13-11-2025, 08:17 PM
(This post was last modified: 13-11-2025, 08:21 PM by Doireannjane.
Edit Reason: specifiying Native Irish Speakers, added comma
)
(13-11-2025, 07:45 PM)rikforto wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.(12-11-2025, 06:52 PM)Doireannjane wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.How would I be getting hyper specific taxonomies and logical instructions and even lyrical and clever sentences without cherry-picking if it is not linked directly to a Celtic language? Genuine question there.
I have now seen this line of argumentation, "How would I be getting a translation with relevant features if this were not the solution?", so many times that You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.. As mentioned in the post, this does not disprove your solution here, but the existence of a translation is not all that impressive---we have lots of those, and several a week. The question is how can the rest of us recreate it and does it make for convincing Irish or Korean, as the case may be.
So, what you're doing is not in good faith. It's rude. I'm not an academic or a linguistic. I make videos because they're the most accessible, for everyone including those not privileged with time or money to attend university. I was advised by Lisa Davis Fagin to post on here twice. I didn't the first time for this exact reason. People were critical after my podcast was released in a mean spirited and not at all constructive way.
I thought more of my material could have been watched when I posted this thread. My full publication has not been released and I don't want to include all of it on the forum. I'm mainly showing only what I have already made public so others can test things out.
Your example in Korean is not AT ALL connected to the script/character nor do the sentences make any sense. All my sentences do, they're depictive and the assignment of characters were based of of texts and symbols that exist and are linked to what sounds I am linking them to. I explain this thoroughly. Look at the cross symbol for "T" sound across the board of the character maps I present, for example.
Can you use my methodology and see what you produce? That's why I'm on here. This took me over a year to establish. It's not going to be immediate that someone can start translating in my methods, it takes time. There are rules and exceptions as with any language that take time to understand.
I don't see this as a competition. I'm excited about my findings and sharing them. It would be great to have them validated outside on myself and my community. It would be great to have input from native Irish speakers for unknown words and tenses that are still unclear on my end.
