Not sure of a definition. Maybe something is a solution if:
1. It offers an explanation for the text and
2. The author appears to believe in it (rather than just testing something)
In a way, becoming more aware of what solutions are typically like may also assist us in the next crisis of Cheshirian proportions. I've also referenced Tavi's list in several of my videos. If the solvers are beyond salvation, at least others may still benefit.
1. It offers an explanation for the text and
2. The author appears to believe in it (rather than just testing something)
(30-04-2025, 08:34 PM)ReneZ wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.I am not aware that any 'Voynich solution proposer' has ever been successfully dissuaded from going ahead and showing it.
This may therefore be more of a theoretical discussion.
In a way, becoming more aware of what solutions are typically like may also assist us in the next crisis of Cheshirian proportions. I've also referenced Tavi's list in several of my videos. If the solvers are beyond salvation, at least others may still benefit.