Switch System

[dashstofsk]

The argument for gibberish is basically that the repetitive voynich text lies closer to the low-entropy end

Strictly, the dictionary definition of "gibberish" is a adjective referring to speech or talk. The word doesn't seem to be a good one to use when discussing the VMS. Different people here seem to have different understanding what it ought to mean. For the text of the VMS I prefer to use the phrase "an artificial construction fabricated to give the semblance of genuineness".

this whole thing is much too structured to call it meaningless

If Koen was objecting to me using the term "meaningless" then let me explain that I was using that word to indicate that the manuscript was an artificial construction, untranslatable, undecypherable and that therefore the text would have no message or comprehensible substance. Meaningless in that sense.