Having juxtaposed the frequency table of v101 glyphs with the frequency tables of selected medieval European languages, and having first grouped the glyphs into probable vowels and probable consonants on the basis of the Sukhotin algorithm, I randomly selected a page from the v101 transliteration for a test mapping.
For this test, I used page f029v as a source document, and again tried medieval Italian (as per the OVI corpus) as the destination language.
This experiment again did not yield recognisable words. With f029v, the first two lines:
• hoom #oy 1ck19 oe aes 29k19 ǩ9#9 1o 29 8am / ④k1cam s 1oe 1oe ǩ9 1c9 ǩoe8 9k1oy 8ay9
mapped to:
• TEEC #ES NODNA ER IRG MADNA QUA#A NE MA LIC / UDNOIC G NER NER QUA NOA QUERL ADNES LISA.
(In this example, the v101 glyph # was too rare to have any equivalent letter in Italian.)
The Sukhotin algorithm certainly imposes more discipline on the mapping, in the sense that in the mapped “words”, vowels alternative with consonants more often than not (which was Sukhotin’s crucial insight). Consequently, the mapped “words” are generally pronounceable. However, with a few exceptions, they are not Italian words.
The next step was to incorporate Prescott Currier’s seminal insight that, if the Voynich manuscript has natural languages as precursors, it has more than one. I started therefore with Currier’s division of the Voynich pages into Language A and Language B (recognising that Currier did not attempt to assign a language to every page in the manuscript).
With the v101 transliteration, the Sukhotin algorithm (as implemented by Dr Mans Hulden’s Python code) identifies the following v101 glyphs as the most probable vowels (in each case, in descending order of probability):
• Language A: o, a, 9, ④, c, A
• Language B: c, a, o, 9, ④, C
This dichotomy yields another juxtaposition of frequency tables, in which the A pages have a different frequency distribution from the B pages, as follows:
Consequently, given any selected precursor language, the glyphs will map differently from A pages than from B pages.
I am working on a series of experiments with A and B mappings, on which I will report in another post.