Welcome, Guest
You have to register before you can post on our site.

Username/Email:
  

Password
  





Search Forums

(Advanced Search)

Online Users
There are currently 1833 online users.
» 6 Member(s) | 1820 Guest(s)
Applebot, Baidu, Bing, DuckDuckGo, Facebook, Google, Yandex, enpoleonking, LiviuV, Mark Knowles

Latest Threads
First Ideas by a new user
Forum: Analysis of the text
Last Post: pjburkshire
58 minutes ago
» Replies: 1
» Views: 57
The 'Chinese' Theory: Fo...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: Jorge_Stolfi
3 hours ago
» Replies: 1,109
» Views: 454,809
f58v Visual Code, Weird S...
Forum: Imagery
Last Post: nablator
6 hours ago
» Replies: 26
» Views: 1,521
Old Czech (Bohemian) or M...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: pjburkshire
9 hours ago
» Replies: 80
» Views: 12,385
No text, but a visual cod...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: Antonio García Jiménez
10 hours ago
» Replies: 1,961
» Views: 1,637,804
One author, working a sea...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: ololololo
11 hours ago
» Replies: 1
» Views: 112
Circular text in the Voyn...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: Voynich1234
11 hours ago
» Replies: 20
» Views: 1,951
Voynichese is a numeric c...
Forum: Theories & Solutions
Last Post: ololololo
Yesterday, 11:25 AM
» Replies: 296
» Views: 67,280
f57v – Are the empty ring...
Forum: Physical material
Last Post: Jorge_Stolfi
Yesterday, 07:04 AM
» Replies: 13
» Views: 1,234
Poll on f116v Voynichese ...
Forum: Marginalia
Last Post: Jorge_Stolfi
21-11-2026, 11:10 PM
» Replies: 7
» Views: 699

 
  Traces of a wheel or similar
Posted by: takrobat - 01-10-2026, 07:15 AM - Forum: Analysis of the text - Replies (12)

Hi,

I have been studying the text statistically the last days, and want to know if anyone else have noticed this.
I know tavie and MarcoP have shown that a line's first glyph depends on the line above, what I have found is that there is some sort of direction to this. Among d, q and y, consecutive line starts step d -> q -> y -> d more often than the reverse.

Example : 
<f79v.13,+P0>    dain.ar.olshey.dytain.qokain.checthy.okeedy.qokeedy.ror
<f79v.14,+P0>    qokeey.qokedy.okeey.qokol.sheedy.qokeedy.rolchey.qokeedy
<f79v.15,+P0>    yteedy.qokeedy.qokain.olkeey.cheokain.dy,teey.qokain
<f79v.16,+P0>    dol.sheey.qol.olkshey.qokeedy.olkeedy.qol.okaiin.oly

These are the counts for the whole manuscript:
forward:  d→q 125  q→y 75  y→d 119  (total 319)
backward:  q→d 75    y→q 35  d→y 81    (total 191)

Total the wheel moves forward 63% of the time (expected 50%). The difference is about 5.7 standard deviations from the expected. Permutation tests give the same result (p<0.0001).

Frequencies alone can not produce this, if it had fixed probablities (50% d, 30% q, 20% y) the count would be expected to be the same in both directions (0.5*0.3==0.3*0.5). 

This is valid through the whole document, not just parts of it. It could appear everywhere. 

It also seems like ONLY the line preceding the line counts. Both lines need to have d,q or y to see this pattern. If one line appears between them, the pattern disappears (or so my initial investiagation shows). It seems like the scribe looks at the preceding line ONLY when dealing with d,q,y changes. There is no hidden "counter" keeping track.

The first line of a paragraph is outside (often other glyphs). 

What I have checked:
Two transcriptions give the same result (ZL3b and voynichese.com)
Currier A,B and different scribes all follow the "rule".
It goes from start to start, not a seam between line breaks.
It is JUST the first glyph - no matter what the rest of the word is.
Currier A also has a similar rule, it seems : y-o-q-y
I can not find any direction anywhere else line to line.


What does it mean? 
It could mean that some rule is governing these letters. It *could* be a wheel that is cycled, or some sort of weighted random variable. It seems like they move forward 2 of 3 times, roughly. Backwards 1/3 of the time.

Print this item

  Voynich In Person
Posted by: medievalmaxxer - 30-09-2026, 05:18 PM - Forum: Voynich Talk - Replies (6)

Theoretical question: If you ever had the chance to see the Voynich in person, what's one thing you would look for/prioritize that's harder to see digitally/would only come across in person?

Print this item

  Zodiac Construction
Posted by: rikforto - 29-09-2026, 06:29 PM - Forum: Astrology & Astronomy - Replies (3)

I am putting together some data related to degrees of the zodiac and I would like to present it next to the corresponding entries in the Zodiac section. This requires me to make judgements about what those are. I have my own sense of the pages, but I am wondering exactly how much opinions vary in the community. I realize some of you all are going to reject the idea that there is an order or that they represent degrees, but for those of you willing to play along, a few questions:

  1. Where do you start the count of nymphs/labels/whatevers on each page?
  2. Do you count clockwise or counterclockwise?
  3. Do you see the rows staring from the middle or the outside? (Or in another order?)
  4. Do you account for the Aires and Taurus rounds in any unusual way, like the second one first?
Elaborate as much as you want! I welcome guesses, expressions of doubt, and points you've gone back and forth on! I just want to take the temperature of the room.

Anyway, looking forward to learning that we're even further from consensus than I would have guessed before Wink

My answers, which I have some uncertainty about:
  1. After the double lines when in evidence; about 9'o'clock paying attention to the gallows letters in the running text for hard to judge cases.
  2. Clockwise, with some misgivings
  3. Start from the inside, working out
  4. Aires and Taurus in their binding order

Print this item

  Color of the water on f79v as an indicator of religious cleanliness
Posted by: Not_A_Corncob - 28-09-2026, 11:15 PM - Forum: Imagery - Replies (17)

Hey everyone!

Apologies if this page has already been done to death.  I just keep looking at the tubes pages and thinking about what they might mean.

I kept thinking about how odd the water is.  In some pages, it's blue!  In others, it's green.

I was thinking about how stoic some of the green water people looked, and started looking at other manuscripts.

Laufenberg's regimen of health has a depiction of what I think is Jesus' descent into hell, but please correct me if I'm wrong.  My medieval German is, uh, not conversational.

Here is the image in question: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.

Now, I have yet to find a 15th century manuscript that depicts hell as green, but it got me thinking about similar concepts.

On f79v, on the top left, there is a woman with a cross under an umbrella shape.  I cannot tell if the shape is meant to represent a basin of pure water, or the firmament.

[Image: image.jpg?ref=f79v&q=f79v-255-64-423-357...&caption=1]

Notice how she is standing upright, holding a cross.

Below her is a woman lounging on her back, wearing some kind of head covering and some kind of wring, bracelet or shackle.

[Image: image.jpg?ref=f79v&q=f79v-249-297-475-48...&caption=1]

She is being sprayed in the face by the water up above, which is a little funny.

Below her, the water comes out green.

[Image: image.jpg?ref=f79v&q=f79v-249-720-297-50...&caption=1]

It's interesting to me that the water coming into this basin is green, but the water in the other pipes is still blue.  The figure on this tier doesn't seem to be immersed in water at all!

From below this section, it looks like blue water comes out of one spout, but then the other tubes feeding into the funnel have green in them.  Below that, you have the green water splashing down into the green pool that has the fish eating the woman (or mermaid, per other threads) and the various beasties.

[Image: image.jpg?ref=f79v&q=f79v-254-953-409-89...&caption=1]


Water used as an allegorical substance wouldn't be out of the question in the medieval world. The bible has lots of references to ritual cleanliness, living waters, and the like. The exordium magnum cistercience refers to the cistercian order as a pure fountain.  I do not have a facsimile of this document, but this paper on medieval water symbolism has a translated quote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.



"""
Here begins the narrative of the beginning of the Cistercian Order, how our fathers left the monastery of Molesme in order to recover the purity of the Order according to the Rule of St Benedict and founded the fertile house of Cîteaux which is the mother of all our houses, since from her, as if from the purest fountain, the rivers of all the churches of our Order flow (Burton and Kerr, 2011: 21, italics in original).
"""

folio You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. has more water imagery, this time seemingly only of clean water.  Right near the top, we see a woman in a hair covering on top of either a cistern or possibly a smaller version of the figure on the previous page, which I took to be either a cistern or a representation of the firmament.

[Image: image.jpg?ref=f80r&q=f80r-597-34-389-323...&caption=1]

At this point, I'm starting to go cross-eyed from zooming in on all these tubes and ponds to inspect the water color and the faces of the people within the water, so not sure if I'm getting tunnel vision on this one.

What do you all think?

Print this item

  It's a falcon on 80v - with Chaucer's magical ring
Posted by: SherriMM - 28-09-2026, 10:52 PM - Forum: Imagery - Replies (6)

New blog post: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.

In this post, I identify the animal on folio 80v as a falcon (not an armadillo or dragon, etc). I also draw connection with Chaucer's story of The Squire's Tale - in which a princess receives a magical ring that gives her the ability to understand all animals and to know the curing power of herbs, which she uses to heal an injured falcon. Please follow the link for the full explanation. 

I am not necessarily saying that this story of Chaucer's appears in the Voynich, but that perhaps they both drew of an earlier tradition....but also that this animal is totally a falcon. 

Your thoughts?

All the best, 
Sherri



Attached Files Thumbnail(s)
   
Print this item

  Repetition as a positive aesthetic quality
Posted by: npcompl33t - 27-09-2026, 04:40 PM - Forum: Theories & Solutions - Replies (10)

I think many people, myself included, have been frustrated by the amount of repetition in the VM. There is historical precedence for repetitive phrases like 'Holy Holy Holy', etc, but I haven't personally seen examples of historical works that utilize repetition to the extent of Voynich.

Even under the self citation theory, you have to ask: why would they choose to copy the same word consecutively multiple times?

It's obvious that the scribes behind the Voynich manuscript valued aesthetics of the text, regardless of the broader questions around its semantic meaning. As I have been analyzing the VM, I am increasingly starting to suspect that scribes are intentionally choosing to render words in repetitive forms, even when other options may exist.

What if the answer is simply that the scribes viewed the repetition as a positive aesthetic quality?

I'm reminded of the You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. of the medieval minims phrase that appears to be multiple lines of I characters, but actually spells out a complex phrase.

With Voynich, the repetition doesn't necessarily even need to come from ambiguity of characters possibly taking multiple forms (although that could be the case). Maybe others have already suggested this, but it would explain how both extreme atypical repetition and semantic meaning could coexist.

Print this item

  The Seasons of Life on f85r2
Posted by: pjburkshire - 26-09-2026, 06:06 PM - Forum: Imagery - Replies (26)

I watched the recently posted "Voynich Talk" YouTube video.  I agree about the Seasons of Life on f85r2 ; the small plant could be youth and the cane could be old age.  I don't know about the other two being a scholarly introduction and a medical person but they could be.  They could be making observations on the Seasons of Life.

I think the Seasons of Life theme needs to be continued.  The Zodiac is clearly about birth; the beginning of a person's life on Earth.  A person's zodiac sign is based on when they were born.  You know I believe the focus should be on the birth part and not on constellations.

I think you need to go even another step.  There is no birth without a pregnancy.

The Voynich Manuscript is a Christian document.  It is about both physical life on Earth and about spiritual life beyond Earth.

I still believe that the goal in the creation of the Voynich Manuscript was to take medical and spiritual information from Latin (probably multiple sources) and make it available to young men who did not know Latin.

Print this item

  Tiktok Theorist slop
Posted by: medievalmaxxer - 24-09-2026, 06:03 PM - Forum: Voynich Talk - Replies (39)

Hey,

has anyone else seen the current theory floating around Tiktok right now? I feel like I'm going crazy looking at all of it... completely unfounded.

For those of you who haven't seen it, a bunch of new agers are saying that the plants in the VMS (specifically 20r) are grown from period blood and moon water.... based on a video a woman made filming a plant that supposedly grew from her period blood. I won't link specifics for my own sake, but a simple search for the VMS on TikTok reveals a slew of videos that people are making on this. There's also some claims that the VMS was written by a female coven. It's obviously extreme pseudoscience, but I was wondering what y'all thought.

Print this item

  The Fastnachtspiele theory
Posted by: JustAnotherTheory - 24-09-2026, 12:50 PM - Forum: Theories & Solutions - Replies (22)

OK so recently there have been a few discoveries concerning authors of "Fastnachtspiele", a kind of south German pre-Lent carnival play/song tradition in the late 15th, early 16th centuries:

You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.

These discoveries, as it turns out, might be relevant to the history of the VMS, so I thought this deserves its own thread. Several authors of Fastnachtspiele use "pox"-related swearwords. There is a list already here, thanks to @You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. :

You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.

The main authors are, in chronological order of writing pox-swearwords:

  • Hans Rosenplüt (1400-1460),
  • Hans Folz (1435-1513),
  • Hans Sachs (1494-1576).

These 3 "Hans"s are responsible for the majority of pox-swearing in written literature. They were all based in Nürnberg. This is relevant because on the VMS folio f116v, the first word seems to be "poxleber". 

I recently made the observation that Hans Sachs (one of the Hans' above) wrote some text containing "Geis mich":

   

Note that since the last words on the VMS folio You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. appear to be "geis mich", this once again is relevant to the VMS. More information here:

You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.

In fact, there are a lot of instances of "geis mich" like this, perhaps we should make a sticky thread about it, like with "poxleber".

Anyway, going further, I found an interesting manuscript of Hans Folz, the second Hans above. Take a look:

You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.

   

Oh, and what is this?

   

Hans Folz loved to swear with "pox"-words too. In fact, I've counted (manually) about 30 pox-swearwords in this MS alone. Examples are:
  • pox leichnam
  • pox haut
  • pox trost
  • pox lung
  • pox grint

All of which are used in the context of swearing, not literal body parts.

It turns out, this second Hans was a polymath, not just a satyric trickster-playwright. He wrote a book on bathing: Dises puchlein saget vns von allen paden. Here is a woodcut from that:

   

He was also an astrologer, and astronomer. Look at a woodcut from his Practica teutsch meister:

   

The stars seem to be a matching shape for the VMS stars. Folz also wrote several books on medicine, here is a full list:

You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.

His Fastnachtspiele were also, unusually, bound together in a book with occultism:

You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.

Of note is that Folz also wrote a book on engineering:

You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.

Digital scans here:

You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.

   

Look like it is heavily inspired by Konrad Kyeser and Taccola!

I think it's worth looking into these people, even though they lived and published about 50 years later than the carbon dating of the VMS.

I will say one last thing, about the curious handwriting that ressembles EVA "ain" previously. It seems that this is not the handwriting of Hans Folz himself, but a curious individual with unknown origins. A recent study, that you can find here:

You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.

has looked at the authors of the manuscript, and found 5 different hands. 4 of these could be identified, except for the fifth, the one who wrote our EVA-ish text. The researchers identify this person as "Scribe Gb":

Quote:Gb fällt durch Vorlagentreue auf, ein eigenständiger Dialekt kann nicht isoliert werden.

So they cannot identify even the dialect of Scribe Gb.

Quote:Simon vermutet aufgrund der Textauswahl, dass Gb Folz nahestand.

Meaning that the researchers assume, that he was probably close to Folz himself. This is explained because Scribe Gb had intimate knowledge of Hans Folz plays, and copied only Hans Folz plays by hand, and also appeared to have had access to Folz's personal source material because he copied the spelling mistakes from them, too.

Was Scribe Gb somehow involved in the VMS? Could the VMS have been influenced by, or been masterminded by, Hans Folz? Here are some arguments:
  • Pox-swearwords appear abundantly in Hans Folz works.
  • Folz published about bathing, astronomy, astrology, and appeared in at least one occultism manuscript.
  • He published an illustrated engineering book.
  • One of his close friends/relatives seems to write in a curious EVA-like way.
  • Folz often had access to, and used cheap parchment, for sketching out his Fastnachtspiele plays and songs.
  • Folz loved to write funny and satyric material, making fun of nobles and the clergy. Quite the trickster, one might come to think.

_______________________________________

A final bit of curiosa:

The pope Pius II apparently visited Nürnberg, where Folz lived, around that time. This is an interesting coincidence because Pius II studied under Sozzini in Siena, who we know on a 1438 night met with Taccola himself, who showed him his De Ingeneis I-II books in person...

Print this item

  Evidence for 2 rules linking words in Herbal A->B
Posted by: npcompl33t - 24-09-2026, 03:20 AM - Forum: Analysis of the text - Replies (30)

In my opinion, the differences between Herbal A and Herbal B represent one of the most significant challenges in understanding the VM. Each contains words that are very common in one, but completely absent in the other. These changes go beyond simple word selection, as for example the bigram 'ed' is almost non-existent in Herbal A.

You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. that Herbal A and B are not really different languages, and the differences can be explained by scribes encoding or spelling a group of common words in different ways.

For the last few days, I have been attempting to discover one of these 'transformation rules' that would repair the severed word distributions between the two different Herbals, and I think I have found a few that have compelling evidence.


I should also be clear -- these results are ONLY between Early Herbal A and Herbal B, the Later Herbal A / Pharma sections are not included. Some other work I've done, has led me to believe that Herbal B and other 'Currier B' sections contain significant differences comparable to those between Herbal A and B, so including them muddies the analysis. A natural follow-up is to see if similar transformations exist between Herbal A / Herbal B and other sections.


The rules:

  1. interior (ie non-initial) ch -> ed, followed by y (qokchy becomes qokedy, otchy becomes otedy, etc)
  2. interior (ie non-initial) ch -> chd, followed by y ( qotchy becomes qotchdy, qokchy becomes qokchdy)
 
Below, for convienience, i am going to refer to these rules as chy->edy, and chy->chdy, but i want to be clear that these are within-word-edits, not suffix swaps. This is not asserting that everything to the left of the edited portion is a common stem.

Lets go through the evidence:



They transform "Vanishing" A words into "Novel" B words, and the transformed words occur at roughly the same frequencies as the original. 

I will explain this fully for the chy-> edy transformation, along with all of the data.

chy-> edy creates 17 pairs of A -> B words, each listed below.

For each pair of transformed words, we test (a) whether the frequency ORDER of the A words matches the order of their B forms, and whether the MAGNITUDE matches (the attested/predicted ratio, in both directions)

A word (rate in A | rate in B) ->B word (rate in A | rate in B), rates in per 10k words:

[*]    
Across these 17 pairs, the A frequencies correlate with the B frequencies: Spearman ρ = .758, permutation p = .0004, remaining significant after Holm correction across 14 comparisons (adjusted p = .0047). So the frequencies and rates do overlap, statistically. 

The main takeaway's here are that common A words map to common B words. Rare A words map to rare b forms. This is necessary but not sufficient, as to some extent this is showing how common the initial portions of words are, but just bear with me and I will address all of this. Crucially, you can also see that B versions have no A correspondence, while some A versions have a small B correspondence. 

You should also note that some expected -edy forms occur at roughly 1.65x the rate of the -chy forms, which i will also discuss below. The 2nd transformation from chy->chdy does not have this same property.


The same conditions all hold true for the chy->chdy transformation, these frequencies and rate overlaps are statistically significant, even after holm correction.

   



Alternate forms exist in both directions, where grammar permits

As i mentioned in the previous section, -edy forms occur at roughly 2x -chy. This seems problematic, until you run the operation in reverse, try to replace -edy with -chy, then examine the missing forms.

Take for example, chedy. Running this operation in reverse, produces chchy, which fails the established slot grammar in Zattera 2022.

Chedy, shedy, cheedy and sheedy collectively account for about 40% of the missing token mass, and these can be matched to corresponding A words with a single operation, d insertion
  • chedy can connect to chey by inserting d; it need not come from chchy.
  • shedy can connect to shey.
  • cheedy and sheedy can connect to cheey and sheey through d-insertion.


B has 0 tokens containing ped, fed, ded, led, red or yed. ped and fed will be discussed in the next section. Ded, led, red, and yed are excluded by Zattera’s proposed formal grammar (2022, Figure 4). How then, would dchy move from Herbal A to B? We can see that it uses d insertion, chy->chdy, and NOT the chy->edy.
  • dchy 23 → dchdy 4; no dedy.
  • opchy 6 → opchdy 3; no opedy.
  • qopchy 5 → qopchdy 3; no qopedy.
  • olchy 2 → olchdy 2

So now we have an explanation for why chy can go to either -edy or -chdy, as well as an explanation for the missing reversed forms of -edy in A. These rules appear to respect the known grammar of voynich, and attempt to avoid producing invalid words.


The transformations interact with other Voynich patterns as expected

This is where things get really interesting, and you may have already caught this in some of the examples of the previous seciton. 

In her 2022 keynote, Lisa Fagin Davis proposed what I like to refer to as 'Davis expansion', that consists of the following rules:

P and F represent abbreviated forms of ke and te. BUT no abbreviation can be used before e, and no abbreviations can be used before d.

So for example using P to abbreviate keedy is strictly forbidden. How then, might an aspiring scribe, seek to use a P form for such a word? Is there simply no way?

Let us consider one of the rules from the previous section: chy->edy 

What if we did something like keedy -> kechy -> pchy? This is now perfectly valid. In fact, P and F seem to affect the rest of the word, beyond Davis' proposed Te / Ke abbreviation, because these P/F forms appear to condition the word to use the ch over ed form. 

In general, Herbal B authors tend to prefer ed over ch, except when it comes to P and F.  So in certain contexts, the bench form appears to represent a preferred choice over edy, even for those that prefer edy.


A possible 3rd Rule

About 1/3 of the -chy tokens have no attested B form under either rule. 

The higher count of these cases are:
  • chokchy 13
  • chotchy 12
  • chochy 5
  • ychy 4,shokchy 4; dchokchy 3.
  • shtchy, shytchy, chopchy, torchy, chykchy, otorchy, {ct}chy and dpchy: 2 each.

These are fairly unique voynich words, and interestingly enough, they do have fairly obvious equivalents, involving 2 edits: changing the first o following a bench to an e, followed by one of the rules from the first section.

For example:

chokchy → chekchy → chekedy (5) or chekchdy 1.

In fact, this pathway seems to exist for virtually all of these words.
  • chokchy 13 → chekedy 5, or chekchdy 1.
  • chotchy 12 → chetedy 1, or chetchdy 1.
  • chochy 5 → cheedy 2.
  • shochy 1 → sheedy 8.
  • chopchy 2 → chepchdy 1.
  • shopchy 1 → shepchdy 1.
  • chofchy 1 → chefchdy 1.

This initial e swap, after a bench, appears to have more examples, with different suffixes, and warrants more investigation to determine its full valid grammatical context:
  • choky 19 → cheky 22.
  • chokaiin 7 → chekaiin 5.
  • chokey 3 → chekey 3.
  • chotaiin 6 → chetaiin 1.
  • shoky 2 → sheky 5.

Words without a bench, like ychy, seem to not be valid targets for this rule, and remain unexplained.

Print this item