16-11-2026, 02:03 PM
(15-11-2026, 09:39 PM)Jorge_Stolfi wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.(15-11-2026, 11:12 AM)Voynich1234 wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.I've been looking at the circular writing in the Voynich manuscript ... Are there particular folios where you think the writing forms a continuous loop, rather than simply following the shape of the diagram?I am not aware of any evidence or argument supporting the theory that the texts are a continuous loop, like a miniature You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.. Pointing the other way, there is common sense (why use a loop sentence, how hard is it to write one) and several bits of evidence:So maybe the rings that lack those gaps are continuous loops. But if we admit that some rings have beginning and end, why should we consider the possibility that some don't?
- On You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. there is a circular frame around the diagram with three rings of text. All three rings have a wide gap at about 11:00. Suggesting that each ring begins and ends there. Possibly the three rings are to be read as a three-line parag.
- On f70r2 the frame has four rings of text. The two outer ones also have aligned breaks at 11:00 with a double radial line in that gap. That gap too seems to be the starting point for both rings.
- On f86v4 the four rings of text have two noticeable set of aligned gaps: at 09:00 and at 12:30. They suggest that the four quarter-rings from 09:00 to 12:30 are one four-line parag, and the other four three-quater-rings from 12:30 to 09:00 are another parag.
All the best, --stolfi
Thanks, Jorge. Your examples make a good case for the rings having actual beginnings and endings, rather than being continuous reading loops.
I think there's another distinction worth considering here. The text may have a beginning and an end, while the diagram itself still has a circular or interconnected structure. Those are two different things.
What interests me is whether the breaks in the text correspond to particular features of the diagram, and whether the text around those boundaries shows any consistent positional behaviour.
So I wouldn't necessarily expect a circular diagram to contain a circular reading sequence. The relationship between the textual boundaries and the visual structure may be more interesting than the idea of an endlessly looping sentence.

