Voynich through Phonetic Irish

[tavie]

But no one has been able to repeat your results.  

This is a problem with pretty much every solution, and we have only had a fraction of those out there on this forum.  You are doing the work for your system. 

Had you made a real breakthrough, we would be able to follow your system.  Some things might still remain unclear, but in the majority of cases, people's translations using your system would converge around a similar interpretation, and this would get easier the more your system developed.

What tends to happen with solutions is the opposite.  People find their system starts to break down, so they make tweaks...they think "ok, in this case /o/ could mean /a/" but this introduces flexibility.  And this flexibility gets increased more and more as the translation progresses. There are now choices to be made.  Your brain starts doing more of the heavy lifting, instead of the system doing it.  And the problem is that other people trying to use the system don't know how you make those choices. So they make different choices.  Or they feel they can't make a choice and stop.  

There is no reproducibility.  And without that, we cannot confirm a solution.  If we did that, we wouldn't be able to justify not doing the same for most - if not all - of the other solutions.