geoffreycaveney's Judaeo-Greek theory

[ReneZ]

I'm sorry to say, but this proposal shows all the classical signs of an incorrect solution:

- the translation table from Voynich text to plain text is vague and inconsistent
- the resulting plain text still has to be adapted in order to obtain real words
- the then resulting text is not grammatically sensible.
- the word patterns / low entropy are not explained.

One of the typical problems is that the 'translation' concentrates on the decryption part rather than on the encryption part. It is completely natural to map certain Voynich characters to different plain text characters in order to get some meaningful words out of it. However, this means that the person doing the encryption would have mapped several different plain text characters onto the same code character, which is not at all a natural thing to do.