09-11-2026, 02:37 PM
(This post was last modified: 09-11-2026, 03:15 PM by Jorge_Stolfi.)
(30-10-2026, 09:45 PM)ololololo wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.The author has an advantage over the addressee — he is the creator of this cipher. Perhaps he has simply memorized the frequent word forms, and overall, the ciphertext is perceived by him more easily and quickly. The addressee, on the other hand, will have to dig through the cards and decipher the text word by word. This is where the point of inefficiency arises.It depends on how often one uses the cipher. If there are hundreds of military officers on the front sending occasional messages to one guy at headquarters, the reader is more likely to memorize the codes than the writers.
But even with frequent use one is unlikely to memorize more than a couple hundred codes for the most common words, which may account for (say) 20% of all tokens. Chinese and Japanese students learn the ~4000 characters needed to read newspapers only by the end of high school. That applies to the creator of the cipher too. With or without practice, codebook ciphers are hard to write and read.
Quote:I don't think he detected any evolution on average token length.(30-10-2026, 09:28 PM)Jorge_Stolfi wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.with an empty box, the first few cards could be...In your example, the words evolve from simple to complex and combined. It seems that @npcompl33t found some kind of word evolution, but I don’t really understand whether this can be interpreted in the context of a book cipher...
The effect would not be easy to detect. Suppose you start encoding a 50-page train timetable A for England with an empty box. There will be a few common words like "departs" and "arrives" and "express" and "class" and "hours" and "to" and "from" and "Saint" then maybe hundreds of names of stations. These would get all codes from (say) 1 to 500.
Then you move to encode a 50-page herbal B, and the most common words there are "this", "herb", "the", "take", "days", "ounces", "grows", "cures", "guaranteed", etc. The word "this", which did not occur at all in the train guide, gets code 501, instead of 5 as it would if you started with the herbal. The few new common words plus the plant and disease names take codes 501 to 1200.
Then you encode a second 50-page train timetable C for Scotland. You will find most of the tokens, especially the most common ones in that text, are already in the box, with codes 1 to 500. Only the station names will be mostly new and will get codes from 1201 to 1300.
If you analyze the code token lengths on all three encrypted texts you may notice that the averages for A, B, and C are 1.7, 2.2, and 1.9. You may wrongly conclude that they were created in the order A, C, B...
All the best, --stolfi

