Logic issues

[ReneZ]

This thread is appreciated however i fear it will be forever You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.

I do appreciate that it is unlikely to make any difference anywhere, but still the very simple lemon/banana comparison can be used to illustrate some things, for example about asking the right questions.

Arguments like: "it is yellow", "it is an edible fruit",  'it is pointy at both ends", do not help to distinguish between the two. In another thread I was asked to answer a list of exactly this type of questions.

For this simple case it is possible to come up with some right questions (even where there are lots of very unusual types of bananas). For the arguments related to the Voynich MS it is rarely that simple.