[Article] [split] A Proposed Mapping of the Voynich Alphabet to an Indo-European Language

[-JKP-]

I would certainly have used a different tone and approached it with different priorities if I had known it was students (we still don't know how many might have been students, since Downing's name is in line with the others, perhaps there are more adults).

But the things that need fixing/attention do not change.

There is room for improvement. I hope that is the message that gets across.


It seems rather harsh for a mentor to throw a student paper into the academia.edu cauldron without a disclaimer at the top.