Voynich Decoded

[rikforto]

I chose caper because ...
No water anywhere.

Why are you talking about water? 
Do you know of any proposals that mention water?
Yes, many think it's a water lily? water lily's are in water.....

Who am I supposed to cite?

It's just a tradition to quote your predecessors so that you can prove in the end that everyone before you was wrong.

I don't have any predecessors here, not that I'm aware of anyway, not out to prove anyone wrong, just following where this book is taking me.  You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. coming up! :-)

It would help clarify some of your decisions if you contrasted your methodology identifying the plants with the great many people who have come to different conclusions, and in doing so you would need to cite where you got the contrasts from

More broadly, you might benefit from turning away from doing more of these supposed interpretations---I don't think anyone doubts you can produce more---and instead focus on proving why we ought to accept them as valid. As of now, I don't understand the argument you are making for any of your decisions. Not, mind you, that I disagree with it, but that I cannot because I cannot ascertain how you have come to any of the conclusions you have come to in order to form any kind of useful agreement or disagreement with it. Does You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. have anything to do with semen production? Until I can explain why you think that, I am not going to be able to accept that interpretation!