Calgary engineer believes he's cracked the mysterious Voynich Manuscript

[Ahmet Ardıç]

@Ahmet
EVA and ATA are different things and cant be compared.
ATA takes a set of glyphs and assigns letters to them to form a plain text.
EVA takes a set of glyphs and gives them another name, in latin letters, so the glyphs can be reproduced easily in a different format. It is the same as writting chinese with latin letters, people dont understand chinesse pictograms but understand latin letters.
What is important is the set of ghyps, ATA uses a wide set of glyphs.

You have said too that the Voynich is not a cipher because it hasnt been solved. There are computational approaches to solve complex ciphers with homophonic-polyphonic-nulls, though these techniques are in development and the most complex of them need to be solved manually, see You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.. The Voychenese structure of bigrams-trigrams is compatible with the ciphers shown in this article, so a cipher is possible.

Dear Sali,

If a glyph is a hieroglyphic character or symbol or a pictograph, there is no any glyph in ATA abc transkription. I never compare EVA and ATA because EVA never work to read but ATA works very well to read.


You still don't understand that ATA transcription contains more Latin characters that compared to EVA. So ATA proposes more Latin alphabet symbols in the same visual format. In addition, ATA reads all syllable characters with the same single rule.

That's why you will continue paddling in the EVA boat in imaginary waters without reaching any island.

If a door is locked and you need to open it, you must use the correct key. EVA is the wrong key and no matter how hard you try you will just waste time. ATA has already opened that door, and linguists are slowly starting to get through.

So you may be one of the last hundred people to realize that you are comparing two things, one real result and the other imaginary.

Don't be in a hurry, please keep rowing. Even if you come back from the Greek islands, come to our side and have a Turkish coffee and Turkish delight.


Thanks