1 hour ago
(2 hours ago)oshfdk wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.(2 hours ago)Brouk Pytlík wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.I concede that this might have been prepared for a different binding, though I am not entirely certain—why, then, are only 20 of these quire marks available for the new binding? And why were the original “Q” marks not used? As for the original marks, why are they not uniform (some feature “q,” others “m,” and still others “n”)? Is this an error on the part of the person who created these marks, or is there some other intention behind it? And which quire marks, then, belong to the original binding?
I'm not sure what you mean by "different binding". Rebinding a manuscript generally preserves the order of the quires and the folios.
The only non-uniform marks are quire 19 and 20, I think the rest just spell the quire number in Latin. 1-mus, 2-us, 8-vus. What you call 'q' is probably medieval 4 (l), and -us is contracted to y
Thank you; that is a very interesting explanation. I have re-examined the possible reading of these marks, and it seems consistent with what we see.
However, this raises an interesting question. If the majority of these quire marks are indeed abbreviated Latin ordinal numbers rather than distinct symbols, would it be reasonable to infer that the person who added them was working within a Latin scribal tradition?
Furthermore, if these marks were original to the manuscript rather than later additions, would it then be reasonable to suggest that the manuscript was organized or bound within a Latin cultural environment?
I am not arguing that this must necessarily be the case. I am simply wondering whether such a conclusion would logically follow from your interpretation.

