20-02-2024, 03:25 PM
We are all trying to have a contructive discussion with Rustandi, but the answer (post 26) to Tavie's post (#25) shows that this is not going anywhere.
This is a typical solution attempt, which is certainly not correct.
My interest is why so many independent approaches all work (read: fail) in the same way.
Anyway, I am happy that the discussion is civil and hope it stays that way.
If Rustandi is interested in good advice, then there is already a lot of it in this thread.
Importantly:
- the translation from Voynichese to 'Latin' is not valid because lots of arbitrary additions are made. Example: the four-character word kchsy is converted to a 10-character word, meaning that more than half is arbitrary.
- the proposed Latin text is NOT Latin.
This is a typical solution attempt, which is certainly not correct.
My interest is why so many independent approaches all work (read: fail) in the same way.
Anyway, I am happy that the discussion is civil and hope it stays that way.
If Rustandi is interested in good advice, then there is already a lot of it in this thread.
Importantly:
- the translation from Voynichese to 'Latin' is not valid because lots of arbitrary additions are made. Example: the four-character word kchsy is converted to a 10-character word, meaning that more than half is arbitrary.
- the proposed Latin text is NOT Latin.


![[+]](https://www.voynich.ninja/images/collapse_collapsed.png)