Poll: What is most likely in your opinion?
You do not have permission to vote in this poll.
1
22.73%
10 22.73%
2
6.82%
3 6.82%
more than 2
45.45%
20 45.45%
I don't know anything about this and am happy to follow majority/expert opinion.
25.00%
11 25.00%
Total 44 vote(s) 100%
* You voted for this item. [Show Results]

How many people penned the main Voynichese text?
#30
(29-11-2025, 06:08 PM)Koen G wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.It's interesting that by some opinions being expressed more vocally than others, one can get a warped view on the situation.

This is an interesting observation, probably not just in regard to this particular question, but also (Voynich) research in general. There is just no need to be vocal about your opinion if it is basically being open to both the standard theory and the latest research.

I went with option 3, more than two, for three reasons: Firstly, while I have not researched this question in detail myself, I find Lisa Fagin Davis' arguments compelling, even more so since the latest developments suggesting that the manuscript was not bound as a book originally. This makes a group project seem much more likely as well in my opinion. 
Secondly, as soon as we assume two people were involved, there has to have been a moment of teaching or shared creation when knowledge of the script (or knowledge of the generation of convincing gibberish) was passed on. If this is the case, why stop at two? Of course, the VMS might have been the work of a married couple, of a father-son duo, coincidentally two people of a larger group which had originally developed the glyphs etc. However, most monastic, scholarly etc. contexts offer no particular argument for exactly two people.
Thirdly, while I would not rule out the idea that some 'hands' are just different phases in the life of the same person, I find this idea hard to match with several aspects of the manuscript and its probable practices of creation such as the relationship between illustrations and 'text'.
[+] 1 user says Thank You to N._N. for this post
Reply


Messages In This Thread
RE: How many people penned the main Voynichese text? - by N._N. - 02-12-2025, 07:32 AM

Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  secretary hand and similarities with voynichese text dejiko 1 1,288 28-04-2026, 11:12 AM
Last Post: oshfdk
  Voynichese text-image layout in other plant manuscripts Koen G 14 18,312 07-11-2023, 02:06 PM
Last Post: Juan_Sali
  Where are the letters penned by Voynich? stellar 22 27,153 08-10-2016, 06:56 PM
Last Post: R. Sale

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)