29-11-2024, 05:13 PM
Hi Rich,
Well, I disagree with your assessment of Panofsky's statement. Why would he make an effort to "explain" the MS as late as possible, if it weren't for the Sunflower's shadow? He clearly felt the need to respect this assessment.
Regarding the opinion of botanists, I understand that my opinion there is a bit stronger than most. If one botanist is not the right person to consult about stylized medieval iconography, then seven botanists aren't either.
Well, I disagree with your assessment of Panofsky's statement. Why would he make an effort to "explain" the MS as late as possible, if it weren't for the Sunflower's shadow? He clearly felt the need to respect this assessment.
Regarding the opinion of botanists, I understand that my opinion there is a bit stronger than most. If one botanist is not the right person to consult about stylized medieval iconography, then seven botanists aren't either.


![[+]](https://www.voynich.ninja/images/collapse_collapsed.png)