Morten St George Theory

[ReneZ]

I wonder if I may be allowed to be a bit off-topic in this thread.

JP, A hundred years of research (fact seeking) has failed to resolve the mysteries of the VMS. A little bit of imagination may be just what is required to make some progress

I am more used to seeing a similar statement: "statistics haven't solved the Voynich MS", implying that statistics are not useful, can be ignored, or whatever.

However, this is a wonderful example of a non-sequitur.
The Voynich MS mystery has not been solved. Period.
Necessarily this means that it has not been solved by *any* method.

This would imply that *all* methods are useless.
Not just statistics, or fact-seeking, but everything.

Also interestingly, I daresay that:

A hundred years of plentiful and unbounded imagination has failed to resolve the mysteries of the Voynich MS.