27-02-2024, 07:14 PM
According to Ahmet's logic, only Turkish linguists can judge the VM and claim or disclaim whether the language is actually Old Turkic. The Voynich solution is not depended on confirmation only, but also on disproving other possible theories. As long as any other theory is floating around, the Turkish team and the experts defending Turkic theory would have to convince non-Turkish Voynich experts why Turkish theory is better and why it can exclude all possible future proposals. As I understand, they are not yet determined which dialect the VM is written, or if it written in some extinct Turkish dialect. This brings me to one extinguished dialect, spoken in today's Turkey, before the Turks came from Mongolia. That was the Slavic dialect in Thessaloniki, which was so close to the Slavic language spoken in the 9th century in Pannonia and other parts of Great Moravia, that the missionaries from Thessaloniki were invited to Great Moravia to instruct the Slavs in their native language. The language subsequently called the Old Church Slavonic has been best preserved in Slovenian dialect of Prekmurje.
Since by 15th century, Turkish grammar and vocabulary was already explained in the Codex Cumanicus in the words written in Italian and German writing conventions, it would be relatively easy for the Turkish team to find some words that are spelled exactly the same in the Voynich Manuscript and in the Codex Cumanicus, possible in the same grammatical form.
They would also have to address all those grammatical and structural oddities of the VM language which were pointed out by various VM researchers.
Since by 15th century, Turkish grammar and vocabulary was already explained in the Codex Cumanicus in the words written in Italian and German writing conventions, it would be relatively easy for the Turkish team to find some words that are spelled exactly the same in the Voynich Manuscript and in the Codex Cumanicus, possible in the same grammatical form.
They would also have to address all those grammatical and structural oddities of the VM language which were pointed out by various VM researchers.


![[+]](https://www.voynich.ninja/images/collapse_collapsed.png)