12-12-2016, 10:44 PM
(12-12-2016, 08:52 PM)Davidsch wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.I've read you paper quite rapidly and it was a nice read.
Thanks David for your response. Did you find it nice (only) or also convincing?
not much time , so a quick reply only:
yellow as indicator of fire, or salt?
I made the suggestion in 2014 on fire (the element) being part of the Rosette folio - have a look at the previous paper. Inflaming the air I think is a good comparison. Not just the colour but also the form (to me) looks like a flame.
Salt, as you mention, is interesting, because there is yellow in the bottom left sphere in the Rosette folio. THis bottom right sphere I believe to represent book 4 of Meteorologica (I took that out for brevity in the essay) with the generation of metals and salts subterraneously located...Yellow for sulfur anyone?
5+1 (number of pipes): Again, as I said in the essay at that stage where I mentioned it, I omitted it for brevity. One of the six phenomena (Thunder, lightning, hurricane, thunderbolt, whirlwind and firewind) is dominant. Will provide the full quote later.
Block paradigm: As I tried to explain, I think I used this method in a special use case, maybe I should have labelled it differently (e.g. network paradigm?) I split the imagery into micro images and matched these to text (a single one in this case) and tried to analyse if I can see any network like structures deducible from the image and text relationship.
Cappadocia was introduced by Diane (as the essay cites properly and states correctly). I also believe, that if rock formations are the appropriate ID, then others (I mentioned the Italian dolomites in the essay) could be possible too.
Original Greek text source: Not sure what you mean by original: The screenshot is based on the ebook version of (5). Or do you mean the original by Aristotle? That, I believe is not available.
Will have a proper look at your other material/comments later in the week. I suggested back then a comparison between classical Elements versus physical Elements ("matter" - essay You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.). My refinement now consequently refers to these as 'exhalations' (dry and wet and the mixtures of these, ascending towards the kapnosphere, where there is a big difference between wet/dry).
NB: What do you make of the turbo/whirlwind comparison with R. Fludd (Cosmic Meteorology) with the Rosette text spiral?