In Support of Guido Pérez's Suggestion

[dashstofsk]

Orphaned reference list, one of the references doesn't exist. The whole thing is illegible

It might just be that he is a newcomer to writing academic papers, and might just be in need of constructive advice. Aren't you being a bit too hard on him?

I doubt he understands it himself.

I don't see this. He knows about Jaccard Similarity, and enough to generate and present a table of continuity statistics by codicological section.

I also believe he is correct when he wrote "any viable account of MS 408 must therefore explain not only token statistics, but the observed structural independence between diagrammatic units." He highlighted this statement as being particularly significant.