Voynich through Phonetic Irish

[igajkgko]

I was made fun out the gate on this forum, excuse me for having a response. I understand more of your context for doing so, but How do you expect it to get solved if some people and certain thinkers, with less time to dedicate, are not welcome?

This is unfair. While I cannot speak for others or all of the many comments, I don't think the main thrust of this thread has been to make fun of anyone. I also don't think you're not welcome. And it's OK to not have a lot of time to dedicate to this.

But it's also true that your theory - and I know that you believe otherwise - is not convincing. And conveying this and the reasons for it always risks coming across as rude, insensitive, and unwelcoming. But what is the alternative? Do you want to be lead on by false, encouraging comments? Do you want to be left alone?

Thinking is good, but gets better when it has to make contact with and become shaped by what we know about the world - or the manuscript and other translations, in this case. Community outreach is great, but while building a community around the theory that the earth is flat might be nice in some sense it's not a way of getting closer to the truth.

You said that you hoped this to be useful, and maybe it is? Just not in the way you initially hoped.