Why and how the text could be Bavarian

[oshfdk]

But every cipher must also have rules; that’s a circular argument that leads in the wrong direction, and by no means constitutes a counterargument. And so far, there are extremely few and general rules—far from covering every specific case with a new, specific rule. That’s the difference.

I don't think I provided a counterargument, I was talking about plausibility, which is a subjective quality. If I find the method and the set of rules implausible, it's implausible for me, no proof of this is needed. 

I'm not sure there is anything to argue about here at this stage, either this method leads to a deciphering, in which case this is huge. Or it doesn't, in which case this is just another attempt to invent a cipher that resembles Voynichese, of which there have been many.