08-12-2023, 01:28 PM
I have little experience in writing articles, and with this unusual method of decoding and desk rejection today, I don't think that it will be in the scope of any journal (I have sent it mainly to the journals in the subjects of cryptology and linguistics). Now I sent again to a journal in the field of linguistics.
Regarding the decoding method, I tried blog, website and even writing book. I sent the book to the best professors of dialectology and computational linguistics, they said it was a creative method and gave their comments, same time stating they can't judge exactly for the method used which they are not familiar with.
For this new article (its preprint without supplementary materials is at You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.), I have increased the samples and included a dictionary for Voynich, which is for evaluation of the method explained years ago. It can be said that it is more like a game, fun and sharing the results step by step, but on the other hand, an attempt to answer the critics who easily said that it is a nonsense method, which made me try harder to prove it. A fighting spirit.
Those 99 pages are practically methods, modification on twenty paragraphs, because you can't just write and expect them to be able to repeat the work that was done in three months.
Regarding the decoding method, I tried blog, website and even writing book. I sent the book to the best professors of dialectology and computational linguistics, they said it was a creative method and gave their comments, same time stating they can't judge exactly for the method used which they are not familiar with.
For this new article (its preprint without supplementary materials is at You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.), I have increased the samples and included a dictionary for Voynich, which is for evaluation of the method explained years ago. It can be said that it is more like a game, fun and sharing the results step by step, but on the other hand, an attempt to answer the critics who easily said that it is a nonsense method, which made me try harder to prove it. A fighting spirit.
Those 99 pages are practically methods, modification on twenty paragraphs, because you can't just write and expect them to be able to repeat the work that was done in three months.