10-11-2026, 02:23 PM
Quote:Yes, and that is a big weakness of codebook ciphers. One can guess the plaintext of several codes from their frequencies and their occurrence patterns. If a bunch of messages from planet Vulcan end with 334 673 14 812, one may guess that 334 = "live", 673 = "long", 812 = "prosper"...
And that's exactly what happened with the Rohonc Codex. There were a lot of patterns which allowed words to be assigned to their meaning.
Quote:On the other hand, codebook ciphers have the advantage that even if one cracks 90% of the codes, the remaining 10% may forever remain uncrackedAgain it is unfortunately true with the Rohonc Codex. You know there was some holy virgin and she had a vision of Christ but you just can't read her name.
The problem with VMS is that it generally lacks patterns similar to natural languages.
You don't have often repeated phrases, you don't have good candidates for the most common words like "be" or "and".
Labels don't work too, a few repeated labels don't make sense as they seem to describe a totally different stuff.
Personally I gave up with trying to break VMS as it was codebook cipher.

