| Welcome, Guest |
You have to register before you can post on our site.
|
| Online Users |
There are currently 1832 online users. » 6 Member(s) | 1819 Guest(s) Applebot, Baidu, Bing, DuckDuckGo, Facebook, Google, Yandex, enpoleonking, LiviuV, Mark Knowles
|
| Latest Threads |
First Ideas by a new user
Forum: Analysis of the text
Last Post: pjburkshire
58 minutes ago
» Replies: 1
» Views: 57
|
The 'Chinese' Theory: Fo...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: Jorge_Stolfi
3 hours ago
» Replies: 1,109
» Views: 454,809
|
f58v Visual Code, Weird S...
Forum: Imagery
Last Post: nablator
6 hours ago
» Replies: 26
» Views: 1,521
|
Old Czech (Bohemian) or M...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: pjburkshire
9 hours ago
» Replies: 80
» Views: 12,385
|
No text, but a visual cod...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: Antonio García Jiménez
10 hours ago
» Replies: 1,961
» Views: 1,637,804
|
One author, working a sea...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: ololololo
11 hours ago
» Replies: 1
» Views: 112
|
Circular text in the Voyn...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: Voynich1234
11 hours ago
» Replies: 20
» Views: 1,951
|
Voynichese is a numeric c...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: ololololo
Yesterday, 11:25 AM
» Replies: 296
» Views: 67,280
|
f57v – Are the empty ring...
Forum: Physical material
Last Post: Jorge_Stolfi
Yesterday, 07:04 AM
» Replies: 13
» Views: 1,234
|
Poll on f116v Voynichese ...
Forum: Marginalia
Last Post: Jorge_Stolfi
21-11-2026, 11:10 PM
» Replies: 7
» Views: 699
|
|
|
| Entropy and visual aesthetics |
|
Posted by: Grzechu - 23-09-2026, 09:04 PM - Forum: Voynich Talk
- Replies (1)
|
 |
It's my first post and English is not my mother tongue. Some thoughts about entropy and the visual aspects of Voynichese, if I understand it correctly. Without delving deep into statistics or using technical language.
Much has been written about low entropy of the glyphs, but it seems to me that it is usually considered in isolation from the visual compatibility of that glyphs or the visual aesthetics of the script (call it what you will; it is largely subjective, dependent on human feelings and individual preferences – and harder to define, yet its existence cannot be denied). In my view, this yields in an incomplete picture of the puzzle, because these two issues are inextricably linked.
It is possible to use glyphs from the VMS to write a “text” with much lower entropy than actual Voynichese but without regard for that kind of aesthetics. I'm mean a system in which the shape of the individual glyphs themselves does not suggest a more or less probable order. An example below.
Is the low conditional entropy intentional, or is it rather a side effect of text production, much like many of its other statistical properties that the author of the VMS might not have even cared about?
If the text is meaningless and was primarily intended to “look nice” and alongside the illustrations to imitate only a genuine herbal, a treatise on women's health, astronomy etc. (while also being easy to replicate through minor modifications), then low entropy is merely a side effect.
If Voynichese conceals some meaning (whether it is a natural or artificial language, or a cipher), then the author must have focused primarily on that semantic meaning of the source text – a task far, far, far more difficult than merely attending to the aesthetic aspect of a pseudo-text.
No one has succeeded in creating a genuine cipher similar to Voynichese. I'm setting aside discussions regarding a “verbose cipher”, though that approach also presents a number of problems.
In any case the codemakers always (almost always?) want to conceal any patterns in the ciphertext, they strive for the highest possible entropy and are not care of visual aesthetics.
To put it simply: the creators of writing systems were likely guided by the goal of representing the sounds of a given language in graphic form. They certainly did not create alphabets with the intention that some letters would visually harmonize with some others – or fail to do so – to varying degrees; that would have been a major limitation.
Below are an ordinary text and the anagramm version. Does anyone who doesn't speak Polish find either of them visually or aesthetically more cohesive or “valid”?
An ordinary Georgian text and the text with randomly shuffled letters
An ordinary Russian and Ceasar cipher
Letters are combined to each other to graphically record words that carry semantic meaning, not because one letter looks more elegant next to the another. Orthography and spelling rules have nothing to do with the shape of the letters.
Unless such writing systems exist?
(One might say: positional variants, like in Arabic. But it’s something else, and in my opinion, that doesn’t really explain the VMS).
The same applies to word length – it is determined by the meaning of the words, not by the available writing space (such as wrapping around an illustration or the end of a line).
But Voynichese works differently. It is a unique script, likely created for the one project only.
It's “orthography” is based on a set of rules that some are attempting to describe or systematize. Many regularities are evident and well-known, yet there is no comprehensive, definitive theory.
And there is a very important remark: essentially, there are no hard-and-fast rules, because exceptions can always be found. For example, EVA-i is typically preceded by EVA-a and followed by another EVA-i or EVA-n, sometimes EVA-r or EVA-m (glyphs based on a diagonal stroke and – one might say – visually compatible). However, on f107r, there are “weird” vords as “okirol”, “okil” (appearing twice, one with the “k” strangely connected to the “i”), “qokiil”, “otiir” (if I am “reading” it correctly), and also “taidy”. Are these “errors”, “exceptions” or rather the result of the author not being bound by any rules, free to experiment or indulge in momentary whims?
Someone wrote on this forum that vords ending in “e” look unfinished. Why does a final “e” look bad, while a final “ey” or “edy” look nice? Is it unfathomable orthography, a mysterious encryption algorithm, or simply subjective aesthetic preference?
There is common English pair “th” or “ch” and uncommon “cj” or “gv”; there is common Voynichese EVA-kch or EVA-or and uncommon or rare EVA-er, EVA-ni or EVA-ag. Are those things comparable?
Are certain vords “invalid” due to entropy (or “grammar”?), or rather because of aesthetic considerations?
Perhaps the EVA-ra pair (a line-based glyph followed by the one with the shape of a curve on its left side) or EVA-ld might seem “invalid” to some modern researchers, but for the author, it was perfectly valid?
Maybe for the author the EVA-in and EVA-or pairs looked equally aesthetically and it doesn't matter whether the adjacent glyphs are based on a diagonal stroke, a curve, or something else?
Perhabs the author himself might have considered the vords like aiip or daiidy “uglier” or less preferable, yet he left such vords as they were and did not cross anything out?
Maybe in most vords with final EVA-ny, the EVA-y served merely to fill space at the end of a line or next to an illustration?
And so on, and so forth...
Before the Manuscript was written, a set of glyphs had to be devised. Perhaps the creative process – whatever inspired the author – simply unfolded in such a way that, through trial and error, in some sense by chance, a collection of glyphs emerged with characteristics allowing some to fit together visually better than others (while also enabling many of glyphs to be used interchangeably to easily generate new vords). And this was enough to achieve the primary goal: cool-looking gibberish, “an elegant enigma”?
Or is it more likely that all this elegance, the “dance of glyphs”, was merely an accompaniment to the fundamental objective of encoding actual content? An accompaniment that was a side effect (is this even possible?), or an accompaniment that makes the encryption algorithm much more complex?
While writing these subjective reflections, I also had in mind the work of various people, including Luke Lindemann, Claire Bowern, René Zandbergen, Jorge Stolfi, Torsten Timm, Brian Cham.
|
|
|
| First thought |
|
Posted by: Joerg Fuchs - 23-09-2026, 11:26 AM - Forum: Theories & Solutions
- Replies (13)
|
 |
My first thought when floating over the symbols and pictures was: I´ve seen similar things before. In books and museums regarding to Outsider Art or known as art of people with mental diseases. In Heidelberg / Germany is a very well known museum with art produced by mental disordererd people collected since the 1920s.
Many of those artists were not accepted as artist because they were mentioned as lunatics, crazy ones etc.
But if you take a closer look at certain cases (Heinrich Grebing, Franz-Karl Buehler, Josef Forster et al) you´ll find cryptographed information and drawings of another reality. So what if the Voynich was created by a person with mental illness? I wouldn´t wonder if something like that has happened - and it would make sense because those persons work very detailed and have no limitations in their fantasy. Even if it´s just a thought of mine, you can visit the PRinzhorn Sammlung online You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. as well as you can read a lot of books and articles about it all over the world.
|
|
|
| Could the Voynich Author Be a "Ramanujan-style" Anomaly? |
|
Posted by: chenxiang - 21-09-2026, 12:31 PM - Forum: Voynich Talk
- Replies (33)
|
 |
Body:
Hi everyone. Since the title is quite short, let me expand on it right here: I want to share a thought experiment about whether the author of the Voynich Manuscript could have been a "Ramanujan-style" anomaly.
Let me start by introducing someone I find more and more absurd the more I think about him: Srinivasa Ramanujan. He was an Indian mathematician, born in 1887 and died in 1920, only 32 years old. He had almost no formal higher education in mathematics and taught himself from a book of formulas. Later he wrote to the British mathematician Hardy and enclosed a pile of formulas. Hardy first thought he was a madman, but the more he looked, the more shocked he became.
Ramanujan left behind nearly 4,000 mathematical formulas, propositions, and results. Many had no derivation at all—just answers. He said a goddess told him in his dreams. At the time, many mathematicians couldn't understand them, and some even thought they were nonsense. But later? Most were proven correct, a few were wrong, and many remain unproven to this day. Even more absurdly, his work later showed up in modular forms, black hole entropy, string theory, and other fields. Hardy reportedly rated him 100 and himself 25.
I've always felt Ramanujan was not a genius in the ordinary sense. Several things about him are too anomalous:
No process: often no derivation, just the answer;
Pure intuition: as if he could directly "see" the result in his head;
Sustained output: not one lucky hit, but thousands of results;
High accuracy: most were later confirmed to be correct;
Ahead of his time: many results were only understood decades or centuries later;
Mysterious origin: he said a goddess came to him in dreams; no one can explain how he did it.
So some people say Ramanujan's existence shows that the upper limit of humanity is not a fixed ceiling, but a hole that is occasionally punched through by some anomaly.
Then I thought of the Voynich Manuscript. It is a medieval book, carbon-dated to around 1404–1438. It is full of an unknown script, with illustrations of plants, astronomy, human figures, and so on. For centuries, no one has been able to decipher it. It is not simple gibberish, because its statistical features resemble those of natural language—word frequency, information entropy, and so on look like language. Who wrote it, what the script is, and why it was written remain a complete mystery.
So I had a thought experiment: If Ramanujan could write down large numbers of formulas that no one understood at the time and that were later verified, could the author of the Voynich Manuscript also have been some kind of “Ramanujan-style” anomaly?
Not Ramanujan in the mathematical sense, but rather: someone who had a system in his head that we still cannot decode, or who could directly “see” some kind of structure and wrote it down in an unknown script. We can't understand it, just as people at the time couldn't understand Ramanujan.
If we put Ramanujan and the Voynich Manuscript author side by side, the shared ingredients might be:
No process: Ramanujan had no derivations; the manuscript has no process we can read;
Pure intuition: Ramanujan said a goddess came to him in dreams; the manuscript author may also have drawn on some kind of intuition or mystical system we don't understand;
Sustained output: Ramanujan left nearly 4,000 results; the manuscript is also many pages of sustained writing;
High accuracy / ahead of its time: Ramanujan has been verified; if there is real knowledge behind the manuscript, it might also be correct and ahead of its time—we just can't verify it;
Mysterious origin: Ramanujan's source is mysterious; the manuscript's author, script, and purpose are all unknown.
Of course, the biggest difference is: Ramanujan's work can be verified. A mathematical formula is either right or wrong, and later generations can prove it. The Voynich Manuscript cannot be verified. We haven't even found its encoding rules, so we have no idea whether there is real knowledge in it at all.
So I'm not saying the manuscript is definitely real knowledge, nor that its author was definitely a second Ramanujan. I just think Ramanujan's existence suggests there may have been more than one of these “glitch accounts” in human history. Some left behind verifiable mathematics; others left behind a black box we still can't open.
Could the Voynich Manuscript be that kind of black box? If there really is knowledge behind it, could its author also be a Ramanujan-style figure? Only instead of leaving verifiable formulas, he left a system we haven't been able to crack for centuries.
I'm only 16, so this is just a speculation. I know there are probably many counterarguments, but I still wanted to put it out there as an idea.
|
|
|
| Alchemy Theory |
|
Posted by: Maks1 - 21-09-2026, 11:19 AM - Forum: Voynich Talk
- Replies (76)
|
 |
Let me clarify right away: I did not use AI or anything like that. I don't speak English, so I used a translator. I apologize for any errors.
Have a good day! Could you tell me if you are considering the alchemical theory? The first symbols in the text resemble the graphic symbols of alchemy from that period. It seems to me that the botanical section graphically shows the apparatus itself or part of it and the reaction taking place inside it, represented by plants and roots. Perhaps it even encodes the element used. In the text, the first symbol denotes the process of heating, cooling, and so on. Then comes the result. It seems to me that it is about obtaining some element through distillation. I think the author was experimenting and mixing substances, and perhaps was describing not formulas, but what they saw with their own eyes — the reaction process itself. What do you think about this? Are there similar theories? Could you tell me what devices were used in the past to tell time?
|
|
|
| Mariano Sozzini the Elder's students |
|
Posted by: JustAnotherTheory - 20-09-2026, 10:57 AM - Forum: Theories & Solutions
- Replies (2)
|
 |
So the idea recently came to me that the VMS might have been the prooduct of students at a school or university, who were studying a profession that was unrelated to scribal work or professionnal writing. Such a hypothesis has already been advanced several times on this forum, by some prominent members. Some have even suggested that the VMS writing looks like that of an apprentice lawyer.
So this prompted me to look for handwriting examples of Italian university students in faculties of law in the first half of the 15th Century. There are not a lot of examples of this, as you might imagine. However, I got lucky, as some students in Siena's university of law actually did leave some written records behind.
In particular, there was a group af about 12 students there, studying under Mariano Sozzini (the elder), who was a prominent lawyer who became famous because he taught the future Pope Pius II (You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view., in French as there is no Enlgish article available). These students often exchanged notes, and as it turns out they even coollaborated on a common student's notebook during Sozzini's afternoon classes.
This notebook, Recollectae super quibusdam libri II Decretalium, is unfortunately in private hands. However, on the bookseller's webpage, we can see some (low resolution) scans of certain pages:
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.
One page particularly stands out:
Many other pages seem to have a Voynich-y feel to their handwriting. Note that among these students, there were several who were German and others Italian. I tried to track them down, and I found the name of the German student: Nicolaus Vetter. He wrote another treatise on Sizzini's courses later in Germany, it is preserved in Valenciennes, BM, MS 261, which is once again unfortunately not available as it is not digitised.
But since we are talking about Siena, I was wondering whether these students could have had any access to Taccola's material, as he was a resident of Siena at this time. Recall that there are several hypotheses about the involvement of at least one Taccola notebook in Quire 13 of the VMS:
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.
It turns out, that there is a connection between Taccola and Sozzini. According to a recent study on Taccola's life, On 8 December 1438, Taccola showed Sozzini his drawings from his De ingeneis at Sozzini's home in Siena:
Link to the study:
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.
This MS is today referred to as Munich, Clm 197 II and is present in several comparisons between Taccola's work and Quire 13 of the VMS.
So now we have: - A documented evidence, that Taccola showed at least one of his notebooks to Sozzini,
- Sozzini's students often collaborated together,
- The students produced at least one common manuscript together,
- The students were of German and Italian origin.
|
|
|
| [split] Early 15thC German Herbal & Bestiary (Augsburg, Cod. II.1.2° 109) |
|
Posted by: DG97EEB - 19-09-2026, 10:02 PM - Forum: Voynich Talk
- Replies (30)
|
 |
I don't think this Manuscript has been discussed You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.
It's Augsburg, early 15th Century herbal and bestiary. .. I have looked at my own archive and Google and it hasn't turned up... It was owned by a prominent Artz/apothecary family whose work later appeared in a Hartlieb..
c. 1403–1409: Produced in southern Germany on paper; some later additions use paper dated 1428–1436.
1407: A note records a visit by Anzinus, son of Jörg Tömlinger, a Munich apothecary, placing the manuscript in a Munich pharmaceutical milieu.
Contains extensive medical, pharmaceutical and herbal material, including more than 200 plant images, followed by an illustrated bestiary of about 73 animal species.
By the 15th century it belonged to the Benedictine abbey of St Mang at Füssen, confirmed by an ownership inscription.
After the abbey was secularised in 1803, its library passed to the Oettingen-Wallerstein collection.
In 1980 Bavaria acquired that library; the manuscript is now Universitätsbibliothek Augsburg, Cod. II.1.2° 109.
I can't find any information about who created it...
|
|
|
Imagine If... Was the Voynich Just a Notebook of Scientific Dreams? |
|
Posted by: Abdelwahab Rahmani - 19-09-2026, 03:41 AM - Forum: Theories & Solutions
- Replies (5)
|
 |
The manuscript is the individual and spontaneous work of a European polymath, written slowly and fluidly from left to right with regular spacing that reflects a real language. However, it is stripped of small grammatical words (such as conjunctions) due to the author's need for a condensed, telegraphic style that focuses on the core terms of hypothetical ideas. The motive behind the simplicity of the drawings and the casual coloring—which occasionally bleeds outside the lines—is neither art, deception, nor an attempt to commercialize the book. Rather, it is a purely scientific drive, oscillating between "passionate inner monologue" and the recording of "dream-like visions" of non-existent, hypothetical plants and cosmic configurations. Ultimately, the manuscript forms a personal notebook designed to preserve scientific suggestions and aspirations far ahead of its time, hidden behind an invented cipher alphabet to protect the author's intellectual freedom during a highly oppressive political and religious era (1404–1438).
What confirms this personal, non-utilitarian identity of the book is the absolute absence of any motive for fame or trade on the part of its author. It is completely illogical for someone seeking fame and money to formulate their thoughts in an obscure language that no one understands, which perfectly explains why the manuscript remained isolated and hidden in the shadows for more than two centuries before ever reaching the hands of an emperor or a king. It appears that this scholar's intellectual journey was abruptly cut short by a forced event during that turbulent era—such as being forcibly taken away when the rulers' soldiers raided his home and confiscated his research, or the book being stolen from him, or perhaps he hid it in a secret place and died without telling anyone. Thus, it remained shrouded in secrecy until its location was discovered a generation or two after his death, which preserved its absolute confidentiality and prevented any copies or imitations of its unique alphabet from appearing in history.
The strongest candidate to be the author of this manuscript could be the polymath Giovanni Fontana. In that exact era, he faced official accusations and persecution for practicing black magic and heresy due to his forward-looking machines that were ahead of his time. Consequently, he was forced to cipher his writings and tighten secrecy to protect his life. He was entirely isolated from the political and scientific environment until he died in total isolation and obscurity around 1455, with no mention of his burial site or the circumstances of his death. Furthermore, his works and ciphered notebooks were indeed confiscated by the Church and government authorities to be banned from publication and entirely forgotten, and attempts were made to erase his identity by rewriting some of his works under pseudonyms of other figures. As a result, his name remained wiped out and unknown in history books for centuries until his notebooks were discovered by chance in the modern era. Even if Fontana himself was not the author, this identical oppressive environment and the documented political and historical background of a "forced event" certainly and definitively confirm everything reached and established in this theory.
|
|
|
|