02-07-2026, 03:55 PM
@ MarcoP
In my opinion, this system cannot be explained as a language phenomenon at the token or word level. But this peculiarity is yet another clear indication that the VMS is not based on substitution or even a simple abbreviation system—especially in languages like Latin, Italian, German, and other European languages of the time. Without a more complex cipher, this cannot be explained.
Probably not in Chinese either, but I’m not familiar enough with it....
I have maybe a logical explanation, but I’m not allowed to write about it here
I hope to post the explanation in my thread in the next few days.
-----
But there’s another piece of “evidence” that, for example, t and k aren’t interchangeable:
k before aiin (20.6 percent) (n=810)
t before aiin (9.0 percent) (n=356)
k before ain (38.1 percent) (n=645)
t before ain (12.4 percent) (n=210)
"t" seems to occur significantly less frequently with the “aiin” family than "k". "t" is more likely to appear with ‘o’ and "ch."
Have Fun
Jost
In my opinion, this system cannot be explained as a language phenomenon at the token or word level. But this peculiarity is yet another clear indication that the VMS is not based on substitution or even a simple abbreviation system—especially in languages like Latin, Italian, German, and other European languages of the time. Without a more complex cipher, this cannot be explained.
Probably not in Chinese either, but I’m not familiar enough with it....
I have maybe a logical explanation, but I’m not allowed to write about it here
I hope to post the explanation in my thread in the next few days. -----
But there’s another piece of “evidence” that, for example, t and k aren’t interchangeable:
k before aiin (20.6 percent) (n=810)
t before aiin (9.0 percent) (n=356)
k before ain (38.1 percent) (n=645)
t before ain (12.4 percent) (n=210)
"t" seems to occur significantly less frequently with the “aiin” family than "k". "t" is more likely to appear with ‘o’ and "ch."
Have Fun
Jost


![[+]](https://www.voynich.ninja/images/collapse_collapsed.png)