28-04-2025, 02:27 PM
Let's search for suitable Latin word pairs Vodar and Umydain (if any).
The Voynich Ninja
›
Voynich Research
›
Imagery
Origin of the Shield Shape in the Solar Folio of the f85-86 Foldout
Origin of the Shield Shape in the Solar Folio of the f85-86 Foldout
|
Origin of the Shield Shape in the Solar Folio of the f85-86 Foldout
|
 Member details
Posts: 370 Threads: 23 Thanks Received: 62 in 49 posts Thanks Given: 43 Joined: Jan 2025 Reputation: 0 Location: Thailand Member details
Posts: 370 Threads: 23 Thanks Received: 62 in 49 posts Thanks Given: 43 Joined: Jan 2025 Reputation: 0 Location: Thailand
From You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. (assuming that o is 'o'):
 Member details
Posts: 10,542 Threads: 432 Thanks Received: 4,938 in 2,813 posts Thanks Given: 4878 Joined: Mar 2016 Reputation: 11 Country: 
28-04-2025, 04:03 PM
Ah but if you assume EVA-o is o, then why isn't EVA-d s or d? And EVA-a, a? And EVA-r, r? They all have similar counterparts in regular Latin texts, just like o does.
So then we're looking at vodar or vosar. That in turn would imply that you now discovered readings for several glyphs. Then you'll end up on Tavi's list and we have to explain why the theory doesn't work. (An admittedly dramatic way of saying: why assume o is o?) Member details
Posts: 1,188 Threads: 14 Thanks Received: 178 in 147 posts Thanks Given: 331 Joined: Sep 2016 Reputation: 0 Country: 
28-04-2025, 05:12 PM
(28-04-2025, 02:27 PM)Dobri wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.Let's search for suitable Latin word pairs Vodar and Umydain (if any). We can also consider the initial "Um" to represent an entire word. By searching in Cappelli: ![[Image: 4787.jpg]](https://www.adfontes.uzh.ch/cappelli/img_abbr/4787.jpg) verum, - virum, - vestrum![[Image: 4788.jpg]](https://www.adfontes.uzh.ch/cappelli/img_abbr/4788.jpg) utrum, - unum, - verbum
Member details
Posts: 370 Threads: 23 Thanks Received: 62 in 49 posts Thanks Given: 43 Joined: Jan 2025 Reputation: 0 Location: Thailand
28-04-2025, 07:59 PM
Member details
Posts: 370 Threads: 23 Thanks Received: 62 in 49 posts Thanks Given: 43 Joined: Jan 2025 Reputation: 0 Location: Thailand (28-04-2025, 05:12 PM)Ruby Novacna wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.We can also consider the initial "Um" to represent an entire word.It is a possibility indeed and ydain could be a distinct vord in <1r.9>, because ydain occurs as a distinct vord also in <13v.8>, <14v.1>, <16r.8>, <33v.1>, and <75r.20> but not as a paragraph starter. However, on the remaining 2-out-of-8 occasions ydain occurs in the first vord in each one of the two paragraphs in You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. and has k as a prefix: kydainy in <2r.1>, and kydain in <2r.8>. What if k is 'Um'? Food for thought: If the Beneventan approach is a part of the cipher design, then all gallows could possibly be ligatures of two letters. Member details
Posts: 370 Threads: 23 Thanks Received: 62 in 49 posts Thanks Given: 43 Joined: Jan 2025 Reputation: 0 Location: Thailand
28-04-2025, 10:05 PM
Member details
Posts: 370 Threads: 23 Thanks Received: 62 in 49 posts Thanks Given: 43 Joined: Jan 2025 Reputation: 0 Location: Thailand
28-04-2025, 10:29 PM
Member details
Posts: 370 Threads: 23 Thanks Received: 62 in 49 posts Thanks Given: 43 Joined: Jan 2025 Reputation: 0 Location: Thailand
28-04-2025, 10:36 PM
One major difference between the cipher manuscript and Beneventan scripts is the lack of punctuation marks in the cipher manuscript.
 Member details
Posts: 2,241 Threads: 23 Thanks Received: 1,680 in 1,029 posts Thanks Given: 2477 Joined: Oct 2017 Reputation: 5 Country: 
Are you going to put Beneventan in every sentence describing generic medieval Latin? The abbreviations are generic too, not Beneventan.
|
|
« Next Oldest | Next Newest »
|
![[+]](https://www.voynich.ninja/images/collapse_collapsed.png)
Users browsing this thread: 6 Guest(s)