Generally about proposed solutions

[ReneZ]

I think that there is another aspect to the Voynich MS.

It's 'unsolvability' is famous, and so is the statement (fact) that not a word of it has been translated with any certainty.

So, as soon as one 'sees' something promising, or gets a feeling that one can understand part of it, one may be overcome with excitement. Otherwise completely reasonable people could lose most of their capability of critical thinking.