It is unfortunately a fact that providing more details makes any proposal more susceptible to criticism.
This is just a generic statement, and it is a problem for cases where proposals and their evaluation are important.
In such cases, a minimum of detail will be required, and proposals can be rejected for failing to do that.
When moving (back) into the area of Voynich MS theory proposals, I regularly suspect that some proposals are deliberately kept vague (or completely unknown) just to avoid such criticism.
This last point clearly does not apply to Mark.
This is just a generic statement, and it is a problem for cases where proposals and their evaluation are important.
In such cases, a minimum of detail will be required, and proposals can be rejected for failing to do that.
When moving (back) into the area of Voynich MS theory proposals, I regularly suspect that some proposals are deliberately kept vague (or completely unknown) just to avoid such criticism.
This last point clearly does not apply to Mark.