09-11-2026, 03:41 PM
(09-11-2026, 02:37 PM)Jorge_Stolfi wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.It depends on how often one uses the cipher.Well, first of all, if he spent a long time working on the book and developing his own code, he could have memorized that chol means “herb,” and chal means “decoction". At the very least, he will remember the most common or useful words.
I’m not saying he’ll remember them for the rest of his life. When he finishes working on one section and moves on to another, some words might have stuck in his memory.
Second, in the context of VMS, I try not to think about the addressee. Especially in the context of the book cipher. It only spoils the picture. More on this below...
(09-11-2026, 03:09 PM)Jorge_Stolfi wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.How many -iin and -in were expected to occur in it?I don’t know, but for me, the disappearance of these characters is like the unexpected disappearance of, for example, the letter “e” in the most ordinary English text. It can’t be a coincidence if a person doesn’t have a phobia of that letter...
(09-11-2026, 03:09 PM)Jorge_Stolfi wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.One can guess the plaintext of several codes from their frequencies and their occurrence patterns.There are very few of these patterns in the text, and they are not verbal; rather, they are related to symbols. For example, r does not often follow y, or after a word ending in ol (chol, otol), daiin follows.
Overall, I don’t see a justified reason to encrypt a book using such a complex method as you did. The only rational explanation is pure enthusiasm for working on this cipher. The author could have been either an early enthusiast cryptographer or just an “eccentric” who got the idea to write a book in this way. He might have thought he had invented something really cool (perhaps he believed he was creating a magical language or something akin to steganography), or he might simply have enjoyed having a huge collection of word cards.
In the process, he could modify the cipher, since it didn’t matter to him whether someone else would be able to decipher it. He most likely didn’t even intend to show this book to anyone.
Maybe he would never have been able to decipher it himself. It would have been enough for him to simply write it down...
In that case, the plain text might not be what he wrote, but some texts from other manuscripts. The Astrology section fits this very well.
It seems to me that only this enthusiast’s hypothesis, based on a multitude of assumptions, gives the hypothesis about the book cipher a chance to exist…


