15-05-2021, 07:54 PM
(15-05-2021, 05:00 PM)geoffreycaveney wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.Yes. I believe this is a rather small number of changes to have to make in order to produce a text with as much not only meaningful and grammatical text but also moreover historically relevant text to political events in England in 1405.
I understand that you need to make changes in order to convert the Voynich text into something that you consider legible and meaningful, but I am talking here about the process that would have been followed by the composer of the text, according to your proposal.
This person would have changed:
Quote:" kirche-eek -- irour-isynge, picchynge, path-isynge -- is also accitynge tir-biri "
" siest side, lo! sis dis-lisynge "
into:
Quote:" KrcheeeK irOrisK pYcK pthisK isOsl KtisK tir iriB "
" sYOs Ydis lO sis dislisYeK "
but for no reason at all.
It can hardly have been to make it end up more Voynich-like.
This is the generic problem of all four-step solutions, that only look at the decryption of the text, and ignore what the composer would have had to do.