Voynich Decoded

[Kris1212]

I'm not sure why you think I haven't listened to his criticism, I have and I disagree. What more can I say, if I'm wrong, I have no issue with that, none whatsoever but I won't just be told to let something be and to go back to my corner when I don't think the other person is correct. He offered to look at it for me, he did, I thanked him, I was polite, he clearly isn't happy that I want to continue on my decode path, why I'm not sure, makes no odds to him if I make myself look a fool, to none of you actually so what's the issue, not hurting any of you, just having a go and will see it through.

That's all fair enough, for sure. (I can't speak for Koen, but I can tell you that I took a little bit of offense when you implied that he had approved your solution simply because I knew that that was surely a misleading statement.)

I do understand your concern about protecting your solution (although I think you are going about it wrong). And for what it is worth, I'd be happy to look at your solution too, and give you an honest, private assessment. I just won't do it under an NDA because, having worked with IP NDA's for decades, I know it would take fair bit of time and effort to prepare one that would adequately protect both of us. You can DM me if you want to discuss that further though.

I didn't mean to imply that he had approved the decode, I just saw the good parts he had said and I knew the bad parts was because I hadn't clearly explained it, not sure why you were offended, what has it to do with you, are you married to Koen or something?...How I go about things is of no concern to you, I don't know you from Adam, and honestly you've been off with me from the start so I wouldn't want you to look at it, Koen was nice to me and that's the only reason I gave it to him but I didn't know him either hence the NDA. It didn't hurt him to sign it, it just protected me and mine in case.

---

Wouldn't it make more sense for us all to wait to discuss this for a few days until the promised information has been published?  The more we debate it now, the more time Kris1212 will have to spend on replying to our messages instead of working up a publication (and caring for rescued dogs: kudos for that).  Let's give Kris1212 some breathing room.  We'll know the details soon enough.

Thank you :-)