In my opinion, it's perfectly fine to present any kind of “ complete solution” as long as it's done in a separate thread; scattering them across multiple threads without any recognizable context can be annoying.
Which and to what extent publications written by “veterans” are read through is up to you. Again, anyone who thinks they have found a solution for the VMS “from scratch” should be allowed to present it. However, in this case it is also permissible to point out the usual stumbling blocks in the development of a solution for the supposed solver. This has nothing to do with “I know better anyway”. The reason why newcomers who directly offer a solution often do not lead to meaningful discussions is that any criticism is simply ignored. It often seems to be all about getting unconditional confirmation. With such an approach, there is only one thing to do: move on.
Which and to what extent publications written by “veterans” are read through is up to you. Again, anyone who thinks they have found a solution for the VMS “from scratch” should be allowed to present it. However, in this case it is also permissible to point out the usual stumbling blocks in the development of a solution for the supposed solver. This has nothing to do with “I know better anyway”. The reason why newcomers who directly offer a solution often do not lead to meaningful discussions is that any criticism is simply ignored. It often seems to be all about getting unconditional confirmation. With such an approach, there is only one thing to do: move on.