)

Online Users
There are currently 2114 online users.
» 8 Member(s) | 2100 Guest(s)
Applebot, Baidu, Bing, Facebook, Google, Yandex, CnRwork blowsminds, Dana Scott, Mark Knowles, pjburkshire

Latest Threads
First Ideas by a new user
Forum: Analysis of the text
Last Post: pjburkshire
1 hour ago
» Replies: 1
» Views: 61
The 'Chinese' Theory: Fo...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: Jorge_Stolfi
3 hours ago
» Replies: 1,109
» Views: 454,865
f58v Visual Code, Weird S...
Forum: Imagery
Last Post: nablator
7 hours ago
» Replies: 26
» Views: 1,521
Old Czech (Bohemian) or M...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: pjburkshire
9 hours ago
» Replies: 80
» Views: 12,387
No text, but a visual cod...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: Antonio García Jiménez
10 hours ago
» Replies: 1,961
» Views: 1,637,835
One author, working a sea...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: ololololo
11 hours ago
» Replies: 1
» Views: 113
Circular text in the Voyn...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: Voynich1234
Yesterday, 12:48 PM
» Replies: 20
» Views: 1,967
Voynichese is a numeric c...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: ololololo
Yesterday, 11:25 AM
» Replies: 296
» Views: 67,281
f57v – Are the empty ring...
Forum: Physical material
Last Post: Jorge_Stolfi
Yesterday, 07:04 AM
» Replies: 13
» Views: 1,234
Poll on f116v Voynichese ...
Forum: Marginalia
Last Post: Jorge_Stolfi
21-11-2026, 11:10 PM
» Replies: 7
» Views: 700

 
  The nymphs are possibly inspired from Dante manuscripts
Posted by: JustAnotherTheory - 11-09-2026, 09:14 AM - Forum: Imagery - Replies (43)

This is a follow-up to this thread: 

You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. 

in which I discovered a possible connection between the VMS nymphs and 15th century Italian illustrated Dante manuscripts.

I will show some concrete examples below. All of the pictures below are from 14th and 15th century Dante manuscripts.

   

   

   

   

   

   

Could the VMS nymphs section be inspired by Dante manuscript(s)? Could it somehow be a representation of a female version of Dante's hell?

Print this item

  Just an hypothesis in my mind.
Posted by: A.R.B.C.J - 10-09-2026, 12:49 PM - Forum: Theories & Solutions - Replies (4)

Hi everyone, I'm new here! Please keep in mind that this is purely a contextual hypothesis/theory rather than a definitive linguistic solution, but I wanted to share a scenario I've been developing.

I would like to propose a contextual hypothesis regarding the Voynich manuscript’s origin that addresses both its fluent, multi-scribe creation and its sudden erasure from the historical record. I hypothesize that the manuscript originated within a small, highly exclusive, and wealthy esoteric cult led by a charismatic visionary experiencing religious psychosis. The bizarre illustrations represent the leader’s divine, symbolic visions of a cosmocentric, non-Abrahamic theology, dictated aloud to the members. To preserve the "holiness" of these revelations, the affluent members funded the expensive vellum and developed a fluid, uniform writing system—acting as a sacred literacy barrier over their native spoken tongue. To maintain spiritual purity for divination, the group took a strict vow of total isolation, misleading their neighbors into believing they were simply moving away. Upon eventually being discovered by hostile outsiders, the group executed a desperate pact, dissolving their auxiliary records in chemical acid and self-destructing to preserve their secrets, leaving only this single holy book behind with a trusted child bound by a strict divine curse. Generations later, a final descendant fulfilled the vow by trading the text to an influential figure (likely entering the court of Rudolph II) before vanishing entirely, perfectly explaining the manuscript's internal consistency alongside its absolute lack of early provenance.

Ty for reading!

Print this item

  Quires 14 and 15 acquired as two large off-cuts?
Posted by: Jorge_Stolfi - 10-09-2026, 11:48 AM - Forum: Physical material - Replies (1)

The "regular" VMS folios, like those in Herbal, are listed as measuring ~160 by ~230 mm, meaning that each "regular" bifolio is about ~320 x ~230 mm.

You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view., that allow a sheet of one size to be cut or folded into two halves with the same aspect ratio.  Specifically, each bifolio of the VMS is close to the ISO C4 size 324 by 229  mm, which is the size of an envelope suitable for a document in the common A4 paper format.

Quires 14 and 15, 17, and 19 consist of larger "non-regular" sheets. (Quires 16 and 18 are assumed to have been lost after the folios were numbered.)

Quire 14, the Rosettes fold-out, has a single sheet with two rows of three flaps.  Four of the flaps are fairly rectangular with about the same width as a regular folio. (The top left flap, however, seems to have a curved top edge and to be a bit shorter vertically.)   The two rightmost flaps have an irregular right edge and vary in width from ~130 to ~145 mm.

The inner "bifolio" of quire 15, f88+f89 has four flaps: two fairly rectangular ones with normal dimensions, then a slightly narrower one, ~145 mm wide, and a very narrow one with very irregular right edge, ~110 mm wide.  (The latter is also ~5 mm shorter vertically.)

Another "bifolio" with four flaps is f99+f102, the outer "bifolio" of quire 19.  Like the one above, it has two "regular" flaps, then one that is a bit narrower  has only three flaps.  The first two have "regular" shape and size; the third one is still fairly rectangular but a bit narrower, ~130 mm;  and the fourth one has an irregular edge and is very narrow, from ~30 mm at the bottom to ~50 mm at the top. (The third flap is missing a triangular piece at the bottom corner adjacent to flap 2.)

It s proposed that the Author obtained the vellum of quires 14-19 as a set of six off-cuts whose height was twice that of a regular folio, ~460 mm, with two straight horizontal edges and one straight vertical edge,  whose width varied irregularly between ~480 and ~640 mm, like the "B" and "C" red outlines below:

   

It is conjectured that the vellum maker or the merchant intended to cut the prepared skins into sheets of 640 by 460 mm (close to the ISO C2 paper), as per the blue outline above.  A sheet of that size would have been a bifolio of a book twice as tall and wide as the VMS.  Let's say that it would sell for 10 pazoozas. 

However he would get many off-cuts like the red outlines above.  Presumably he would further cut any one with an "A" outline along the dashed vertical line to produce a "C3" sheet, suitable as a bifolio of a book 40% wider and taller as the VMS.  Let's say that it would sell for 4 ₽. 

On the other hand, an off-cut with "B" or "C" outline would be offered "as is" to any consumer who could use them.  Its market price would be somewhere between 4 and 10 ₽ -- say, 6 ₽.  

So the Author would have acquired a bunch of those "B" or "C" off-cuts. He used a whole "B" one, trimming the irregular edge, for the Rosettes diagram.  He cut the others horizontally, using the "B" ones for "bifolios" with three "regular" flaps, like f87+f90, and the "C" ones for "bifolios" with three-and-a-half flaps, like f88+f89.

Makes sense?

All the best, --stolfi

Print this item

  Hypotheses on the Botanical Folios: A Functional Encryption System
Posted by: A.Weiss - 09-09-2026, 08:28 PM - Forum: Theories & Solutions - Replies (9)

Dear Voynich Community,

As a newcomer to the study of the Voynich manuscript, I would like to share a series of hypotheses regarding the identification of its botanical folios. Unlike many researchers, I initially explored the Voynich Manuscript without prior knowledge of its extensive scholarly history. Instead, I focused on the visual and functional aspects of its botanical illustrations.


What struck me most was the deliberate distortion of certain plants, which seemed to serve a purpose beyond mere artistic representation. For example, the discrepancy between the well-designed parts (such as flowers or leaves) and the seemingly arbitrary elements (like the square roots in folio 53r) suggests intentionality. Additionally, the absence of labels—either visually in the text or on the illustrations—reinforced my assumption that both the text and the drawings are coded.


This led me to a critical question: How can we accurately identify plants in an encrypted manuscript?


Given the manuscript’s apparent objective—not to create a herbal dictionary or a copy of existing designs for knowledge dissemination—it seems the content was intended to be accessible only to those with prior knowledge of plants or medicine. This aligns with the idea of a restricted audience, such as medieval apothecaries or physicians.


Proposed Rules for Decoding the Botanical Section:


Based on these observations, I propose that the Voynich’s botanical section operates under the following rules, which I illustrate with examples below:

  1. Functional Emphasis: The shape of a plant hints at its medicinal use, while the inaccurate or distorted parts (roots, leaves, or flowers, depending on the folio) are those not used in medicine. Botanical illustrations prioritize functional utility and overal aspect ( position of the leaves top / bottom, symetrical non symetrical, pointy/round...) over botanical accuracy (norm of description at this time).
  2. Nominal Rebus: Specific shapes or objects are integrated into the drawings to hint at plant names or properties through visual puns or symbolic representations.
  3. Filler Elements: Some parts of the plant are included only to complete the drawing and may explain recurring similarities (reused by the artist to fill gaps). These elements are medicinally irrelevant and often inaccurate, and used to « encrypt » the plant and mislead on its identification.
Identifications and Supporting Evidence

Folio 43v – Aspic Lavender (Lavandula latifolia) and the Snake Rebus
This was my first clue to the system:
  • The flowers (the medicinally relevant part) are accurately depicted as clusters of small blue dots.
  • The leaves are small and spaced, while the roots are an indistinct mass (unused, hence inaccurate).
  • The snake drawing on the left is a nominal rebus, linking the plant to Lavandula latifolia (aspic lavender).
  • A potential connection exists between the flowers in 43v and drawing 135 on folio f100v, row 2, which may confirm the flowers as the usable part of the plant.
  • Comparative illustrations for flowers and pair of leaves:

Folio 47v – Arnica montana
  • The folio displays a basal leaf rosette and composite tripartite flowers.
  • A diagnostic element: two small, stylized mountain peaks at the transition between the stem and root system.
  • Botanically, Arnica montana features a ground-level rosette of ovate leaves and a stem supporting three terminal composite flowers (yellow in nature).
  • The blue color of the flowers may serve as an alchemical marker (medieval humoral theory :cold/purification), encoding its use for cooling contusions and resolving bruising ( hot and red).
  • The mountain rebus at the root is to give clue on the identification (montana).
Folio 90v – Valeriana officinalis ("Cat Herb")
  • The root resembles a feline silhouette, a zoomorphic rebus referencing the plant’s common name and properties (roots attract cats due to volatile compounds like valerenic acid).
  • The symmetrical pointed leaves and complex blue flowers are simplified or filler representations.
  • Comparative illustration for the leaves: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.
  • The flowers are unused in medicine, so their depiction is inaccurate and filler.
Folio 46v – Pteridium aquilinum (Eagle Fern)
  • The root resembles a heraldic eagle with outstretched wings, while the leaves cascade downward with deep, multiple demarcations.
  • The plant’s vascular bundles (visible when the stem is cut) resemble a double-headed eagle, a feature known in medieval botany. (requires further medieval textual confirmation it seems to be a common knowledge but I was not able to track a formal proof).
  • Only the roots are medicinally relevant; the flowers are filler.
  • Comparative illustration for the leaves: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.

Additional Identifications
  • 5v - Orchis anthropophora, Small man in the flower, walking on akink of Ankh cross. The man is directly drawn in the flower, clue: Flower resembles hanging men; binodular root
  • 13r - Gentiana lutea, Large, inverted heart-shaped root; rigid stem, clue: Root symbolizes its cardiotonic use
  • 25v - Artemisia dracunculus, Dense narrow green leaves; small dragon, clue : Dracunculus  means "little dragon" (mnemonics)
  • 34v - Paeonia officinalis, Roots depict two fighting stags, clue: Medieval belief: stags ate roots for strength/wound healing
  • 6v - Ricinus communis, Accurate part = castor bean pods, Aligns with prior identifications
  • 42v - Hypericum perforatum, Strange, pointy star-shaped flower : link to the five petal of the yellow flower as represented here : You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.
  • 89v, row 1 (Illustration 64) / folio 1V - Helleborus foetidus, Root designed as a bear paw, clue : Common medieval name: "bear’s foot" .Probable link with folio 1v two roots like paws with claws ?
  • 49r - Lonicera, Two snakes in the root, clue : Plant coils like a snake ; flowers are the accurate/medicinal part
  • 17v - Centaurea cyanus, Red Eyes in the root ( inflammated eyes) 3 blue flowers on the top with pointy symetrical thine leaves, similar illustration on flower and leaves here : Egerton F21r : You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. ,  You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.

To close this I would like to share some though on Folio 7v. I do not think at all that this plant is Juniper. I think f7v is Arctium lappa and here is why:
  • If it were juniper, the berries (medicinally relevant) would be accurately depicted. Here, only one black dot appears on the leaves and not several.
  • Leaves are detailed and quite accurate: round mass near the ground, growing along a single stem with sporadic leaves, multi-colored (light green, dark green, brown), and small hooks .
  • The dot symbolizes the healing part (leaves) and their use .
  • The hook near the root (biologically inaccurate) hints at the plant’s adhesive property ("sticks like Velcro").
  • Arctium lappa was called "herbe aux teigneux" (herb for ringworm), a visual indicator of its use for tinea cataplasms from the leaves.
  • Reference of these properties are here :You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. BNF Latin 6822 f15V
  • Illustration : Sloane MS4016 You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. : You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.
    For the dot on the leave here a similar treatment there is an italian Historia Plantarum from around 1340-1398 that shows two different plants with the same details here : You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. ,  You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.


Furter Folios with unindentified clues
  • 10v Root resembles a wing, 
  • 22r Stem in a Neron’s cross, 
  • 35r Plant resembles a cup 
  • 55r Right root similar to an elephant

Conclusion: A Structured System of Visual Encryption

The Voynich Manuscript’s botanical illustrations are not botanical failures—they are functional successes. By encoding medicinal utility into visual distortions and rebuses, the manuscript transforms into a compact, encrypted pharmacopoeia, designed for rapid recognition by initiates
This framework resolves longstanding contradictions between botanical realism and the manuscript’s unique iconography.
This system explains:
  • Why some parts are accurate (medicinally relevant).
  • Why others are distorted (irrelevant or filler).
  • Why symbols recur (mnemonics for names/properties).

From the serpent of 43v to the bear’s paw of F89v, each clue is a piece of a puzzle. The iconography operates as a deliberate, rational encryption system.
This challenges the notion that the drawings are fantastical or poorly executed copies, instead positioning them as purposeful, coded representations for those "in the know."

Who else has noticed these patterns?

Happy to exchange further

A.Weiss

Print this item

  Possible related charm for f116v
Posted by: Rafal - 09-09-2026, 02:43 PM - Forum: Marginalia - Replies (19)

I found a charm in a German manuscript that may be relevant to the Voynich charm from the last page:

   

I mean the word "ahia" from VM. Maybe it's not "ahia" after all? In my charm there is something looking a bit similar and also unsure. I marked it for you.

The charm, according to Gemini AI, seems to say:

So schrib diese wort vnd drag sie by dir
Caput xpi [christi] + fons elye + orti ysaie + nasus moysi + libra noe + lingua salomonis + sanguis abel + mens benjamin + abra heliam + gracia iohannis + et pax xpi [christi] hodie et cottidie et semper mecũ [mecum] Amen



So write these words and carry them with you:
Head of Christ + fountain of Elijah + garden of Isaiah + nose of Moses + balance of Noah + tongue of Solomon + blood of Abel + mind of Benjamin + ??? + grace of John + and the peace of Christ today and daily and forever with me. Amen
.

"Abra heliam" doesn't really make sense. Also "abia" and "ahia" don't make sense.

But what if the word is actually some corrupted form of "labia" which is mouth? That would make sense as the charm mentions other body parts. It would mean "mouth of someone".

The man's name is also unsure. Heliam, Hesiam, Hesiim? The working candidates would be Isaiah, Elijah, Jesse and Elisha. However Isaiah and Elijah are already mentioned

Can you read something with more certainty? 
And could "ahia/abra" be labia, both in my example and Voynich Manuscript?

Print this item

  The Voynich Manuscript’s positional entropy collapse
Posted by: Torsten - 08-09-2026, 11:08 PM - Forum: Voynich Talk - Replies (29)

Rod Kinnison published a You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. at Cryptologia: "The Voynich Manuscript’s positional entropy collapse: comparative evidence from languages and ciphers"

You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.

Quote:The Voynich Manuscript exhibits unusually low conditional character entropy and rigid positional constraints that have resisted explanation within linguistic frameworks for more than a century. In this study, I apply a leakage-free, folio-segmented, character-level analysis to the Voynich Manuscript and to a set of natural-language, constructed-language, and cipher control corpora. The analysis measures bigram and trigram bits per character, the marginal gain from higher-order context (ΔBPC), positional cross-entropy within words, and local lexical overlap under minimal edit distance. All experiments employ strict recto–verso train–test separation, transcription-layer isolation, and identical preprocessing across corpora. The results show that Voynichese exhibits a pronounced collapse of medial positional entropy and a consistently small ΔBPC. These properties persist across manuscript sections and transcription layers and are not reproduced by natural or constructed languages under identical conditions. Applying the same analysis to a verbose substitution cipher derived from a Latin source text demonstrates that this cipher reproduces the Voynich statistical profile with high fidelity. Shuffle controls confirm that this profile is destroyed when internal adjacency is randomized, indicating structured generation rather than sampling artifacts.

Print this item

  Technical rebuttal: semantic density and the “Naibbe” verbosity constraint
Posted by: Torsten - 08-09-2026, 11:04 PM - Forum: News - Replies (8)

There is a You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. to the editor by Domingo Delgado: Technical rebuttal: semantic density and the “Naibbe” verbosity constraint"

Quote:Technical rebuttal: semantic density and the “Naibbe” verbosity constraint." Cryptologia, ahead-of-print(ahead-of-print), pp. 1–2

Delgado also wrote at You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. about the paper:

Quote:I’m pleased to share that my paper, “Technical Rebuttal: Semantic Density and the ‘Naibbe’ Verbosity Constraint,” has been accepted for publication in Cryptologia and is now in production with Taylor & Francis.

The paper examines a focused technical question in Voynich Manuscript research: whether short, compact Voynich-like ciphertext units can, in principle, preserve greater local information density than the Naibbe cipher model appears to permit.

Using a deliberately limited toy model, I illustrate how a cipher architecture incorporating positional behavior, nulls, permutation, and abbreviation could encode more plaintext information while retaining compact ciphertext forms.

The paper does not claim a decipherment of the Voynich Manuscript. Its purpose is narrower: to clarify what conclusions can—and cannot—be drawn from the Naibbe model regarding the possible information density of alternative Voynich-like cipher systems.

Print this item

  The Voynich Manuscript: Understanding the Untranslatable with Lisa Fagin Davis
Posted by: Torsten - 08-09-2026, 09:39 PM - Forum: Voynich Talk - Replies (43)

There is a You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. about the Voynich manuscript with Lisa Fagin Davis: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.

Quote:The Voynich Manuscript has been a curiosity and mystery for hundreds of years – what can its strange history teach us about worldbuilding? This week, we’re joined by Lisa Fagin Davis, one of the world’s experts on this enigmatic text. Come along as we discuss the history of the text, its creation and contents, and how the sciences and humanities can come together using tools like latent semantic analysis to discover the nature of untranslatable texts.

Print this item

  A question about f93r, Aizoaceae/vygies
Posted by: Adilah - 08-09-2026, 08:00 PM - Forum: Theories & Solutions - Replies (3)

Hello everyone,
I'm very much an interested amateur rather than a Voynich researcher, so please forgive me if I'm overlooking an identification that has already been discussed.
I've been looking at You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. and had a rather strange botanical thought.
The upper structure immediately reads to me as some kind of flower, but I started wondering whether it might instead represent a dried flower or fruit/seed capsule, particularly when the entire plant is considered rather than the reproductive structure in isolation.
I'm South African, and I grew up familiar with vygies (Aizoaceae). Some vygies have thick, spreading/ground-covering foliage and distinctive flowers that, when dried, leave a very different-looking reproductive structure. The visual resemblance between the Voynich drawing and a dried vygie/seed capsule caught my attention.
I am not suggesting that You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. is a vygie. The historical/geographical problem is obvious, and I don't have the botanical expertise to make that claim.
What I'm wondering is something more basic:
Could the apparent “flower” in You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. actually be a fruit/seed capsule or post-flowering structure?
And, if so:
Does the structure resemble any known plant family more closely when interpreted as a reproductive structure rather than a flower?
Does the apparently thick/spreading foliage support any particular family or growth habit?
Are there Aizoaceae or unrelated Old World plants with sufficiently similar morphology that the resemblance could be more than superficial?
Has anyone previously compared this particular Voynich illustration with succulent groundcover plants or Aizoaceae?
More generally, how much confidence should we place in the apparent flower/leaf/root morphology when assessing Voynich plants, given the possibility of artistic distortion?
One reason I'm asking is that some Voynich plants seem remarkably convincing while others are, frankly, spectacularly strange. ?
That made me wonder whether we're sometimes judging the botanical accuracy of the whole illustration when perhaps the artist was much more accurate about certain features than others.
So I'm curious what people who have spent far more time with the manuscript see here.
Am I seeing a meaningful botanical resemblance, or have I simply found another excellent example of the human brain being extremely good at finding patterns?
I'd genuinely love to hear the botanists/illustration specialists/long-time Voynich researchers weigh in.
Thank you!



Attached Files Thumbnail(s)
                   
Print this item

  f89, f102: folds planned, then shifted towards spine?
Posted by: Koen G - 08-09-2026, 05:30 PM - Forum: Physical material - Replies (5)

I don't know if this has been discussed before, but I noticed something strange about f89 and f102. There may be other foldouts as well, but I found these two the clearest. In both cases, on the recto and the verso (so four "pages"), the scribe takes into account a fold that's somewhat visible on the parchment. Gaps are left in the text block, or the whole block is confined to one side of the fold line. However, in both cases, the actual folding line that came to be used in the codex is shifted inward, i.e. the fold came to be closer to the spine.

   

   

What this tells us is that the scribe planned for a fold, more or less on the location where a previous fold is still visible. But this fold did not become the preferential one, with both sheets becoming more folded inward.

I wonder what could be deduced from this, if anything, especially with misbinding and singulions in mind. Is the current preferential fold required to fit the foldout into the codex? Maybe someone misfolded the flap before storing the MS for a long time? Although then it would be a coincidence that both foldouts show a similar shift.

Print this item