23-11-2024, 04:34 PM
What I'm saying is that the amount of detail, whether it be great or small, it not necessarily the best metric to judge a theory by. A better question (to which I do not know the answer) is how we can talk about the imagery without too much speculation. Your argument appears to be that a theory becomes stronger if it explains more details, but I would argue that it's too easy to make details fit into one's theory. It all depends on how much speculating and nudging is allowed. If quantity is a reflection of how hard one speculated, the only thing it does is make the theorist more convinced of their own theory.
It would probably be possible to make ChatGPT explain all the details in the rosettes page within a medieval context.
It would probably be possible to make ChatGPT explain all the details in the rosettes page within a medieval context.

