- Options
- Login
- Desktop Style
Options
Voynich's anatomy
- Voynich's anatomy
-
RE: Voynich's anatomy
Linda > Yesterday, 04:48 PM
(Yesterday, 12:04 PM)ololololo Wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.I don't deny the lack of connection to Archimedes' screw and the coincidence. I'm not really sure if the author was trying to disguise the images of internal organs. Rather, he was making them implicit to us but clear to someone who knows what they're referring to.
In any case, I didn't notice the similarity to the Archimedes screw...
Ah ok I must have misunderstood you, I thought you had said the vms drawing was stylized as an Archemedean screw.
I sit on the fence in terms of the body parts idea. It would be interesting for it to be the case, but I see something else in it, not because it looks like something else, but because I can make sense of it in terms of the iconography and what it means to me within the quire. -
RE: Voynich's anatomy
RenegadeHealer > Yesterday, 04:49 PM
@JoJo_Jost, I remember first learning about the brain in Michelangelo’s Creazione d’Adamo when I took History of Western Art and Architecture in the late 1990s. I find it convincing. Michelangelo was an amateur anatomist and dissector, as training for his realistic portrayal of human bodies. And although this question is hotly debated by historians nowadays, I’m fairly sure a lot of people in the Middle Ages (and before) had a decently good big-picture view of what the brain did.
I later encountered this idea of God-as-brain in Michelangelo’s Creazione d’Adamo when reading about Western esoteric spirituality. The symbolism that esotericists see in this work is the idea that there is a little piece of God peering out of the eyes of every sentient being, and that the brain (the lesser mind) is like a television set receiving a signal (the greater mind). I happen to find this convincing too, for what it’s worth. But we're not here to talk about those kinds of topics.
Another anatomical similarity I’ve noticed: The You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view., and You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.. Could the plant on You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. be an herbal remedy for nasal congestion, rhinitis, or sinusitis? -
RE: Voynich's anatomy
ololololo > Yesterday, 07:18 PM
(Yesterday, 04:49 PM)RenegadeHealer Wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.@JoJo_Jost, I remember first learning about the brain in Michelangelo’s Creazione d’Adamo when I took History of Western Art and Architecture in the late 1990s. I find it convincing. Michelangelo was an amateur anatomist and dissector, as training for his realistic portrayal of human bodies. And although this question is hotly debated by historians nowadays, I’m fairly sure a lot of people in the Middle Ages (and before) had a decently good big-picture view of what the brain did.
In general, given that the plants in VMS are not particularly accurate (at least we can say this about the castor bean), and given that the human organs are indeed described in balneology, then yes, it is possible.
I later encountered this idea of God-as-brain in Michelangelo’s Creazione d’Adamo when reading about Western esoteric spirituality. The symbolism that esotericists see in this work is the idea that there is a little piece of God peering out of the eyes of every sentient being, and that the brain (the lesser mind) is like a television set receiving a signal (the greater mind). I happen to find this convincing too, for what it’s worth. But we're not here to talk about those kinds of topics.
Another anatomical similarity I’ve noticed: The You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view., and You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.. Could the plant on You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. be an herbal remedy for nasal congestion, rhinitis, or sinusitis?
Perhaps VMS is a herbalist with a focus on anatomy.
Also, as Ruby Novacna pointed out, the roots of the You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. plant are very similar to the shape of the eye... -
RE: Voynich's anatomy
JoJo_Jost > 1 hour ago
Well, unfortunately, it’s easy to read too much into things—we humans are really good at that. The root here could represent the human heart.
If there were hidden anatomical clues in plants as well, it would definitely be clear why the VMS is so heavily encoded. -
RE: Voynich's anatomy
ololololo > 1 hour ago
(1 hour ago)JoJo_Jost Wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.Well, unfortunately, it’s easy to read too much into things—we humans are really good at that. The root here could represent the human heart.
By the way, the reason we can't identify the plants accurately might be due to their stylization. The artist may have intentionally distorted them to emphasize their anatomical significance.
If there were hidden anatomical clues in plants as well, it would definitely be clear why the VMS is so heavily encoded.
But the question is, why can't we find a liverwort in VMS that resembles a human liver in shape?.. -
RE: Voynich's anatomy
JoJo_Jost > 1 hour ago
I'd be able to recognize a pancreas... with a lot (!!!) of imagination.
-
RE: Voynich's anatomy
Linda > 59 minutes ago
(1 hour ago)JoJo_Jost Wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.Well, unfortunately, it’s easy to read too much into things—we humans are really good at that. The root here could represent the human heart.
If there were hidden anatomical clues in plants as well, it would definitely be clear why the VMS is so heavily encoded.
I know you were just making a point, but I found this interesting, I think that was the banana plant you posted, and I went looking for pictures of the roots, and this was the first image that came up, they are holding a banana corm.