@ You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.
Nice work!
---
As I've said before, if you look at the structure as a table, you can clearly see that this table structure “evolves.” And that would be typical of a cipher that evolves as it is written—in this case, additional table cells are added because the existing ones are obviously insufficient. Chol’s problem, on the other hand, shows that there was an issue there—perhaps with the back-translation—it was adjusted, and then resurfaced, likely to generate further variety.
So I see it similarly: there is a development.
[And I could even imagine that the entire VMS is a kind of feasibility study for this cipher—and that it consists of several forms that were simply recorded on poor-quality vellum during its development. But of course, that’s just another unverifiable theory
.]
Nice work!
---
As I've said before, if you look at the structure as a table, you can clearly see that this table structure “evolves.” And that would be typical of a cipher that evolves as it is written—in this case, additional table cells are added because the existing ones are obviously insufficient. Chol’s problem, on the other hand, shows that there was an issue there—perhaps with the back-translation—it was adjusted, and then resurfaced, likely to generate further variety.
So I see it similarly: there is a development.
[And I could even imagine that the entire VMS is a kind of feasibility study for this cipher—and that it consists of several forms that were simply recorded on poor-quality vellum during its development. But of course, that’s just another unverifiable theory
.]