19-05-2020, 08:03 PM
The more i have read from this guy, the more i like him.
As Koen and JKP say he has responded to comments with cordiality and respect and has even updated some of his writings
in response to criticisms and objections, that takes a bit of doing.
Also i like the theory and hope he comes up with something good.
And a side note; the idea of a context dependent encipherment raises some interesting ideas.
One could see a situation where the original text is in broken latin and the deciphering method contains lots of
ambiguity, then a modern day real solutiion to the VMS would be one that the original author/s would agree with and since they
are gone it would be impossible today to say definitively that one has solved it.
As Koen and JKP say he has responded to comments with cordiality and respect and has even updated some of his writings
in response to criticisms and objections, that takes a bit of doing.
Also i like the theory and hope he comes up with something good.
And a side note; the idea of a context dependent encipherment raises some interesting ideas.
One could see a situation where the original text is in broken latin and the deciphering method contains lots of
ambiguity, then a modern day real solutiion to the VMS would be one that the original author/s would agree with and since they
are gone it would be impossible today to say definitively that one has solved it.