Morten St George Theory

[-JKP-]

No, I didn't say it wasn't helpful. I said you shouldn't decide whether it's important or not until you have researched it. You obviously hadn't researched it and yet you made pre-judgments about how useful it might be.

Just research and stop trying to second-guess the data. The data will lead you in the right direction. It doesn't work very well the other way around, trying to construct the past out of your imagination as a substitute for  seeking out facts.

JP, A hundred years of research (fact seeking) has failed to resolve the mysteries of the VMS. A little bit of imagination may be just what is required to make some progress.

To further clarify: the data we need is not available. No amount of research will ever find it because it was destroyed by the Inquisition in the 13th century. We must therefore try to make sense of what the VMS shows us and in that regard a little imagination might prove helpful.

It really doesn't matter what I say...

Having a theory is more "glamorous" than doing research.

Inventing things is more fun that seeking facts that may be hard to find.

Pretending that all the information was destroyed in the Inquisition is something you made up to justify avoidance of the less-fun nitty-gritty nose-to-the-ground research.

You are seeking ONLY those bits of information that confirm your bias. You don't care about facts because they aren't fun as fiction. I get it now.