Lament from the Sea, New Method! f2r

[ThomasCoon]

Jkp and Coon,

Go ahead an dispute as much as you can about my findings; yet I'm coming from a logical premise where numbers are associated to words from the VMS imagery.  The letters that are substituted have weight as any cipher, although the Author would have had a great memory or he could read his own script.  I don't know how the Author reconciled his understanding of his own cipher to be honest.  Maybe he just wished to put all his findings into something that he thought would never be discovered.

I think JKP pointed out something important: there are many features of the text that don't seem to be explained by the gematria hypothesis alone, such as the very rigid order of letters within words or lines. Any theory that attempts to explain the VMS will need to account for this feature of the text, and all the others: the low entropy, the scarcity of 2- or 3-vord phrases, etc. Why don't you start with those things as a launching point?

Also as an aside, I hope you don't think we disagree with you just for the sake of disagreeing. I apologize if that seems the case.