Should we have a thread to refer theorists to?

[Pepper]

The bingo card is so accurate but I would feel bad directing any excited theorist to it (except, maybe, Gerard Cheshire...) 

I do like the idea of a list of common problems with theories that we can refer to, e.g. "It looks like items 2, 5, and 6 apply to your theory. You'll need to be able to explain why these don't apply to gain widespread acceptance of your theory." A bit like Edmund Landau's response to Fermat's Last Theorem.