14-02-2026, 08:27 PM
Hi Mr Tavie, It's a pleasure!
I understand the policy against 'AI slop' and I respect the need to keep the forum clean of generative nonsense. I’ve seen the subforum and I get the fatigue.
However, I completely disagree with your conclusion regarding my posts. The hypothesis I am putting forward, that the text is physically constrained by a state dependent mechanism, is the exact opposite of an 'AI hallucination.'
It is empirically deterministic. An AI hallucinates when it invents facts. What I am describing the mechanical constraints of a volvelle. You don't need a chatbot to verify it. You don't even need a computer. You just need a pen and a piece of paper. I invite you to actually check the logic yourself. If the output depends on the previous state, a volvelle is a valid physical explanation.
In any case, I wasn't trying to cause trouble, just to start a discussion.
I understand the policy against 'AI slop' and I respect the need to keep the forum clean of generative nonsense. I’ve seen the subforum and I get the fatigue.
However, I completely disagree with your conclusion regarding my posts. The hypothesis I am putting forward, that the text is physically constrained by a state dependent mechanism, is the exact opposite of an 'AI hallucination.'
It is empirically deterministic. An AI hallucinates when it invents facts. What I am describing the mechanical constraints of a volvelle. You don't need a chatbot to verify it. You don't even need a computer. You just need a pen and a piece of paper. I invite you to actually check the logic yourself. If the output depends on the previous state, a volvelle is a valid physical explanation.
In any case, I wasn't trying to cause trouble, just to start a discussion.


![[+]](https://www.voynich.ninja/images/collapse_collapsed.png)