Lament from the Sea, New Method! f2r

[-JKP-]

Umm... I don't think I implied that word order is irrelevant, I didn't change the word order at all from the list, no anagramming, they are one after the other by column then back to the start etc.  It doesn't mean anything beyond that things which are vaguely grammatical and maybe meaningful to some can be pulled out, and each will pull out a different selection. 

[deleted for brevity]

Okay, I must have misread one to get that impression, but you have started at an arbitrary point and then come round in a circle, but that implies starting anywhere, stopping anywhere and then circling around again to make it work.

There's a difference between interpreting text and shoehorning it into submission by making up your own grammatical rule (and I don't mean the poetry, I mean the starting, ending points).


Plus, there's no evidence yet that the manuscript is in English (or that it's encoded natural language).