The following warnings occurred:
Warning [2] Undefined variable $can_link - Line: 6 - File: showthread.php(1658) : eval()'d code PHP 8.5.12 (Linux)
File Line Function
/inc/class_error.php 157 errorHandler->error
/showthread.php(1658) : eval()'d code 6 errorHandler->error_callback
/showthread.php 1658 eval




Circular text in the Voynich: does the writing actually form a loop?
#19
(18-11-2026, 06:40 AM)Linda wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.
(17-11-2026, 08:28 AM)Voynich1234 wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.The comparison with the Rosettes is interesting, especially the similarities you've noticed between the figures and the central elements.
One thing I've been looking at is how certain patterns recur across different parts of the manuscript, not only in the drawings, but also in the text, colours and the way elements are arranged and connected.
This brings me back to the question of loops. A repeated pattern isn't necessarily a closed loop, and a circular text doesn't necessarily have to be read continuously. But there may be recurring relationships between elements that are worth examining.
That's why I find the Rosettes particularly interesting. With their multiple connected regions, they may help us understand how some of these patterns relate to the manuscript as a whole, rather than just to individual pages.

I think the other parts are connected too, in various ways. Like closets in a home. 

Loops are found in a lot of places, like the movements of the planets, albeit it seems they leave room for changes also by in fact being spirals, since the sun moves too. Babies are born every day, all over the world, they grow into children, then youths and adults who have babies, grandparents who have grandchildren...the grandparents were once babies too, and connect with the younger generations in various ways.

I feel like great lengths of time are being discussed. I think the nymphs are various representations of inhabitants of their various vicinities over time, as in, all who ever lived there. I feel like the zodiac month names are inappropriate additions as they seem to discuss ages of travel through the galaxy, not horoscopes. 

I see traces of Hecateus' work in quire 13, who thought he knew his lineage to the gods in 16 generations, and told this to the Egyptians upon meeting them. They showed him 345 statues of the lineage of fathers and sons who ruled Egypt until that point, all mortal. This made Hecateus realize that his lineage might be fabricated. It has been about 100 generations since then...and that is only what we have been able to count and remember, there had to be eons of previous generations, just within our own species, and what were we before that? Another cycle, built up in our DNA, little fragments of information still exist. Anaximander's humans came from fish mouths, I think that might be touched upon also on f79v.

The Rosettes seem to me also to speak of geography, multiple ways to get to places, that affect each other through trade!

When I think of the writing forming a loop, I think of the song that never ends...yes it goes on and on my friends... I feel like this compendium was put together to ensure that it does go on, by including some of these cycles of history, and knowledge, including the plants that seem both to nourish the body and the world, by keeping it together with their roots during times of flooding. More loops, the seasons, the various growing cycles of other life on Earth. The ambiguity of it all means anything is fodder for the cycles of discussion. The various words that could exist on the pages, if any are there. It makes us look up things, learning along the way, and imparting what we've learned to the rest. We reiterate the ones that stand out the most, we discuss the validity of the rest, someone new joins in, rediscovering a topic that has come up many times over the past century and will for many years to come. 

The cycles continue...

I think you make an interesting point about cycles in nature and over long periods of time. The Moon, the seasons and other natural processes all involve recurring patterns, often with changes from one cycle to the next.
I've been looking at different kinds of repetition and connections within the manuscript itself, in the text, illustrations, colours and the arrangement of elements across pages.
What interests me is the possibility that these internal patterns might also have structural parallels in systems outside the manuscript. That doesn't necessarily mean they represent a particular natural process, but I think the comparison is worth exploring.
The Rosettes are particularly interesting to me in this context, because of the way their different regions and connecting paths are organized. They may be relevant not only to relationships within the manuscript, but also to how we approach possible external parallels.
So for me, the question of loops goes beyond whether a circular line of text returns to its starting point. It also raises the question of how different recurring structures might relate to one another, both within the manuscript and potentially beyond it.
Reply


Messages In This Thread
RE: Circular text in the Voynich: does the writing actually form a loop? - by Voynich1234 - 18-11-2026, 09:40 AM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)