The 'Chinese' Theory: For and Against

[rikforto]

I think the crux of the immediate disagreement we are having is that I believe if you propose a spelling system, you should be able to describe the spelling rules to a reasonable degree of accuracy while you do not. Likewise, I do not believe loose correlations between parts of a subset of paragraphs constitute a translation, let alone of the "entire" section, while you do. I will leave it to people reading this thread to judge which of us has the more convincing position