29-10-2016, 07:12 PM
(This post was last modified: 30-10-2016, 01:36 AM by ThomasCoon.)
Thank you both for keeping the discussion civil 
I agree with Tom that the text does not appear to be "linguistic" in the sense that "you cannot apply a language to it in a fundamental way." There seem to be too many "okchor-chor-chol-okchy" things for a natural language.
JKP brings up a good point about other languages - if we can make this picture fit German, Latin, or another language, then this might be an issue that Tom will need to address: why can not only Welsh be found using his numerology rules, but anything we look for? I tried German and could find 75% of the astrological signs without having to use related words:
![[Image: attachment.php?aid=861]](http://www.voynich.ninja/attachment.php?aid=861)
(Yet to find: Skorpio, Stier, Fische, Wassermann)

I agree with Tom that the text does not appear to be "linguistic" in the sense that "you cannot apply a language to it in a fundamental way." There seem to be too many "okchor-chor-chol-okchy" things for a natural language.
JKP brings up a good point about other languages - if we can make this picture fit German, Latin, or another language, then this might be an issue that Tom will need to address: why can not only Welsh be found using his numerology rules, but anything we look for? I tried German and could find 75% of the astrological signs without having to use related words:
(Yet to find: Skorpio, Stier, Fische, Wassermann)


![[+]](https://www.voynich.ninja/images/collapse_collapsed.png)